Live data from Hacker News

Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them

road.cc

351–360 of 456 posts

Re: Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them

#351
post #312
post #224

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bike lanes on a curb are significantly more dangerous due to turning car drivers often not seeing them (due to parked cars in the way) or interpreting them as “just a sidewalk” and not properly looking for cyclists.

Not a real problem, as proven by many countries where cycling is encouraged and supported

I bike in Chicago and curbed bike lanes recently installed are a big problem

Re: Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them

#352

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Humans are flawed and need punishment to correct their behaviour. Waymos are autonomous and can have their behaviour corrected with a software update. These are not the same.

It can't be so uneven. The other drivers will react irrationally if only a few cars obey those rules. Try doing your own drop offs in the car lane, when there's a bike late there, with traffic behind you. They'll often react dangerously.

Dang maybe they shouldn’t be allowed to drive then

Re: Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them

#353

Cities that want to keep cars out of bike lanes should keep all cars out of them, autonomous or not, by ticketing them. But they don't, so taxis and delivery drivers stop in them. That's traffic enforcement's fault. Given that human drivers stop in bike lanes, Waymo then has a tradeoff: 1) Be the only ones to follow the letter of the law, break a lot of people's expectations, and catch backlash for disrupting traffic…

Share the road. It works both ways.

It’s a bike lane not a road. It’s mine as a cyclist gtfo.

Re: Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them

#354

Cities that want to keep cars out of bike lanes should keep all cars out of them, autonomous or not, by ticketing them. But they don't, so taxis and delivery drivers stop in them. That's traffic enforcement's fault. Given that human drivers stop in bike lanes, Waymo then has a tradeoff: 1) Be the only ones to follow the letter of the law, break a lot of people's expectations, and catch backlash for disrupting traffic…

I agree with you in priniciple but cities no longer have the money to enforce this and everyone knows it. What they do have is the ability to demand that Waymo give them video of every stop and use AI to detect if it obeyed the laws. I've had waymo drop me off in dangerous no-stopping zones with red painted curbs. I've had waymo pick wait for me to get in blocking apartment complex garage entrances. I've seen waymo p…

Witting tickets is revenue positive, “they don’t have the money” doesn’t make any sense

Re: Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them

#355
post #253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Drivers generally follow the rules. It's considered bad form when they don't, and they're occasionally ticketed. This doesn't apply to bikers. No one even expects them to follow the rules. I'm not anti-bike. I bike a bit and I got hit by a car last year. Some crackhead turned left across the opposite lane right into me. I'm just reporting what I see -- bikers do not generally follow the rules, and I find this interes…

> Drivers generally follow the rules. No, they don't. They break the rules all the goddamn time. Have you ever been on an American freeway? Most people are going above the speed limit, myself included. Do you think most drivers give the legally required amount of space in front of their car while driving, especially on the freeway? It's not even close. Do people signal for the legally required amount of time before c…

I bike for 90% of my traveling. The examples you give for when cars break the rules vs what bikes do is telling. Yes, everyone breaks the rules, but cars (mostly) do it in safe and predictable manners. Most urban cyclists(including me tbh) break rules in very unsafe ways. Bikes routinely completely ignore stop signs even when there are cars waiting. The ignore red lights which cars never do. They swerve around in traffic, they ride on the sidewalk. Many refuse to use lights when biking at night. Urban biking behavior in the US is on average much more reckless than driving behavior.

Cars are more dangerous due to size and speed but if we’re just talking about who acts more recklessly and ignores more rules it’s easily bikes, at least in Chicago.

Re: Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them

#356
post #236

Waymo didn’t “say” this. Or at least the article this article references doesn’t claim they did. It’s a now third-hand paraphrase from an SF bike advocate who says he heard it from some unnamed representative of Waymo. If someone has something more direct, happy to read it, since this seems to be clickbait napalm at the moment.

Well we have to take whatever scraps of info we can get from these secretive PR managed companies with huge public impact.

Putting words in their mouths makes it harder to get the actual statements, which seems counter to getting actual information about (or from) these companies.

Re: Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them

#358

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All the more reason to be aware of who you’re sharing the road with. I spent a decade cycling for commute in a capital city in Australia. I’m also a tradesman, so I’m well aware that some people actually work on the road. By being a pedestrian or cyclist, you’re literally in other people’s workplace . Delivery drivers, construction workers, breakdown services, road maintenance, electricians, crane operators, cars for…

Working on the road does not give you priority on the roads. If anything, if you’re making money off it, maybe you should be more mindful of the commons you’re using for your profession.

Didn’t your mumma teach you to share.

Re: Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them

#359

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Drivers generally follow the rules. No, they don't. They break the rules all the goddamn time. Have you ever been on an American freeway? Most people are going above the speed limit, myself included. Do you think most drivers give the legally required amount of space in front of their car while driving, especially on the freeway? It's not even close. Do people signal for the legally required amount of time before c…

I bike for 90% of my traveling. The examples you give for when cars break the rules vs what bikes do is telling. Yes, everyone breaks the rules, but cars (mostly) do it in safe and predictable manners. Most urban cyclists(including me tbh) break rules in very unsafe ways. Bikes routinely completely ignore stop signs even when there are cars waiting. The ignore red lights which cars never do. They swerve around in tra…

> Yes, everyone breaks the rules, but cars (mostly) do it in safe and predictable manners.

???

How is texting while driving safe? How is going over the speed limit safe? How is driving too close to other cars to stop in time safe?

Re: Waymo says can't avoid bike lanes because riders want to be dropped off in them

#360

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I bike for 90% of my traveling. The examples you give for when cars break the rules vs what bikes do is telling. Yes, everyone breaks the rules, but cars (mostly) do it in safe and predictable manners. Most urban cyclists(including me tbh) break rules in very unsafe ways. Bikes routinely completely ignore stop signs even when there are cars waiting. The ignore red lights which cars never do. They swerve around in tra…

> Yes, everyone breaks the rules, but cars (mostly) do it in safe and predictable manners. ??? How is texting while driving safe? How is going over the speed limit safe? How is driving too close to other cars to stop in time safe?

Going over the speed limit is not even close to as reckless as completely ignoring stoplights which I see bikes do every day. I see bikers texting weekly even though you need 2 hands to confidently steer a bicycle. Drivers texting is dangerous because theyre controlling heavy machinery, but at least you only need one hand to steer a car in an emergency. A significant portion of bicyclists seem to have a death wish which I can only say for maybe 10% of drivers at most.
Post reply on HN