She, and apparently others she gathered feedback from, felt like I hadn’t done a good enough job pulling other engineers into the project. She spoke of how proud she was of the outcome but that it didn’t excuse my less than ideal methods. I gather from what he wrote that he's a software engineer. How is it his duty to "pull other engineers into the project"? What does management at this company do, besides invent con…
* it depends if the "other engineers" are on the same team or not. If they're a different team, it's not so much a manager responsibility.
* in tech, it helps to already be doing the next job level up to get promoted to it.
> What does management at this company do, besides invent contrived criticism to mash into a compliment sandwich?
The primary job of a manager is to get their employees promoted. The second job is to do whatever you promised your own management you'll do. So yes, that's what they're supposed to do - the "compliment sandwich" is the yearly performance review.