Live data from Hacker News

Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

justice.gov

351–360 of 446 posts

Re: Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

#351
post #233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How did they manage to intercept him at the airport? Are there lists for suspected criminals?

often the feds will surveil someone for a long time and just wait until they try to leave the country . it makes it much easier than trying to do the arrest elsewhere. it's all electronic . You buy a ticket, show your ID/passposrt, and your info will go out.

Couldn’t he have sent a canary to the boarding gate?

Re: Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

#352
post #285

Earlier quoted context omitted.

During which conversation a fairly large number of HN commenters thought that crypto insider trading wasn't illegal: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31012837

If you read the actual SEC filing, you'll note that they're only filing for 7 of the alleged 25 coins that he traded. [1] Even the SEC agrees that this was not insider trading in all 25 instances. "Throughout the relevant period, Nikhil and Ramani repeatedly traded ahead of Coinbase listing announcements, trading in at least 25 tokens. At least seven of the listing announcements described above involved crypto asset…

No. Suspects are often arrested on a subset of the criminal charges with which they will ultimately be indicted. Even in more serious crimes like mass shootings, prosecutors will press charges on only a few of the homicide counts at first. This is common practice for prosecutors.

Re: Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

#353

Wow, the indictment references [this tweet][1] that caused Coinbase to investigate the matter and ultimately led the defendant in being caught at the airport before trying to leave the country. > On May 11, 2022, Coinbase’s director of security operations emailed ISHAN WAHI to inform him that he should appear for an in-person meeting relating to Coinbase’s asset listing process at Coinbase’s Seattle, Washington offic…

It's amazing how they already had tabs on this guy and just waited for him to leave but without arresting him sooner if you think you broke the law and want to avoid arrest, stay away from the airport. anyone who buys a ticket they get your full info and then the arrest is as easy as picking you up at the gate, nowhere to hide.

India has an extradition treaty with the U.S. https://www.state.gov/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/12873-India... sooner or later he'd be back in an orange jump suit

Re: Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

#354

Earlier quoted context omitted.

often the feds will surveil someone for a long time and just wait until they try to leave the country . it makes it much easier than trying to do the arrest elsewhere. it's all electronic . You buy a ticket, show your ID/passposrt, and your info will go out.

Couldn’t he have sent a canary to the boarding gate?

Given the security checks are done by facial recognition, this seems like action-movie level stuff.

Re: Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

#355
> (including interstate wire communications sent from ISHAN WAHI to a fellow Coinbase employee located in Manhattan, New York)

This is an interesting side effect of our remote workplace culture. It used to be that if you committed a crime physically in the workplace, I presume it would not be an interstate crime. However, now you likely are required to work with people all over the place so the laws are all escalated (as i understand it typically interstate law is more punishing).

Re: Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

#356
post #323

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For some nuance, though, partly this has to do with lack of SEC enforcement on crypto as a security. My opinion then would have been that this should be insider trading, crypto should be classified as a security, and also that I wasn’t sure the SEC would classify this as insider trading. Since the definition of insider trading is kind of, “whatever the SEC enforces”, it’s possible to believe that this is a security t…

> the definition of insider trading is kind of, “whatever the SEC enforces” Insider trading is a crime. The SEC cannot bring criminal complaints. Every insider trader who has gone to jail was prosecuted by the DoJ.

According to SEC: https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-ba...

FBI: https://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/insider-trading

Only talk about securities. It seems to me as if it would depend a lot on if the digital asset(s) in question count as securities or not.

Re: Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

#357
post #341

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He could've taken out cash from his local bank account, turned off his phone, driven to San Ysidro and walked through the public turnstile into Tijuana. And then tried to get a flight from Mexico City to somewhere in south asia. Would have been much better than going through the US/Canada border which has a full data sharing agreement between CBSA and US CBP/ICE. (note: this is a stupid, humorous theoretical, not rea…

Isn't the whole point of crypto that you don't need to get your cash out of a bank account that the government can monitor and potentially lockdown?

Crypto is good for recouping his funds once he's out of country and settled. Not super liquid when making last minute on-the-fly purchases though (at least not with the current level of adoption)

Re: Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

#358

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there a list of all 25 somewhere? This could provide some illumination on what SEC does and does not consider a security.

Or maybe the SEC considers all of them securities but thought that they had the strongest case for these seven and didn't want the distraction of arguing about the other 18. But yeah, would be interesting to see the list.

If SEC considers any of them securities, it's very strange for them to go after a single guy at Coinbase and not the entire company, since they've just declared them an illegal securities exchange.

(As opposed to an illegal commodities exchange for bitcoin.)

Re: Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

#359

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you read the actual SEC filing, you'll note that they're only filing for 7 of the alleged 25 coins that he traded. [1] Even the SEC agrees that this was not insider trading in all 25 instances. "Throughout the relevant period, Nikhil and Ramani repeatedly traded ahead of Coinbase listing announcements, trading in at least 25 tokens. At least seven of the listing announcements described above involved crypto asset…

No. Suspects are often arrested on a subset of the criminal charges with which they will ultimately be indicted. Even in more serious crimes like mass shootings, prosecutors will press charges on only a few of the homicide counts at first. This is common practice for prosecutors.

Well, when they indict on the remaining 18 then we can update our models. Until then, the SEC is only alleging that 7 were securities.

Re: Former Coinbase PM charged in cryptocurrency insider trading tipping scheme

#360
post #297

Am I reading the indictment correctly that they are actually being charged with defrauding Coinbase, and that they are not being directly charged with insider trading?

"ISHAN WAHI, 32, of Seattle, Washington, is charged with two counts of wire fraud conspiracy and two counts of wire fraud, each of which carries a maximum sentence of 20 years.

NIKHIL WAHI, 26, of Seattle, Washington, is charged with one count of wire fraud conspiracy and one count of wire fraud, each of which carries a maximum sentence of 20 years.

SAMEER RAMANI, 33, of Houston, Texas, is charged with one count of wire fraud conspiracy and one count of wire fraud, each of which carries a maximum sentence of 20 years."

Yeah from what I understand it seems like the charge comes from defrauding Coinbase

Post reply on HN