Live data from Hacker News

Console Do Not Track – Proposal for a standard environment variable

consoledonottrack.com

351–352 of 352 posts

Re: Console Do Not Track – Proposal for a standard environment variable

#351
post #303

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The similie fails since software tracking in programs you run are agreed to by you when you accepted the license agreement. Yet another reason to prefer free as in freedom software, which can be forked.

I don’t think the simile fails for that reason. “Informed consent” is generally accepted as the standard, and it’s arguable that click-through EULAs are not in any way “informed consent” for the average person. To bring the original simile full circle, let’s say a person signs a contract with another person, and then that person forces themselves on them. I doubt the presence of a clause in the contract saying “I agr…

There certainly is a difference in harm between forcing sex and sending unique user IDs, and it’s not unreasonable to make a contract about the latter if one wishes, is it?

This is rather a reason to prefer free software licenses. Culture has yet to catch up to this, but in the long run I hope the collective consciousness learns to distrust and avoid complicated proprietary software licences.

Re: Console Do Not Track – Proposal for a standard environment variable

#352

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I thought we were discussing the comment you quoted and replied to. It has a different but similar suggestion. And Homebrew automatic updates aren't needed anyway. I don't think fine tuning would help. People who think they're entitled to collect user data without consent don't want to make it easy to opt out.

You literally just said you considered them very different problems? But now you say you think they should both be handled per the OP with a single flag, and you're opposed to both of them on the same grounds -- doesn't sound like you do consider them very different problems? This seems like one of those internet debates where what we're talking about keeps changing in pursuit of "winning" rather than enlightening.

I said nothing close. I won't reciprocate the accusation of bad faith.
Post reply on HN