Live data from Hacker News

A critical look at MCP

raz.sh

341–348 of 348 posts

Re: A critical look at MCP

#341
Not to mention... To actually use MCP you need to:

- Google for half an hour to find the correct steps

- Install Claude Desktop

- Find the Claude Desktop settings (which are not the same as the Claude settings)

- From there you can open a JSON file that you manually edit

For all the hype around this tech, I can't believe how user-unfriendly this is.

Re: A critical look at MCP

#342

I'll say it: MPC is immature trash, and will be replaced with... nothing. It is not needed, nor necessary if one has any functional engineering experience. It's yet another poorly considered distraction created by the software industry that cannot tie it's own shoes.

> It is not needed, nor necessary if one has any functional engineering experience There indeed are people without functional engineering experience. I wrote some software meant to be used by journalists. MCP is a great fit for it, it allows the tool to be expanded and adapted to their needs without having to code the whole thing themselves.

Ok so MPC is just a way for non devs to be able to make calls. Us devs need not apply.

Re: A critical look at MCP

#343

Earlier quoted context omitted.

DeepSeek is a perfectly knowledgeable English speaker in China.

[me] > Translate to palatable startup-style English: >> DeepSeek API 不限制用户的访问速率。我们会尽力满足每个请求。但是,请注意,当我们的服务器流量压力较大时,您的请求可能需要一些时间才能收到服务器的响应。在此期间,您的 HTTP 请求将保持连接状态,您可能会持续收到以下格式的内容…… [LLM] > Here's a more palatable, startup-style translation of your message: > DeepSeek API has no hard rate limits. We strive to process every request as quickly as possible. However, during peak traffic, responses may take slightly longer. R…

I don’t think the person needs to be bilingual. They could just speak English, and start with whatever English attempt at translation had already been made, then take a look at an LLM translation, and then create the final copy based on all of that. They don’t need to speak Mandarin.

I always thought there might be a market for this kind of service. Maybe it would be hard to build trust though. If they don’t trust your language and copy creating abilities, no one will pay for your English skills. And how are they supposed to assess your abilities when the problem they are facing is that they don’t have good command of English in the first place?

Re: A critical look at MCP

#344

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you a native English speaker? "does NOT constrain user's rate limit" should be "does NOT rate limit incoming requests" or similar. "We will try out best" should be "our best". "when our servers are under high traffic pressure" is at least grammatical, but it's awkward. Normally you'd say "when our servers are dealing with high load" or something similar. "your requests may take some time to receive a response fro…

> "Our response times may be slower" would be more natural. How can the time be slower? Response times may be longer, but not slower

It’s not time that is slower. It’s a thing called “our response time” which is slower. There is a slower response. This is perfectly grammatically correct and normally used, at least in American English.

Re: A critical look at MCP

#345
post #249

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In colloquial English my construction is just fine, but sure, you'd be welcome to pick longer too. Some examples of my usage in the wild ("response times may be slower" is present verbatim on each page): https://github.com/aquasecurity/trivy/discussions/8133 https://www.ameristarstaffingny.com/the-negative-effects-of-... https://oci.wi.gov/Pages/Regulation/Bulletin20200320Regulato... https://playrix.helpshift.com/hc/…

This sentence is a good example where the native speaker's version is worse (in this case because it's just non-sense, as the parent commenter already pointed out).

This is normal and accepted English, at least in the USA.

And in English, the word “worse” requires a comparative compliment . Worse than what? Maybe you meant worse than a non-native speaker, but because you didn’t say it, your sentence sounds off.

In English time can have lots of lengths. Any number of English novels have the phrase “a long minute”. People talk about time passing slowly or quickly. We say things like “The last 15 minutes took hours!” Or “Today went by so fast.”

Just because the word “sunrise” is nonsense scientifically doesn’t mean it’s not understood and correct to use in English.

Re: A critical look at MCP

#346

Hey, I am one of the MCP authors. We appreciate the criticism and take it very seriously. We know things are not perfect and there is lots of room for improvement. We are trying to balance the needs of the fast paced AI world, and the careful, time consuming needs of writing a spec. We’d love to improve the spec and the language, and would of course appreciate help here. We also work with an increasingly larger commu…

AI post

Too many grammatical and punctuation errors for it to be AI.

Re: A critical look at MCP

#347
post #258

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah it's unreadable for me. There's been a trend to post LLM slop about tech subjects and they anger me - I don't know why someone wanted to waste people's time like that. Even worse - I've come across an AI slop site that masquerades as dev information, with just plain wrong information.

I let the domain "micropolisonline.com" expire, which I was using for the old OpenLaszlo/Flash Python/SWIG/C++ client/server based version of open source SimCity, and somebody took it over and replaced it with AI generated claptrap, stealing a lot of my own and other's images without any credit. It even promises the source code, but doesn't actually link to it, just has promises and placeholders. It totally misrepres…

Expired domains have always been interesting for the SEO clique. They were early adopters of LLMs.

Re: A critical look at MCP

#348
post #342

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It is not needed, nor necessary if one has any functional engineering experience There indeed are people without functional engineering experience. I wrote some software meant to be used by journalists. MCP is a great fit for it, it allows the tool to be expanded and adapted to their needs without having to code the whole thing themselves.

Ok so MPC is just a way for non devs to be able to make calls. Us devs need not apply.

I am not a dev, so yeah, maybe.
Post reply on HN