Live data from Hacker News

NY Sabotages Right to Repair Bill [video]

youtube.com

341–342 of 342 posts

Re: NY Sabotages Right to Repair Bill [video]

#341

Right to repair is quickly starting to enter similar territory as the 'free software' absolutists. Basically, people who refuse to basically look at the current environment of software / hardware realistically and decry their outdated ideals onto everyone else. All I generally care about is that I can get my data off of a device after some kind of failure or having a reasonably priced solution from the manufacturer.…

I envy your experiences. I personally have had the opposite experience. It’s important to remember that your personal experience may not be the same as others. As this movement is very popular in the general public, my guess is many others have had bad experiences with trying to repair their device (i.e. $500+ for a simple repair from the manufacturer).

I personally don’t care for Louis and he may be a jerk as you suggested, but I try to look at ideas instead of people. Some really bad people have had good ideas. If you follow ideas instead of people, it’s not an issue if you agree with someone on one topic and disagree with almost everything else they have said.

Re: NY Sabotages Right to Repair Bill [video]

#342

Earlier quoted context omitted.

the "bad stuff" currently discussed is about manufacturers only making assemblies available, not components. (that is the big topic in the linked video) I diffed S4104 and S4104A and don't see that in the changes. I also don't see the interpretation of Louis Rossmann in the old version, the definition of "part" was always quite open to interpretation and neither "component" nor "assembly" are mentioned in S4104A. But…

Right. We need to wait until the NY site updates and shows the final version of the bill as "signed by governor". Probably Tuesday.

The bill status has been updated to "Signed by Governor".[1] The text hasn't changed since the version passed by the Assembly.

[1] https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2021/s4104/amendm...

Post reply on HN