Live data from Hacker News

Incident with Actions and Pages

githubstatus.com

331–340 of 407 posts

Re: Incident with Actions and Pages

#331

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They... Didn't describe RAID? More 3-2-1.

The last sentence in the comment is literally "RAID is the way".

I think they were intending to evoke the image of RAID rather than literally referring to a redundant array of inexpensive disks. You host your code on Github, Gitlab, and at home, then you survive a Github outage. It's a redundant array. Not sure it's inexpensive, though.

Re: Incident with Actions and Pages

#332

It's crazy to us how Github Actions have these issues but Azure DevOps never has these hiccups for us even though we hear they're on the "same infra". We're happy to stick with DevOps.

Who says Azure devops is on the same infra as GitHub? I mean, sure they're both hosted in Azure data centers, but there's very little else shared between them AFAIK. I used to work for Microsoft and I heard about the grand plans to merge the two but I don't think it ever really happened.

Re: Incident with Actions and Pages

#334

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Scaling to human use vs automated/agentic use is a very different thing.

Github has had horrible uptime for years, before agentic use was a thing. The killer was Microsoft.

It had uptime issues before Microsoft. They just got better at tracking and reporting after Microsoft.

Re: Incident with Actions and Pages

#335
post #298
post #255

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's an eye opener. Think about it - today, it was a mistake. But, what if it really happened? What if you really lost access to all your years of hard work? It's a wake up call. A blessing in disguise to store what matters to you the most locally, backed up offline. Never trust any single provider. Be it MS or Google or Apple. RAID is the way.

I recently got my GitHub account suspended for 4 months. When it was finally reinstated, their support just said it was a "mistake". Proudly self-hosting Forgejo since then.

This happened to me as well—thankfully not my personal account that I use for work, but the organization associated with an open source project I worked on was suspended. It similarly took 2 months for GitHub to restore the organization.

> Our team is currently experiencing an unexpectedly high volume of tickets which has resulted in longer response times than we prefer. We acknowledge the long wait and apologize for the experience.

> Sometimes our abuse detecting systems highlight accounts that need to be manually reviewed. We've cleared the restrictions from your account…

Fully self-hosted IMO can be an overcorrection. The issue isn’t “relying on other people”—it’s relying on GitHub, when they’ve made it clear they don’t care about uptime and they don’t care about support turn-around-time.

Re: Incident with Actions and Pages

#339
post #55
post #19

My action failed with "Unexpected error fetching GitHub release for tag refs/heads/master: HttpError: Sorry. Your account was suspended" Which certainly made me shit myself, briefly.

Same. It's weird how I always find out that GitHub is down before GitHub does. Took 15 minutes before it appeared on githubstatus.com

> githubstatus.com

There's a threshold. It shows only once 1000 users complain.

/i

Re: Incident with Actions and Pages

#340

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People should use something that keeps a local copy of their code and just copies it to Github and to other contributors with a sync process to push and pull changes. Some sort of 'distributed source control system' maybe. Then people would only need a 'hub' to connect to people, and it'd be easier to move somewhere else.

This gets tiresome. Github is a lot more than a host for Git repositories. If you want to suggest that people use something else, you need to suggest a replacement that has the features people use Github for.

I think you missed the joke, which is that the parent poster you're replying to is suggesting a 'solution' to the problem which evolved in complexity until he was just describing Github again.
Post reply on HN