Live data from Hacker News

OpenClaw is what Apple intelligence should have been

jakequist.com

331–340 of 440 posts

Re: OpenClaw is what Apple intelligence should have been

#331
post #296

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I feel like I’m watching group psychosis where people are just following each other off a cliff. I think the promise of AI and the potential money involved override all self preservation instincts in some people. It would be fine if I could just ignore it, but they are infecting the entire industry.

I don’t think it’s a group psychosis. I think it’s just the natural evolution of junior engineers. They’ve always lacked critical thinking and just jumped on whatever’s hyped on Twitter.

It’s a group psychosis fueled by enormous financial pressure: every big tech company has been telling people that they’re getting fired as soon as possible unless they’re one of the few people who can operate these tools. Of course that’s going to have a bunch of people saying “Pick me! Pick me!” — especially since SV has become increasingly untethered from questions like whether something is profitably benefiting customers. With the focus on juicing share prices before moving to the distilled fiat pricing of cryptocurrency, we have at least two generations of tech workers being told that the path to phenomenal wealth comes from talking up your project until you find a rich buyer.

Re: OpenClaw is what Apple intelligence should have been

#332

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>> Imagine if Siri could genuinely file your taxes Imagine if the government would just tell everyone how much they owed and obviated the need for effing literal artificial intelligence to get taxes done! >> respond to emails If we have an AI that can respond properly to emails, then the email doesn't need to be sent in the first place. (Indeed, many do not need to be sent nowadays either!)

How can government know how much you owe them when they don't know all your tax deductibles?

By knowing all your tax deductibles?

Re: OpenClaw is what Apple intelligence should have been

#335

Newbie question .. how much ram do u need for tbis on mac minis? I thought u had soldered ram these days. So arent people limited by that?

It depends on whether you're running the models locally. If you're just using a Claude or OpenAI token (as probably 95%+ of OpenClaw users are), the RAM requirements are minimal. My first-gen M1 Mac Mini runs it just fine.

Re: OpenClaw is what Apple intelligence should have been

#337

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple's niche product, consisting of like 1-4% of computer sales compared to its dominant MacBook line, is now flying off the shelf as a highly desired product, because of a piece of software that Apple didn't spend a dime developing. This sounds like a major win for Apple. The OS maker does not have to make all the killer software. In fact, Apple's pretty much the only game in town that's making hardware and softwar…

Really doubt it has a significant impact on mac mini sales… And being fair ClawBot is a complete meme/fad at this point rather than an actual product. Using it for anything serious is pretty much the equivalent of throwing your credit cards, ids and sticky notes with passwords and waiting to see what happens… I do see the appeal and potential case of the general concept of course. The product itself (and the author h…

> Using it for anything serious

One man's trash is another man's serious

Re: OpenClaw is what Apple intelligence should have been

#338
post #141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exactly. Apple operates at a scale where it's very difficult to deploy this technology for its sexy applications. The tech is simply too broken and flawed at this point. (Whatever Apple does deploy, you can bet it will be heavily guardrailed.) With ~2.5 billion devices in active use, they can't take the Tesla approach of letting AI drive cars into fire trucks.

This is so obvious I'm kind of surprised the author used to be a software engineer at Google (based on his Linkedin). OpenClaw is very much a greenfield idea and there's plenty of startups like Raycast working in this area.

Being good at leetcode grinding isn’t the same as being a good product person.

Re: OpenClaw is what Apple intelligence should have been

#339
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Airtags were released in 2021, I'd say that counts, but generally I agree.

Their hardware division has been killing it. The software has been where most of the complaints have been in recent years.

> Their hardware division has been killing it.

The last truly magical apple device launch was the Airpod. They've done a great job on their chipsets, but the actual hardware products they make are stagnant, at best. The designs of the new laptops have been a step back in quality and design in my opinion.

Post reply on HN