Live data from Hacker News

Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

theverge.com

331–340 of 506 posts

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#331

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sorry you're frustrated, but it has nothing to do with this change, which works in the opposite direction.

No it doesn't. If you blocked Elon's account, you'll still see it on your timeline.

The change is to let people who you've blocked (Elon) to see your posts, rather than their posts. Otherwise, blocking would be useless.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#332
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes. It's always been a stupid, petulant implementation, and its widespread acceptance is confusing.

The point of blocking is to prevent harassment, no? Hiding the blocker's posts from the blockee puts up an additional barrier to interaction. Even if it can be circumvented, it still requires some effort and may dissuade the person from continuing the harassment. There is a reason why this is the standard implementation for almost every social media site, and petulance has nothing to do with it.

The point of blocking is to prevent harassment, no?

No, the point is "I don't like this person for whatever reason so I don't want to see their posts".

"I don't want this person to see my public posts" can be done by making an account private, or not posting the posts publicly.

Otherwise it opens the door to trollish behavior like reply-and-block-to-prevent-retort.

To stop harassment, reach out to the platform, assuming it cares about harassment, and if it doesn't, contact law enforcement, or file a lawsuit.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#333

Bluesky's Twitter account is appropriately crowing about their superior blocking features: https://twitter.com/bluesky/status/1838292181909672312 : > damn that's crazy. Anyway on bluesky, users have named the blocking function "the nuclear block" because it's such a powerful tool to reduce harassment and dogpiling. You should have control over your experience online.

blocking makes even less sense on a decentralized app.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#334

Bluesky's Twitter account is appropriately crowing about their superior blocking features: https://twitter.com/bluesky/status/1838292181909672312 : > damn that's crazy. Anyway on bluesky, users have named the blocking function "the nuclear block" because it's such a powerful tool to reduce harassment and dogpiling. You should have control over your experience online.

Bluesky is fortunately a honeypot where crazy people all flocked to so that they could post predictions on when Twitter would collapse (highest option: 2 weeks). I think the most effective tool on bluesky is being on bluesky so no one can read what one says because you’re constantly blocking each other even though everyone’s got the same views.

Bluesky is the weirdest echo chamber of white liberal queer Americans, it feels like entering a museum or a theme park where everyone is the same, posts the same things, and agrees with each other to demonise the same things.

With Twitter being the cesspool of humanity—but with a ton of variety and opinions—I don't know which is worse, so I use neither.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#335

This is technically the better option as it doesn’t indicate via sidechannel that someone has blocked you.

I assume it still blocks actions when someone tries to interact with the user, so the fact that they're blocked isn't a secret. It seems like more of a convenience feature for the person who got blocked (since they would otherwise need to log out), which is an odd direction to push a product.

> I assume it still blocks actions when someone tries to interact with the user

That would be weird, the block is there so you don't see their posts & replies, but your block shouldn't affect what they can do. Maybe other people want to see their replies, why should a third party block them from this?

It would be like if IRC's /ignore function prevented someone from sending messages containing your name – weird. You should be able to block yourself off from anybody you wish, but not to control their public speech.

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#336

Makes perfect sense. If the blocked person would still see the post if they logged out, then it's not a real data protection, so why bother?

Twitter is no longer showing things to logged out accounts, but you can still create a separate account

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#338

Makes sense given the current financials. The way you make money in social media is to get people pissed off and arguing with each other. Preventing someone from seeing things that make them mad is just leaving money on the table that they can't afford anymore.

Going to have to agree with this. A semi-related anecdote- I spend an embarrassing amount of time on a music message board with a probably ~97% American user base. It's dedicated to a specific American band but is bizarrely active considering there has not been a UI update of note for maybe 20 years. Parts of the UI have always been frustrating but the culture within the community was palpable and a lot of people grew daily posting habits.

With the 2016 election came a ton of division. Trolls were allowed to run wild. This never really ended. Through the pandemic, insurrection and everything that's followed it's been utter and absolute chaos. Trolls with multiple handles everywhere trying to flood this clearly left-leaning board with far right ideals or purely create chaos.

The owner wasn't hearing the frustration expressed by users though, just the increased ad revenue from engagement largely driven by emotion and anger. Thus why he has let it fester. Twitter seems an extreme variation of this to me, and I foolishly thought Twitter with Elon would do something better with moderation initially

Re: Twitter/X will let people you've blocked see your posts

#340

I am not an X user, I remember Elon making a lot of noise about bots, did Elon fixed the bot issues? Or all that noise was an attempt to get a discount.

I don't know what kind of content these other people are curating with their X accounts, but I never see bots. I primarily follow entrepreneurial & fitness accounts. Honestly X, youtube and HN satisfy just about everything I need for user generated content.

You’re seriously trying to tell someone with a straight face that Twitter isn’t completely overrun with bots?

That’s some of the most disingenuous shit I’ve seen in a while.

Maybe you don’t realise they are bots?

Post reply on HN