Live data from Hacker News

Why Monero

benkaiser.dev

331–340 of 394 posts

Re: Why Monero

#331
post #181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The most promising? What do you mean? BTC and XMR already work and don't have the downsides of Taler. Usability could be improved for those, yes. Outside transparency is not a benefit. Most people I've talked to about crypto don't see the opacity as a detriment. They do not trust the government or tax policy. Most of these people are also generally happy to pay their taxes but can see reasons when they would want to…

> Outside transparency is not a benefit. Most people I've talked to about crypto don't see the opacity as a detriment. They do not trust the government or tax policy. I think his point is: Bitcoin explicitly takes a libertarian position to taxation by making it hard to tax. While most crypto adopters may be libertarian, the majority of people are not and so the libertarian position will deter adoption.

Opponents to cryptocurrency are a very vocal "think of the children" minority as far as I can tell. In the US there seems to be broad interest mostly gated by technical difficulties.

As noted many times here, anonymous crypto is only as bad as cash.

Re: Why Monero

#333

For the dogecoin fans, there is also a similar project based on Monero called Wownero: https://wownero.org/ - that is, technology based on Monero, but more fun. Since I missed to dogecoin hype, I am now rooting for Wow.

You can only trade $wow on tradeorg, wow is not going to get meme adoptions as doge if it is not available on other exchanges or at least supporting Atomic Swaps. Besides people are moving to NFTs.

Re: Why Monero

#334

For the dogecoin fans, there is also a similar project based on Monero called Wownero: https://wownero.org/ - that is, technology based on Monero, but more fun. Since I missed to dogecoin hype, I am now rooting for Wow.

You can only trade $wow on tradeorg, wow is not going to get meme adoptions as doge if it is not available on other exchanges or at least supporting Atomic Swaps. Besides people are moving to NFTs.

Sure it is not investing advice, and obviously it would have to become available on other exchanges.

I wouldn't advise investing in Doge for gains, either.

Re: Why Monero

#335
post #306

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Proof of stake isn’t a good thing actually. Especially in a private cryptocurrency. Monero will remain PoW for its censorship resistance. We can’t have stake oligopolies taking control.

I'm not sure I get your argument, staking takes significantly less powerful hardware so its very accessible. Staking pools also have a "saturation point" to encourage decentralization. That way not all 80 Billion dollars worth of ADA goes to one staking pool. Very hard to see how oligopolies can arise in this scenario when compared to mining operations that are unprofitable to most users (and of course bad for the en…

I think he was arguing for the effectiveness of the proof of work consensus mechanism as opposed to Cardano's PoS's. As someone else described to me:

"..nodes just vote on a block to state whether or not they think it is valid. Once a block gets enough votes, then it is added to the chain."

Whereas a PoW will "just blaze". Is this correct?

Re: Why Monero

#337
post #330
post #202

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This shows how little cryptocurrency users know about how governments collect taxes. The government doesn't go around checking people's bank accounts in order to get tax information. This would be terribly inefficient. What they do instead is pass laws that require employers to disclose how much they pay their employees and to collect taxes on their behalf, before the taxpayer even receives the money. Therefore priva…

For salary or wage payments, kind of. If you received your normal wages in XMR then the government would have a hard time proving anything illegal is happening, even if both your employer and you are breaking the law.

You mean the government may have to rely on old fashioned police work, like undercover agents or informants witnessing the illegimate activity rather than passively spying on financial transactions? Say it ain't so!

Re: Why Monero

#338
post #271

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh no, it works like cash! People will do things with money that you're uncomfortable with. If it's criminal, then laws and enforcement and investigation will have to evolve. That doesn't mean "well, I guess we have to give up privacy now. " Not your money, not your business. Privacy is important, and it's a binary proposition. It's either part of the currency or it's not. You can't have any gray area because people…

Monero (and others) does make ransom collection much more convenient/safe to do. Isn't it its main use case, with probably purchasing drugs and arms? I'm not saying that in theory people wouldn't want to privately purchase their baguette (sorry I'm French), it's just that in practice they generally don't care, unless they are doing something illegal. I'm curious, for those of you who do, what do you actually purchase…

What if your wife hates your baguette habit and she reads your joint bank statements.

Re: Why Monero

#339
post #171

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ZCash is controlled by a privately-owned company in the U.S., who gave themselves founder's rewards. It's also designed in a way to allow "poison pills" - i.e. those in control can force a single transaction on a block, thus giving a vector to deanonymize someone. You may ask, "Who would do something like that?" and the answer would be the U.S. government who can compel privately owned organizations via secret court…

With monero you can analyze residuals to deanonymize people.

Which takes quite a bit of time and hasn't been proven possible yet. Very different from an on-demand poison pill.

Re: Why Monero

#340
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I really want to like Monero but I've had one of the worst crypto experience using the official desktop client. The app crashes randomly, hangs, and worst of all, refuses to send transactions using a hardware wallet when running as a full node. The hardware wallet is only able to sign transactions when connected to a remote node, which is much worse privacy wise. Monero needs much more developers & funding to succeed…

Haven't had any issues on MacOS using monero-wallet-gui.app and a Ledger Nano X.

I'm on Windows. That might be the reason.
Post reply on HN