Live data from Hacker News

Smoke has caused temperature forecasts to go crazy

cliffmass.blogspot.com

331–332 of 332 posts

Re: Smoke has caused temperature forecasts to go crazy

#331

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It goes to show that Cliff Mass has completely lost his framework of reference in his comparison (and so have you). As a German let me assure you that comparing riots among BLM protesters to the Kristallnacht is utterly unappropriate. Don't get me wrong - the rioters should be held accountable for their crimes. You compare a local, loosely organised group of somewhat indiscriminate rioters to a nation-wide, highly hi…

My feeling is that you are getting overly specific about requiring every detail to be an exact match for a similarity to hold. I don't think that is reasonable. Both the criminal subsets of BLM and the brownshirts created an atmosphere of fear. In Seattle, people are afraid to voice their political opinions freely, whether online or in social circles or at work or in political action or protests, because of the threa…

A house cat and a tiger are both cats, they will show the same behaviours and evoke the same emotions, yet they are completely different animals. To go even further, also Cheetahs, Leopards and Ocelots are cats and they will also show the same behaviours!

The point is:

> That is what makes this comparison valid

No it doesn't, the comparison is valid if the dissimilarities are less than the similarities. Which in this case, they aren't.

I've given you a simple order of magnitude argument, and you haven't given any evidence to the opposite.

> BLM is a nationwide (and global) organization

The fact, that you conflate BLM at large with a violent subgroup is concerting. Also you are assuming "they" are a (homogenous) group, are they? Who are "they"?

If you are really interested in discourse, take a different viewpoint for a second and make a list of dissimilarities. Wouldn't Cliff have been able to make the same point (condemn violent riots) by comparing "a house cat to an ocelot"? So why did he choose the tiger?

Re: Smoke has caused temperature forecasts to go crazy

#332

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I read it as less than 1% of all land that has burned this year. Not 1% of all land in the US. Can you imagine if 1% of the entire of the US burned!

There are 1.9 billion acres in the contiguous US, making 1% about 19 million acres. a bad wildfire year is ~10 million acres or ~0.5% ( https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/IF10244.pdf ). It seems conceivable that we surpass that significantly this year.

Wow. Really puts it into perspective. That's equivalent to approx. the four smallest states all burned out.
Post reply on HN