Live data from Hacker News

Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

latimes.com

331–340 of 451 posts

Re: Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

#331

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't buy that. I think it's the media. There are so many reality TV shows and the participants are living in nice houses, driving nice cars. Even movies are fucking unrealistic, you can watch a movie about someone earning minimum wage, yet they live in NYC, in a massive apartment with high ceiling or drive a nice car. The rubbish on TV, both fiction and nonfiction are so far from reality. Yet most consumers desire f…

Fancy phones and watches are, given the current state of most carriers, not actually _that_ much more significant an expense than a cheaper device month to month. You can "buy" that explanation or not, but there's a lot of research and evidence backing up the idea that a huge fraction of the western world lives essentially paycheck to paycheck, and it's not because all of them are less financially savvy than you or I…

My advice is you make sure you have your savings in gear and then live paycheck to paycheck. That is you fund your 401k (IRA, HSA, ...), and set aside some emergency savings. However unless you have a specific short term goal in mind you should be spending everything else and enjoying life to the best of your remaining income.

Of course that $8/month difference isn't much savings, but it is a lunch out vs heating leftovers one day. Or you can eat leftovers everyday, save that $8/month on the phone and use all of that savings to buy membership at a golf club. This is your life and your choice, what do you want?

Re: Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

#332

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well that should be easy to fix. Just keep showing up at the office but don't do any work. It shouldn't take too long before your employer gets sick of it.

They can fire you on disciplinary grounds (you ruining labor discipline or they can even try and prove you are actively sabotaging them). And then you can be liable for damages in court. Believe me, they know how to cover their backs.

Call their bluff.

Re: Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

#333

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, more like a social security system separate for the artist "class". If you manage to declare yourself as an artist, they pay a substantial part of your health insurance, social security, etc... All funded by us, poor feeble minded workers with no creative bone in our bodies, to support 20-somethings and eternal Peter Pans who can't keep a job.

The Künstlersozialkasse is funded by companies which utilize creative work such as publishers, media, ad agencies, museums, etc.

You are technically correct. In practice, I had colleagues working as "web designers" who were working right next to me and would not get a substantial part of their salary taken out for health insurance. So, they were still funded by the non-artists.

Why the distinction? Because this work involved Photoshop and mine used emacs?

Re: Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

#334
post #174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I was living in NYC I paid 39% federal + 13.5% state/city - that’s over 50%. Healthcare and children education not included. I was not a home owner, and my other deduction amounted to almost nothing thanks to AMT. It’s a myth that taxes in the US are low.

I make $100k in Texas and after taxes and everything including healthcare I have approximately $75k. Living in a democratic state has its price.

If I made $100K in NYC I would have likely had the same $75k .... which would have left me with $0 after housing and child raising costs. If I made $10k, I would have had the entire $10k. You are comparing big apples to oranges.

Re: Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

#335

Well, I guess, this may be good. If a lot of dollars seek few resources, and resources pool does not increase much, you get unbounded price increase. Which is not good. Developer have to do something productive for economy. Their wages should be bound to value they produce. If they are consistently paid more then they are producing, whole sector is heading into collapse. In healthy job market, job ads are going to at…

Replace Developer with maid in your post and read it again.

I don't have a maid, instead I clean my own house, and drive my own car. My understanding is in India people with half my income would have maids to do those tasks. However in my country the value a maid produces isn't as much as their value and so I don't pay one. I know what a maid would cost (some advertise in my local newspaper), and they are not worth it.

Same with developers. If the wages go too high some things we could automate will no longer be automated.

Re: Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

#336
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>The unemployment benefit is 400+ euros per month. So tell me who in their right minds would go to work for 500 euros Is there a limit to how long you can collect unemployment? In Finland if you still haven't found a job in about a year, you stop getting payments altogether. And while getting payments, you still have to prove that you're actually searching for a job and not just trying to scam taxpayers.

Similar system in the UK, you have to demonstrate you're applying for jobs. If you're offered something and you refuse to take it your cut off. I think they may even force you in to unpaid/extremely low paid work if you cant get something yourself.

[deleted]

Re: Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

#337

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not that I disagree with the idea but do you have evidence that the average person is actually increasing spending every time they get a raise?

An individual employee may do almost anything. But most of them won't decrease spending when given a raise. Some may spend exactly the same as before. The rest will spend more. Do those who spend more outnumber those who spend less? I have no data, but I would be astonished if those who spent less outweighed those who spent more.

Sure and I basically agree with that. But saying that the actual Average person is spending nearly 100% of any income gains is a pretty bold claim.

Re: Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

#338

Earlier quoted context omitted.

An individual employee may do almost anything. But most of them won't decrease spending when given a raise. Some may spend exactly the same as before. The rest will spend more. Do those who spend more outnumber those who spend less? I have no data, but I would be astonished if those who spent less outweighed those who spent more.

Sure and I basically agree with that. But saying that the actual Average person is spending nearly 100% of any income gains is a pretty bold claim.

That's not a claim that I make, nor one that I think is relevant.

What would I do with more income? Well, I'd probably save some of it, use some of it to pay down debt, and spend some of it. I don't have to be spending 100% of my current income for that to be true.

Re: Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

#339

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fancy phones and watches are, given the current state of most carriers, not actually _that_ much more significant an expense than a cheaper device month to month. You can "buy" that explanation or not, but there's a lot of research and evidence backing up the idea that a huge fraction of the western world lives essentially paycheck to paycheck, and it's not because all of them are less financially savvy than you or I…

My advice is you make sure you have your savings in gear and then live paycheck to paycheck. That is you fund your 401k (IRA, HSA, ...), and set aside some emergency savings. However unless you have a specific short term goal in mind you should be spending everything else and enjoying life to the best of your remaining income. Of course that $8/month difference isn't much savings, but it is a lunch out vs heating lef…

>My advice is you make sure you have your savings in gear and then live paycheck to paycheck

People don't live paycheck to paycheck by choice, usually. Savings first is not an option if it means not paying rent, bills, or food.

Re: Employers will do almost anything to find workers except pay them more

#340
post #309

Wages are not the only issue here. If you look at inflation, the price of food and energy has increased massively since 1999. I know economists like to exclude these figures in their computation of inflation, but they sure do put a dent in the regular workers wallet. I can remember paying 99 cents a gallon for fuel in the late 90's. Now its $3.49 a gallon. I can think back even farther to the 1980s when you could get…

What was the average fuel economy in the late 90's though?
Post reply on HN