Live data from Hacker News

Sora 2

openai.com

321–330 of 916 posts

Re: Sora 2

#321

That could totally power next generation of green-screen techs. Generative actors may not find favorable response in the audiences; but SFX, decor, extras, environments that react to actors' actions - amazing potential.

I can see that future generations are going to think that I'm boomer for preferring the performances of real actors instead of AI slop. The music industry already went through this with AutoTune and we know how that turned out.

I don't get the autotune argument. It's like saying we shouldn't be using electronic instruments because it's not real or we shouldn't use digital audio instruments because they're not real etc.

It's just a way to get different kind of sound. It won't make you good tracks.

Re: Sora 2

#322
Really impressive engineering work. The videos have gotten good enough that they can grab your attention and trigger a strong uncanny valley feeling.

I think OpenAI is actually doing a great job at easing people into these new technologies. It's not such a huge leap in capabilities that it's shocking, and it helps people acclimate for what's coming. This version is still limited but you can tell that in another generation or two it's going to break through some major capabilities threshold.

To give a comparison: in the LLM model space, the big capabilities threshold event for me came with the release of Gemini 2.5 Pro. The models before that were good in various ways, but that was the first model that felt truly magical.

From a creative perspective, it would be ideal if you could first generate a fixed set of assets, locations, and objects, which are then combined and used to bring multiple scenes to life while providing stronger continuity guarantees.

Re: Sora 2

#324

I'm a software engineer and hobbyist actor/director. My friends are in the film industry and are in IATSE and SAG-AFTRA. I've made photons-on-glass films for decades, and I frequently film stuff with my friends for festivals. I love this AI video technology. Here are some of the films my friends and I have been making with AI. These are not "prompted", but instead use a lot of hand animation, rotoscoping, and human v…

I wrote this a year or so ago: https://www.technicalchops.com/articles/ai-goes-to-hollywood...

"The studios and creators who thrive in this new landscape will be those who can effectively harness AI’s capabilities while maintaining the human creativity and vision that ultimately drives the art of cinema."

It is in many ways thrilling to see this come to life, and I couldn't agree with you more.

Re: Sora 2

#325

I haven't seen comments regarding a big factor here: It seems like OpenAI is trying to turn Sora into a social network - TikTok but AI. The webapp is heavily geared towards consumption, with a feed as the entry point, liking and commenting for posts, and user profiles having a prominent role. The creation aspect seems about as important as on Instagram, TikTok etc - easily available, but not the primary focus. Genera…

Meta did the same recently: https://about.fb.com/news/2025/09/introducing-vibes-ai-video...

Re: Sora 2

#326
post #309

I'm a software engineer and hobbyist actor/director. My friends are in the film industry and are in IATSE and SAG-AFTRA. I've made photons-on-glass films for decades, and I frequently film stuff with my friends for festivals. I love this AI video technology. Here are some of the films my friends and I have been making with AI. These are not "prompted", but instead use a lot of hand animation, rotoscoping, and human v…

sorry but it's funny that you mention "heart and soul" while sharing some of the most soulless videos i've ever seen.

I'll have you know that in this year's Atlanta 48 Hour Film project (something I've been doing since I was a teen), several teams used AI.

Rewind to just one year prior -- 2024.

AI video was brand-spanking new. We'd only just gotten over the "Will Smith" spaghetti video and the meme-y "Pepperoni Hug Spot" and "Harry Potter by Balenciaga" videos.

I was the only person to attempt to use AI in 2024's competition. It was a time when the tools and infrastructure for video barely existed.

On the debut night, I was resoundingly booed by the audience. It felt surreal. Working all weekend to have an audience of peers jeering at you in a dark theater. The judges gave me an award out of sympathy.

Back then, image-to-video models really were not a thing (Luma launched "Dream Machine v1" shortly after this). I was using Comfy, Blender, Mocap, a full Mocap suit (the itchy kind), and a lot of other hacks to build something with extremely crude tools.

We lost a day of filming and had to scramble to get something done in just 24 hours. No sleep, too much caffeine. Lots of sweat and toil.

The resulting film was a total mess, of course:

https://vimeo.com/955680517/05d9fb0c4f (It's seriously bad - I hate it. It might legitimately be the very first time AI was used in a 48 hour competition.)

That said, it felt very much like a real 48 Hour competition to me. Like a game jam. The crude ingredients, an idea, the clock. The hustle. The corners being cut. It was palpable.

I don't think you can say there isn't soul in this process. The process has so much soul.

Anyway, fast forward to this year. Three teams used AI, including my own. (I don't think I have a link to our film, sadly.)

We all got applause. The audience was full of industry folks, students, and hobbyists. They loved it. And they knew we used AI.

The industry is anxious but curious about the tech. But fundamentally, it's a new tool for the tool box. The real task is storytelling.

Re: Sora 2

#327
> And we're introducing Cameo, giving you the power to step into any world or scene, and letting your friends cast you in theirs.

How much are they (and providers of similar tools) going to be able to keep anyone from putting anyone else in a video, shown doing and saying whatever the tool user wants?

Will some only protect politicians and celebrities? Will the less-famous/less-powerful of us be harassed, defamed, exploited, scammed, etc.?

Re: Sora 2

#330
What is the target market for this? The videos are not good enough for YouTube. They are unrealistic, nauseating and dorky. Already now any YouTube video that contains a hint of "AI" attracts hundreds of scathing comments. People do not want this.

Let me guess, the ultimate market will be teenagers "creating" a Skibidi Toilet and cheap TikTok propaganda videos which promote Gazan ocean front properties.

Post reply on HN