Live data from Hacker News

Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

reddit.com

321–330 of 365 posts

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#321

This appears to be a classic vision fail on the VLM's part. Which is entirely unsurprising for anyone who has used open VLMs for anything except ""benchmarks"" in the past two god damn years. The field is in a truly embarrassing state, where they pride themselves how it can solve equations off a blackboard, yet couldn't even accurately read a d20 dice roll among many other things. I've tried (and failed) to have VLMs…

5-10 years and Radiologists will be out of a Job, just you wait and see.

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#322
post #142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, the mocking, gleeful negativity really does make me concerned that this place is becoming Reddit. The fact that the highest upvoted post on this thread is just a link to Reddit isn't doing much to help me feel better. And I've been here for at least a decade, so I don't think this is the noob illusion.

[flagged]

Quick question: if there is a paid anti-AI movement, where do I send my invoice? May as well not leave money on the table.

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#323
post #142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, the mocking, gleeful negativity really does make me concerned that this place is becoming Reddit. The fact that the highest upvoted post on this thread is just a link to Reddit isn't doing much to help me feel better. And I've been here for at least a decade, so I don't think this is the noob illusion.

But, I mean… it’s just not good. There is no real way to spin this as anything better than embarrassing.

But why even have a conversation at all? Who cares if Zuckerberg has a demo that goes awry? Does that satisfy your intellectual curiosity somehow? It certainly doesn't satisfy mine.

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#324
post #156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So there was no AI. I know there’s a lot of confusion regarding the exact definition of AI these days, but I’m pretty sure we can this one time all agree that an “on rails” scenario ain’t it. Therefore, whatever it is that they were doing out there, they weren’t demoing their AI product. You could even say it wasn’t a live demo of the product.

You can put the AI on rails by just prompting by it. The latest models are very steerable. System prompt: “stick to steps 1-n. Step 1 is…” I can say confidently because our company does this. And we have F500 customers in production.

And a Fortune 500 company has never done anything stupid.

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#325
post #142
post #135

So much negativity. I’m just excited that our industry is lead by optimists and our culture enables our corporations to invest huge sums into taking us forward technologically. Meta could have just done a stock buyback but instead they made a computer that can talk, see, solve problems and paint virtual things into the real world in front of your eyes! I commend them on attempting a live demo.

Yes, the mocking, gleeful negativity really does make me concerned that this place is becoming Reddit. The fact that the highest upvoted post on this thread is just a link to Reddit isn't doing much to help me feel better. And I've been here for at least a decade, so I don't think this is the noob illusion.

It's a different world than it was ten years ago. Among the ways it's different are people are far more skeptical of billionaires, Big Tech, and capitalism generally. They're willing to cut them much less slack. This is one of the few ways that the world of today is better than the world of ten years ago.

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#326
This is how you know AI will not live up to the hype. You have the highest paid people, at one of the richest companies in the world, building the AI and with unlimited access to the best models and the most talent.

And they still can't pull off a keynote.

So then... what does AI have to offer me? Because I would have thought, as Sam Altman put it, having an expert PhD level researcher in all subjects in my pocket could maybe help me pull off a tech demo. But if it can't help them, the people who actually made the thing, on their very high stakes public address where everything is on the line, then what's it supposed to do for the rest of us in our daily lives?

Because it seems more and more, AI is a tool that helps you stage your own very public humiliation.

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#327
post #153

The mocking, gleeful negativity here concerns me. I am worried that with some of these more polarized topics that the discussions on HN are becoming closer to those on Reddit. The fact that the highest upvoted post on this thread is just a link to Reddit isn't doing much to help me feel better. And I've been here for at least a decade, so I don't think this is the noob illusion. I have no illusions about Zuckerberg.…

HNers lamenting that HN is becoming more like Reddit is one of the longest standing HN traditions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1023252

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#328
post #153

The mocking, gleeful negativity here concerns me. I am worried that with some of these more polarized topics that the discussions on HN are becoming closer to those on Reddit. The fact that the highest upvoted post on this thread is just a link to Reddit isn't doing much to help me feel better. And I've been here for at least a decade, so I don't think this is the noob illusion. I have no illusions about Zuckerberg.…

You just don’t seem to understand. Mark wouldn’t hesitate to grind you down to the last atom in order to extract every last bit of value out of you. And you defend the guy because he gave you freebies, or something. I have no words.

These are the sort of people repeatedly falling for the most obvious scams

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#329
post #153

The mocking, gleeful negativity here concerns me. I am worried that with some of these more polarized topics that the discussions on HN are becoming closer to those on Reddit. The fact that the highest upvoted post on this thread is just a link to Reddit isn't doing much to help me feel better. And I've been here for at least a decade, so I don't think this is the noob illusion. I have no illusions about Zuckerberg.…

HNers lamenting that HN is becoming more like Reddit is one of the longest standing HN traditions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1023252

Sure, but check my account age. It's not like I joined the site 6 months ago. In fact, I was around when that comment was made.

Re: Meta’s live demo fails; “AI” recording plays before the actor takes the steps

#330
post #307

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The signal to noise ratio certainly became worse. You'll see the same folks spamming their hatred towards tesla/microsoft/meta/google over and over with zero substance other than sentimental blabbering.

I"ve not seen that honestly. I think you are looking for it satisfy your internal narrative you've created.

You haven't seen people, on this site, hating on Tesla?
Post reply on HN