Live data from Hacker News

An electric new era for Atlas

bostondynamics.com

321–330 of 443 posts

Re: An electric new era for Atlas

#321

That first video of the bot standing from the floor and turning towards the camera one joint at a time does something strange to the uncanny valley horror movie part of my brain.

Yes, very strong T-1000 vibes – the way it keeps reversing "front" and "back" almost feels like a deliberate reference to that moment in Terminator 2.

Exactly what i was going to write as well. I think that’s the reaction they were aiming for.

Re: An electric new era for Atlas

#322
post #11

If all Boston Dynamics did was make Youtube videos, they'd have a pretty good business.

Is that their business? They've been around for 30+ years and I don't think they've ever successfully commercialized a product. So far as I can tell, they just hop from DARPA grant to DARPA grant and make cool videos of the results. I don't have any particular problem with that, but its a little weird? I figured they were a more traditional industrial robotics company that just did the humanoid robots as a side line…

I got the impression they sold lots of dogs as cargo-carrying robots for US defense organizations.

Re: An electric new era for Atlas

#324

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Uh, what evidence do you have of this "wide scale robotic deployment"? More humanoid robots have been announced lately but that is all I know of. Humanoid robots have many, many challenges to deployment. Especially, creating a machine that people can safely operate near is extremely challenging. The amount of intelligence person uses to not bump another person is very under rated.

It's a hypothetical deployment but it's reasonable to expect. These robots will be very valuable, and everyone will want one. It's not going to become a housemaid in a few years. But will they be making car parts? Almost certainly. Moravec's paradox is still in play, but advancement in AI chips will slowly overcome it.

> But will they be making car parts? Almost certainly.

What can humanoid robots making car parts do, that the already-existing and already widely deployed robots making car parts can't?

Re: An electric new era for Atlas

#325

That first video of the bot standing from the floor and turning towards the camera one joint at a time does something strange to the uncanny valley horror movie part of my brain.

Funny, because Data (from Star Trek) mentions that his joints can move like that but he refrains because it disturbs humans.

Re: An electric new era for Atlas

#326

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're excited... at the yet unexplored military applications... of humanity finding ever more efficient ways of killing each other? FML, that's dark.

War is already dark and more precision makes it less dark. Winning faster saves lives.

Making war feel less risky to politicians who want to wage it for domestic jingoistic bullshit reasons[0] makes war more likely to happen in the first place, which costs lives.

Also, bold of you to assume you're going to be winning. Does the excitement about this new tech hold up if you consider it from the perspective that it's going to be used against you and your troops?

[0] as opposed to actual defence against invasion - despite the euphemism commonly used by western governments for their military political departments. And what %age of military actions in the last 50 years that your country was involved in count as one, or the other?

Re: An electric new era for Atlas

#329
post #299

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure it has ever been about complexity or cost. Right now no regular user has the technical ability to fiddle with a phone's laminated screen glued to a touch matrix paired with a fingerprint sensor and a camera, so we're alreay past the complexity threshold. But we could still reuse a screen block from phone A on phone B, except that's been forbidden by technical measures specially added to prevent it. The s…

It's absolutely about complexity. Complexity always allows companies to explain why they should be the only hands that touch something, lest a laymen fumbles it.

Could you materially affect a half-century old internal combustion engine? Sure. Can you do so after decades of miniaturization/optimization, to make it as efficient as they are today?

Mobiles are similar, they are filled to the brim with various electronics, connected together into a huge mash. why would you even expect to fix that?

Re: An electric new era for Atlas

#330

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Funny how the ubiquity of AI generated artwork plus the shitty quality of phone videos has made people to think that "high quality + depth of field = fake". However if you look closely the robot does have scuffs and scratches on it so I think it's real.

Reminds me to how high framerate made (makes?) people think "Soap Opera", even though it's technically higher quality.

Yeah lol I love all things that deliver more information to my eyes like higher resolution and framerate so I dislike it when people complain about high frame rate.
Post reply on HN