Live data from Hacker News

The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter

twitter.com

321–330 of 491 posts

Re: The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter

#321

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We pay fat piles of taxes for the government to secure liberty. The idea that that government is "managing" that liberty is Constitutionally murky. The "private property" fig leaf is scant comfort.

Uh, no, private property is subjogated to national interest. Personal freedom is subjogated to national interest (you may be conscripted). In all countries. The only way for things not to fall into a terrible state of affairs (like in Russia or Iran) is for the civil society to perform political acts, like engage in honest journalism, activism and critical thinking. And even then freedom and security are not guarante…

> Thinking that you can be a free-from-all libertarian is like being a house cat that does not comprehend the system that keeps him alive.

So because the government does something (THANK GOD), we all need to advocate for more government?

Re: The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter

#322

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The FBI was highlighting obvious parody accounts and accounts with double digit followers for the “crime” of the tired old joke of “(other party) votes on Wednesday”.

The whole parody thing a-la Carl Tuckerson "nobody seriously believes this" while manufacturing outrage that many people believe in and results in stochastic terrorism needs to stop. How many massacres[1] are necessary before people take things like that a bit more seriously? Is it until somebody they know gets murdered? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_right-wing_terrorist_a...

I mean the parody account being referenced here (@madandpissedoff) was one that pretended to be the WWE wrestler undertaker and almost exclusively tweeted denials about shitting his own pants at the mall. I’m not sure it was really leading toward a massacre (unless you count what happened to that mall bathroom stall.)

Re: The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter

#323
post #170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Then someone found an archived copy of all but one of the tweets, and they all turned out to be pictures of Hunter Biden's penis. Yes, he left his images on laptop. That's not revenge porn, as far as I know. > The smoking gun email in the "Part 1" Twitter Files Don't quote me on that, but from my memory not only were links to Hunter deleted, but so were discussions of it from even reputable journalist. I think it w…

Re-distributing intimate material without the subjects permission is pretty much the definition of revenge porn.

> In late 2020, a controversy emerged involving data from a laptop belonging to Hunter Biden that was abandoned at a Delaware computer shop.[1] The data was subsequently shared with the FBI, Republican operatives, and later the press.[2]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunter_Biden_laptop_controvers...

That's a very strange definition of revenge porn. It was made inadvertently by Hunter Biden, it wasn't used for blackmail and it is related to a bulk of other interesting email.

Re: The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter

#325

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder if you’d have an issue with it if these organisations leaned mostly republican. When this last happened in the 1960s and 70s, when it was the left that was anti establishment, and didn’t want the Vietnam war, or didn’t want Christian orthodoxy imposed on society, the left was obsessed with free speech and being anti government organisations. Suddenly no one can think beyond their own party and as long as the…

> People really need to think longer term. Asking too much. In the past couple months, HN users went from “it’s a private company they can do what they want” when Twitter was a public company working with the FBI to enact specific user censorship… to “OMG Elon banned a handful of journalists, freeze peach was a lie!” when it was a suspension for 12 hours. Where are all those “it’s a private company they can do what t…

Ok. It’s a private company and they can do what they like. And we can point out the hypocrisy.

Re: The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter

#326

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Uh, no, private property is subjogated to national interest. Personal freedom is subjogated to national interest (you may be conscripted). In all countries. The only way for things not to fall into a terrible state of affairs (like in Russia or Iran) is for the civil society to perform political acts, like engage in honest journalism, activism and critical thinking. And even then freedom and security are not guarante…

> Thinking that you can be a free-from-all libertarian is like being a house cat that does not comprehend the system that keeps him alive. So because the government does something (THANK GOD), we all need to advocate for more government?

[dead]

Re: The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter

#327

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There has never been need to have judicial oversight when making a request , the FBI can send a request to Twitter just the same as they can ask you to come in for an interview. You're free to refuse.

Ye no. I would certainly worry alot more if FBI sent me an angry letter compared to say Pizza Hut? You always have an implied threat when a government agency is involved.

You can see the letters. They weren’t angry.

Re: The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter

#328
post #179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> current average level of comfort with government involvement It really all comes down to this- it's largely a matter of personal comfort/risk tolerance. Personally, I'd be happy to see entire agencies wiped out, the CIA and the NSA obliterated, the FBI cut back to where it was in the 60s or so, preferably focused on mob/cartel activity and the like. The CIA should never have been separated out from the military and…

Doesn't the NSA represent a huge portion of our signals intelligence capabilities as a country? How would that role be filled otherwise? Wouldn't the best people to do many of those new jobs still be the people who used to work at the (now defunct) NSA?

The internal security is doing fine without NSA and when their biggest "achievement" was making everyone less secure via encryption backdoors you gotta wonder about purpose of existence.

Private industries seem to do just fine when it comes to security and nearly none of the progress in security is due to NSA, unless you count "looking real hard whether NSA didn't try to backdoor new security primitive" as progress

Re: The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter

#329
post #319
post #146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I could see a world where ‘see if it violates your own policies’ is a code for extortion with plausible deniability. This is possible but I would expect people to look for evidence of it before presenting it as a fact. Something like that would show up in internal communications either directly or as people talking like they didn’t really have a choice, or as a trend of tweets being taken down for reasons which don…

It's the slightest whiff of a hint of abuse or intimidation but there's no evidence to suggest they ever even threatened retribution for non-compliance. US intelligence agencies have gone after media a handful of times but the courts have been appropriately skeptical of their claims. And everytime I see a slippery slope argument about law enforcement sneaking into quiet corners of private enterprise, I like to remind…

> I see a slippery slope argument about law enforcement sneaking into quiet corners of private enterprise, I like to remind people that local police shoot people pretty frequently.

Indeed - from the perspective of civil liberties there are many issues which seem more pressing.

Re: The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence community and Twitter

#330

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your link doesn’t make any sense. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volksverhetzung Germany has laws against incitement. > 2] "incitement of popular hatred", "incitement of the masses", or "instigation of the people", is a concept in German criminal law that refers to incitement to hatred against segments of the population and refers to calls for violent or arbitrary measures against them, including assaults against th…

I fail to see how having a law against incitement in germany - that doesn't even sound like would apply to jan 6th if it was done there- makes the article of merkel and several other EU leaders condemning twitter's action not make any sense.

It appears Merkel did not intervene in this case of incitement to violence.

https://www-welt-de.translate.goog/vermischtes/article231416...

Post reply on HN