Live data from Hacker News

Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

reuters.com

321–330 of 330 posts

Re: Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

#321

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From an EU perspective why would peace and trade with Russia be so bad? Clearly US psyops are stronger than anything Russia puts out because EU governments have been persuaded to participate in a crusade in Ukraine against their own economic self interests. Making the EU kowtow to America may be in American interests but it certainly is not in EU interests. I am not sure when this myth of Russia psyop dominance came…

> From an EU perspective why would peace and trade with Russia be so bad? Because Russia every once in a while invades a part of Europe to carve off territory for itself, then holds the rest of the continent hostage by withholding gas during the freezing winter. Why would you want peace with a country that is just biding its time before it starts it's next war?

Every once and while?

When was the last time Russia invaded the EU?

Re: Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

#322

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From an EU perspective why would peace and trade with Russia be so bad? Clearly US psyops are stronger than anything Russia puts out because EU governments have been persuaded to participate in a crusade in Ukraine against their own economic self interests. Making the EU kowtow to America may be in American interests but it certainly is not in EU interests. I am not sure when this myth of Russia psyop dominance came…

Why would doing business with dangerous psychopath be so bad? After all, we’d just continuously give him money and depend on his services for our wellbeing, choosing to ignore that he kills „some less important people way east”. Nothing to see here.

Maybe the less important people should recognise that they are less important and make peace with their powerful neighbor? When did Ukrainian interests exactly correspond to EU interests? Governments are not charities. What is so important about Ukraine that Germany and France need to suffer for it? Didn't German voters elect their government to put German interests first?

Re: Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

#323
post #316
post #281

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Doesn’t make sense at all. Why blow it up when the German governing parties and the largest opposition party don’t want to move ahead with Nord Stream 2 anyway?

Politicians change, sometimes abruptly, especially during crisis. This prevents the "new guys" from starting the pipeline.

That’s an ultra dumb approach and assumes there are no costs associated with sabotage (risk of being uncovered, unintended side effects).

Currently (and during the last decades) politics in Germany have been very stable and predictable.

Re: Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

#324

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> From an EU perspective why would peace and trade with Russia be so bad? Because Russia every once in a while invades a part of Europe to carve off territory for itself, then holds the rest of the continent hostage by withholding gas during the freezing winter. Why would you want peace with a country that is just biding its time before it starts it's next war?

Every once and while? When was the last time Russia invaded the EU?

I didn't say the EU, which has a collective defense treaty similar to that of NATO. I said Europe. And to answer that question:

2014, Ukraine

2008, Georgia

1992, Moldova and Romania

And of course the Soviet Union invading, occupying and brutally oppressing half of Europe after WW2 (including several countries now in the EU and NATO). Or have you forgotten? They haven't.

Re: Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

#325

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would doing business with dangerous psychopath be so bad? After all, we’d just continuously give him money and depend on his services for our wellbeing, choosing to ignore that he kills „some less important people way east”. Nothing to see here.

Maybe the less important people should recognise that they are less important and make peace with their powerful neighbor? When did Ukrainian interests exactly correspond to EU interests? Governments are not charities. What is so important about Ukraine that Germany and France need to suffer for it? Didn't German voters elect their government to put German interests first?

I am speechless. That is the most cynical approach I’ve ever seen. Makes me kinda happy that Germany is loosing its power in EU with every passing day of this war.

Re: Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

#326

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Every once and while? When was the last time Russia invaded the EU?

I didn't say the EU, which has a collective defense treaty similar to that of NATO. I said Europe. And to answer that question: 2014, Ukraine 2008, Georgia 1992, Moldova and Romania And of course the Soviet Union invading, occupying and brutally oppressing half of Europe after WW2 (including several countries now in the EU and NATO). Or have you forgotten? They haven't.

Well for starters Georgia is not in Europe. It is in asia.

I am not sure what you mean about 1992. If Moldova can be independent why not Transinistra?

Ukraine was subject to a coup and civil war. Right or wrong reacting to a coup is not the same as an unprovoked invasion.

Re: Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

#327

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I didn't say the EU, which has a collective defense treaty similar to that of NATO. I said Europe. And to answer that question: 2014, Ukraine 2008, Georgia 1992, Moldova and Romania And of course the Soviet Union invading, occupying and brutally oppressing half of Europe after WW2 (including several countries now in the EU and NATO). Or have you forgotten? They haven't.

Well for starters Georgia is not in Europe. It is in asia. I am not sure what you mean about 1992. If Moldova can be independent why not Transinistra? Ukraine was subject to a coup and civil war. Right or wrong reacting to a coup is not the same as an unprovoked invasion.

> Ukraine was subject to a coup and civil war.

Until this line it wasn’t clear whether you were deluded or actively pushing propaganda. Thanks for clearing that up.

Re: Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

#328

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would doing business with dangerous psychopath be so bad? After all, we’d just continuously give him money and depend on his services for our wellbeing, choosing to ignore that he kills „some less important people way east”. Nothing to see here.

Maybe the less important people should recognise that they are less important and make peace with their powerful neighbor? When did Ukrainian interests exactly correspond to EU interests? Governments are not charities. What is so important about Ukraine that Germany and France need to suffer for it? Didn't German voters elect their government to put German interests first?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neville_Chamberlain

Re: Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

#329

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well for starters Georgia is not in Europe. It is in asia. I am not sure what you mean about 1992. If Moldova can be independent why not Transinistra? Ukraine was subject to a coup and civil war. Right or wrong reacting to a coup is not the same as an unprovoked invasion.

> Ukraine was subject to a coup and civil war. Until this line it wasn’t clear whether you were deluded or actively pushing propaganda. Thanks for clearing that up.

You always give someone a chance. Once they give the game away, it's no longer worth your time to engage.

Re: Three Nord Stream gas pipelines damaged in one day

#330

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, the winner here is clearly Russia. They wanted to cut the line to pressure the EU into pressuring Ukraine to agree to a ceasefire along existing battle lines. Cutting production through an "accident" allows them plausible deniability to cut Europe's gas supplies without formally violating the contract and for restoration negotiations if the Ukraine question is settled.

Supposedly 350 million dollars worth of gas were lost from nord stream 2. Doesn't seem worth it for a false flag. Plus it eliminates a carrot Russia had for Germany. People need to start thinking critically...

Why then is Russia still pumping gas through a broken pipeline, poisoning the environment of European countries ?

https://twitter.com/visegrad24/status/1576975332510298112

Post reply on HN