Live data from Hacker News

FB messenger silently censoring links, claims they were sent

twitter.com

321–330 of 488 posts

Re: FB messenger silently censoring links, claims they were sent

#321

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What screenshot are you looking at? Because there are no red exclamations in the image on the linked tweet

Next tweet in the thread shows them. First pic is cropped (not sure why)

the tweet appears to be intentionally deceptive. They cropped the first picture just to remove the exclamation mark.

Re: FB messenger silently censoring links, claims they were sent

#322
post #87
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hacker News does it. Reddit does it sitewide. Individual moderators do it sitewide. Shadowbanning is an essential tool for moderation, for dealing with trolls, spammers, abusive people. You can argue the tool is being used too widely by Facebook, but it is silly to pontificate against the practice as a whole. You reaaaaallly would not like the uncensored internet.

I am sorry, but the uncensored internet is the only type of acceptable internet. Anything else is just gov or corp interests.

An uncensored internet would become an unusable cesspit.

Re: FB messenger silently censoring links, claims they were sent

#323

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The censorship is intentional, but the silence is a bug in the react code. You can look at the console in chrome devtools to see. There is an error message informing the viewer that their message was censored. The message is incorrectly hidden when you send additional message. Also refresh the page and the messages disappear from the viewer.

As good as they are at 99.99% of what they do, almost every time a friend brings an example to me of Facebook doing something malicious, it turns out to be simple implementation error.

So that got winners of the C Underhanded Contest working there?

Re: FB messenger silently censoring links, claims they were sent

#324

Earlier quoted context omitted.

After big tech stepped in to ban news articles on Biden selling political influence to foreign nationals most people stopped even considering these kind of things conspiracy. But to OP's point on joebiden.info: https://www.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/hr30p3/reddit_f...

He's President and won with 81M votes. Your crying won't change that, just so you know.

Oh let him cry please, I'm enjoying it. ;)

Re: FB messenger silently censoring links, claims they were sent

#325

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It happened. This website has a blurb about it https://censortrack.org/case/joebideninfo . I tried it a few months ago and it was blocked. Here's a screenshot I made of it: https://i.imgur.com/KZa60db.jpg

That website needs proofreading, it does not instil confidence in your case. If it actually happened, it would be trivial to record it happening and to share that recording. But this makes it clear you are just trying to throw more confusion onto the election.

Do you think I'm making this up? I experienced this. Apparently from sibling comments it no longer occurs, and I do not possess a time machine.

I'm not going to jump through hoops to prove this for you - please do some cursory online research.

This is bewildering. I have no agenda nor care enough to comment about a foreign country's election.

Re: FB messenger silently censoring links, claims they were sent

#326
post #183

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right or not, I think charitably, the person you are responding to is pointing out that this is not a new thing in social media sites. It's a decades old technique at this point.

Shadow banning isn’t really something used in private messages, no?

When faced with software/malware that was appending links to user's instant messages back in 2005, back-end code to silently drop the user's messages was put in place. This was a messaging service that had ~200 million users.

Re: FB messenger silently censoring links, claims they were sent

#327

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why don’t we judge each action on its individual merits instead? Why can’t we simply say “yup, this site is a problem, nothing of value lost here” without worrying about whether they’re going to block speech about whether 2 or 3 teaspoons of yeast is the right amount to put in a loaf of bread, or whether my candidate for school board is better than yours? Let me be super clear here: nobody is entitled to use other pe…

I ran into this block last year trying to send a link with a comment like "wow this is wild, if this is what people really believe our democracy is in trouble ", that felt like a hinderance to even discussing the problem.

That's the very definition of concern trolling.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_troll#Concern_troll

Re: FB messenger silently censoring links, claims they were sent

#329
post #195

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Trust me. The way activism is going, they would do it even with no money offered.

Indeed, both the "woke" and the "alt right" are united in their love of repressing what other people have to say. You are correct!

And complaining about how they're the victims of "cancel culture" when they're the ones trying to cancel people themselves.

Re: FB messenger silently censoring links, claims they were sent

#330
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reddit was also silently removing comments containing joebiden.info Not sure if they still are

One of my comments in Reddit was changed by admins. It was something related with d... Not directly related with my comment but this is a proof https://techcrunch.com/2016/11/23/reddit-huffman-trump/

You were one of the people who had a comment edited in that 1 hour period mentioned in that news article?

Or are you saying there was a different comment editing incident? If so, that would be big news. He promised not to do it again, so if he did, he's breaking a promise, and I think that would be pretty newsworthy.

> "As the CEO, I shouldn’t play such games, and it’s all fixed now. Our community team is pretty pissed at me, so I most assuredly won’t do this again."

https://www.theverge.com/2016/11/23/13739026/reddit-ceo-stev...

Post reply on HN