Live data from Hacker News

Firefox Release 89.0

mozilla.org

321–330 of 487 posts

Re: Firefox Release 89.0

#321
post #24

> "We’ve redesigned and modernized the core experience to be cleaner, more inviting, and easier to use." Why does the UI change with every single Firefox release? I find myself having to re-adjust every time a new update is shipped. What's wrong with having a consistent experience that survives for more than 6 months? It's just a URL bar, and a bunch of tabs. Just leave it be already.

Its ok for me if the changes are incremental. When Chrome first came out, the lightweight, clean and out of your field of view tab bar was a welcome change. FF did pretty good with small changes that, in my view, have made it look better over the years. edit : Ok, checked the new design. Definitely don't like the tab buttons, mainly because when there are multiple open, there are no discernable borders among them. So…

I got rid of top tabs panel in favor of tree view, can’t imagine ever switching back.

Re: Firefox Release 89.0

#322
post #230
post #24

> "We’ve redesigned and modernized the core experience to be cleaner, more inviting, and easier to use." Why does the UI change with every single Firefox release? I find myself having to re-adjust every time a new update is shipped. What's wrong with having a consistent experience that survives for more than 6 months? It's just a URL bar, and a bunch of tabs. Just leave it be already.

It makes me dread taking their monthly releases. I wish they would decouple security fixes with everything else. My address bar is permanently broken, I cannot delete previously viewed sites as suggestions at all anymore.

They do, it's called Firefox ESR.

Re: Firefox Release 89.0

#323
I liked the UI changes, except that they removed Compact Mode due to "Low Engagement" Why is that even a metric for a browser UI? Are they putting ads in the settings?

It's now hidden by this bool in about:config, `preference browser.compactmode.show `

Re: Firefox Release 89.0

#324

I don't like the removal of tab separators. Now all the background tabs kind of merge into one large mega tab :( for example - https://i.ibb.co/p4LWvtb/2021-06-01-19-12-43-3841x169.png

that and the container highlight has moved to the top of the tab. On windows 10, i am having a difficult time identifying which tabs are in a container and which are not...

I'm having similar difficulty on macOS.

Re: Firefox Release 89.0

#325

I liked the UI changes, except that they removed Compact Mode due to "Low Engagement" Why is that even a metric for a browser UI? Are they putting ads in the settings? It's now hidden by this bool in about:config, `preference browser.compactmode.show `

Because an option visible in the UI that nobody is using is visual clutter. You still have it hidden in about:config as you say.

Re: Firefox Release 89.0

#326

I liked the UI changes, except that they removed Compact Mode due to "Low Engagement" Why is that even a metric for a browser UI? Are they putting ads in the settings? It's now hidden by this bool in about:config, `preference browser.compactmode.show `

> Why is that even a metric for a browser UI?

Because they need to know where to focus their efforts.

Re: Firefox Release 89.0

#327

I liked the UI changes, except that they removed Compact Mode due to "Low Engagement" Why is that even a metric for a browser UI? Are they putting ads in the settings? It's now hidden by this bool in about:config, `preference browser.compactmode.show `

> Why is that even a metric for a browser UI? Because they need to know where to focus their efforts.

I'm not familiar with how Firefox UI works. Would it require a non-trivial amount of work to maintain a compact theme? I'm assuming it's some form of style sheet and they share assets like icons.

Re: Firefox Release 89.0

#329
post #286

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Really? They seem much bigger, like twice the size. I don’t dislike them as much as I initially did. They’re just a little to big on low resolution monitor. Personally I’d like to see browsers move away from trying to be “special” and just follow the design of operating system. A little tricky on Linux, but for Windows and macOS just follow the guidelines from Microsoft and Apple.

I'm wrong, but the difference is about 2 pixels on Linux.

Okay, I was way of. The tabs just seem much bigger, but if it's only two pixels I won't complain again.

Re: Firefox Release 89.0

#330

I don't like the removal of tab separators. Now all the background tabs kind of merge into one large mega tab :( for example - https://i.ibb.co/p4LWvtb/2021-06-01-19-12-43-3841x169.png

The favicons separate tabs clearly enough for me.
Post reply on HN