Live data from Hacker News

Hire people who give a shit

alexw.substack.com

321–330 of 342 posts

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#321
post #209

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the way the author expands on it isn't too great, with questions like "How many hours were you working a week?" and "obsessed person". However, I do think there's sense in the general premise of "hire people who care about what they do", but this doesn't need to translate to "work your ass off". A lot of the time when I see people produce really crap code it's because they just don't care. They show up for wo…

Some people would always produce crap code, because they simply don't care. But for others, it may be a reaction to how they are treated by the company. Making the code nice takes some time, and if the project is understaffed and people work overtime... you just want to get it done and go home, not take additional overtime to refactor it nicely.

Definitely. I've been watching Ramsey's Kitchen Nightmares in the last week or so (the less sensational UK version), and one thing that struck me is that in a number of cases you have decent or even good chefs who are demotivated, bored, have little or no responsibility, and have given up and produce crap results.

Sometimes even just a little injection of responsibility can revive the enthusiasm.

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#322
post #57

Not a native speaker, but for me "giving a shit" doesn't sound like you really care for something. Ok, it's (maybe) better than "not giving a shit", which is nothing at all, but it's not much more than the bare minimum...

Thank you for this moment of humour. It was much needed.

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#323

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm curious. How many misogynistic clients actually scream at 22 year old analysts in MBB? I'd assume business norms would ensure some form of civility in meetings. I haven't heard from any of my MBB friends (who are mostly in India btw), of being yelled at. When I was in PE, I was the 25 year old shouting at some 45 year old CEO (with the license of my firm's MD) for BSing around. Fun times, but that was a very exce…

Consultant for well over a decade now. I've worked with quite a few MBB kids over the years as well as with clients who previously hired them. I'd say it's fairly uncommon for clients to actually yell at the analysts on the ground, but it does happen. It's more likely that the MBB associate or engagement manager gets yelled at for various reasons. But it's a lot more common for the analysts to be told "do whatever th…

So clients actually shout at consultants? Guess somebody's parents didn't raise them right.

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#324
post #207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From my experience, the people who get hired are people who complain about corporate propaganda and don't work hard while what I considered hard working individuals are the ones who struggle to find work. Companies hire for mediocrity, not skill. If skill mattered, I would dedicate my life to a company. But it doesn't I so won't ever care.

Life can get better. Don't give up don't give into the bitterness. What ever you're doing isn't working for you but you can change your situation. There is hope.

Heard that for 10 years

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#325
post #286

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From my experience, the people who get hired are people who complain about corporate propaganda and don't work hard while what I considered hard working individuals are the ones who struggle to find work. Companies hire for mediocrity, not skill. If skill mattered, I would dedicate my life to a company. But it doesn't I so won't ever care.

If you think a company would swear life long loyalty in return to you just because you happen to have some skills, wait till you see what happens when they no longer have use for your “skills”. Never swear loyalty, it’s business, not the military.

Spoken like a person who had a mediocre job they didn't like yet still took the money

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#326

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From my experience, the people who get hired are people who complain about corporate propaganda and don't work hard while what I considered hard working individuals are the ones who struggle to find work. Companies hire for mediocrity, not skill. If skill mattered, I would dedicate my life to a company. But it doesn't I so won't ever care.

I am rooting for you

Lying isn't helpful. You most likely forgot already and looked at some memes while getting paid during this 4 day break

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#327
post #286

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From my experience, the people who get hired are people who complain about corporate propaganda and don't work hard while what I considered hard working individuals are the ones who struggle to find work. Companies hire for mediocrity, not skill. If skill mattered, I would dedicate my life to a company. But it doesn't I so won't ever care.

If you think a company would swear life long loyalty in return to you just because you happen to have some skills, wait till you see what happens when they no longer have use for your “skills”. Never swear loyalty, it’s business, not the military.

I assume you don't have skills if you don't dedicate your life to it. I assume you have blah blah blah family blah blah blah memories in which you chose some something else over harnessing your skills. Something you can only do when when you have a job in the first place. You more or less defined mediocrity

Re: Hire people who give a shit

#328

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am rooting for you

Lying isn't helpful. You most likely forgot already and looked at some memes while getting paid during this 4 day break

It really isn’t my place to say since I have no skin in your situation, but I think you should consider talking to a friend.
Post reply on HN