Live data from Hacker News

Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

theguardian.com

321–330 of 546 posts

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#321
post #204

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for mentioning this example. Every time I see complaints of how FB (or any big company) should not be using contractors, I'm at a loss to think of companies that employ this kind of support staff. I think most of the companies I've worked have generally outsourced cafeteria and janitorial work, albeit these companies were in much more affordable metros.

It's a lost opportunity that companies who view themselves as socially progressive and invest heavily in marketing and PR around inclusivity then continue inadvertently maintaining an internal class system of knowledge vs service workers.

It's almost like they value the image of being progressive more than actually being progressive.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#322

Almost 80k/year in salary leaves a family stuck in a garage over there? That's absurd

Currently many Bay Area cities, including ones that are a solid 90 minute drive, have median household incomes in the 75-$125K range. But the payment on a median house is 100% or more of that income. The situation is not yet literally Dickensian, but I don't know it's that far off.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#323

> A spokeswoman for Facebook said none of the company’s contingent or contract workers have access to facilities such as clinics, gyms, or bring-your-child-to-work days One thing I liked about AirBnB was their entire staff including cafeteria workers and security guards were full-time employees who ate the same food, had access to the same facilities and events, and went through the first week 'bootcamp' alongside de…

I don't know if this was a special circumstance, but I shared a table with a security guard during my noogler orientation. That made a similar impact on me (and we stay in touch even now, actually). But, at Google, there is also a strong differentiation between full time employees and everybody else (temps, vendors, contractors), with clear and consistently impressed rules about what non-FTEs are allowed to see and d…

After engineer pressure a few years ago Google opened their cafes and some other amenities to many of their contract staff; they used to be more restricted.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#324

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's the dumbest goddamn thing I've ever heard, least of all because a TV on sale on Black Friday is pretty far from a nice sandwich. This sort of selfish reasoning--"but but but what about the poors that might somehow abuse the system"--is cancerous, and you sir or madam are a shitty person for suggesting it.

We used to allow employees to take home any food left over at the end of the day. Worked great for about 4 months. Then the food cost started creeping up, then it nearly exploded. Seems that the late shift discovered that if they simply made a lot of food right before closing they could take it home so it wouldn't be "wasted". You know it has gotten bad when people are starting to argue about who gets to work the clo…

So, how much were you paying your employees? Were you giving them enough hours? Were they getting tipped-out appropriately?

People aren't shitty just to be shitty--there's usually a reason they find themselves taking advantage of a system.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#325

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I didn't make a misstatement. Both cases have the same problem. The government has stepped in and made it more difficult for you to enter the market. In one case, you have to pay an electrician to take a class because the government won't let you learn for free. In the other case the government has made it even worse because you now have to perform labor at sub-market wages for 4 years before you're allowed to do wor…

There's a difference between the requirements for licensing being excessive and "massive debt".

In both cases the government regulation is making you an indentured servant to incumbent wealth. In one case you're a slave to financiers and the education incumbents and in the other case you're a slave to the labor union who doesn't want you coming in and undercutting them. I'm not interested in debating which one is worse, they're both very similar problems. And neither is necessary.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#326

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's the dumbest goddamn thing I've ever heard, least of all because a TV on sale on Black Friday is pretty far from a nice sandwich. This sort of selfish reasoning--"but but but what about the poors that might somehow abuse the system"--is cancerous, and you sir or madam are a shitty person for suggesting it.

Woah calm down buddy. He's not suggesting anything. He's explaining the reason these policies are in place across the nation. Poor people's number one pasttime is abusing the system for personal gain. Wouldn't you in their situation? If you say no to that you might actually be the first person that "check your privledge" would non ironically apply to that I have met.

> Poor people's number one pasttime is abusing the system for personal gain.

Wow. Just wow.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#327

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As long as we don't confuse what we have right now (corrupt cronyism, corporatism, blatant vertical monopolies, blatant government-backed monopsonies, etc.) with an actual free market.

Yep, it's best not to confuse reality with pipe dreams, generally.

I'm not sure what way that sarcasm is cutting. I'll say the "design the problem away" impulse is partly what causes corporatism and monopolies. For example, regulatory capture in which the regulated industries more or less control the regulators.

So I'll say the regulate-the-problem-away impulse is a pipe dream in the long run.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#328

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Neighboring Atherton has a land use goal of 'preserv[ing] the Town's character as a scenic, rural, thickly wooded residential area with abundant open space.'

Should the residents of the town of Atherton be able to vote and enact policies on how Atherton should evolve? I think they should.

When every city in the bay thinks that way we get a situation where only the lucky get to live here.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#329
post #314

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are excluded from events because they are working not for Facebook, but a food service company that contracts for Facebook. This may be technically true, but ultimately it's just window dressing. And for FB (and many other companies that play the same game with its more expendable workers), a convenient dodge in terms of both expenses and liabilities. If you show up at Facebook's building every morning, work in…

>Let's please not try to compare the "plight" of contract tech workers I don't personally see a difference other than the average wage for what I do. Companies contract other companies for many things. Janitorial, security guards, software work, etc. They shouldn't be involved in the salary of some other company's workers. If there's a wage issue in this case, it's not Facebook's issue to sort it out.

I don't personally see a difference other than the average wage for what I do.

There's this "respect" part, which is one of the major points of the article. And the fact that you apparently don't even see it as an issue -- while those on the other side of the coin insist that it is, in fact, quite a huge issue -- is a great part of what makes it such a huge issue.

If there's a wage issue in this case, it's not Facebook's issue to sort it out.

Right -- it's a matter for the legislators and the courts.

And if Facebook can't, or won't do the right thing for their workers, on this front -- they'll be made to do it.

Re: Cafeteria workers at Facebook struggle to make ends meet

#330

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> At the end of every shift, Nicole watches large amounts of leftover food go into the compost – food that she’s not allowed to take home. On that one in particular - is there a law against that? I know rules on food service workers taking things home vary quite a bit.

There's a lack of law to protect companies from legal liability in case someone gets food poisoning. Once the food leaves campus, the company has no control over packaging, storage, temperature, allergy labeling, etc.

Incorrect.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Emerson_Good_Samaritan_Ac...

Post reply on HN