Live data from Hacker News

A letter to our daughter

facebook.com

321–330 of 555 posts

Re: A letter to our daughter

#321
post #180
post #169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Frankly, I find this is a very cynical approach to the lecture of this letter. Most everyday Joes might not have the means to change the world but it is certain that when turn into billionaire, they rarely pledge the quasi-totality of their fortune to improve the well being of others. If this is narcissistic, just let it be and be appreciate that for once, a great deal of money will be put to good use. The world is f…

Don't know about the Saudi princes however the Koch Brothers have given away millions of dollars (and I am sure there also give away money anonymously as well). http://www.kochfamilyfoundations.org/foundationsdhk.asp Also rest assured that Facebook also "evades taxes" in the same way that the Koch brothers do, that is by taking advantage of the US Tax Code in a legal way. And none of us have any idea what the Koch Br…

[deleted]

Re: A letter to our daughter

#322
post #180
post #169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Frankly, I find this is a very cynical approach to the lecture of this letter. Most everyday Joes might not have the means to change the world but it is certain that when turn into billionaire, they rarely pledge the quasi-totality of their fortune to improve the well being of others. If this is narcissistic, just let it be and be appreciate that for once, a great deal of money will be put to good use. The world is f…

Don't know about the Saudi princes however the Koch Brothers have given away millions of dollars (and I am sure there also give away money anonymously as well). http://www.kochfamilyfoundations.org/foundationsdhk.asp Also rest assured that Facebook also "evades taxes" in the same way that the Koch brothers do, that is by taking advantage of the US Tax Code in a legal way. And none of us have any idea what the Koch Br…

David Koch, worth 44,200 million dollars, is donating literally millions?!? How generous of him to give away approximately 0.002% of his fortune here and there.

Please be serious. This comparison is laughable, the ≈ $300M listed on his foundation is literally 0.7% of his net worth.

Re: A letter to our daughter

#323
post #169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Frankly, I find this is a very cynical approach to the lecture of this letter. Most everyday Joes might not have the means to change the world but it is certain that when turn into billionaire, they rarely pledge the quasi-totality of their fortune to improve the well being of others. If this is narcissistic, just let it be and be appreciate that for once, a great deal of money will be put to good use. The world is f…

While Facebook is not doing everything it can to evade taxation in many countries, right? And let them choose what to do with the money. Why isn't Zuckerberg pledging to drive his company as a good citizen?

Because most tax money is wasted on wars and special interests.

Re: A letter to our daughter

#324

Earlier quoted context omitted.

With Mark, saying and doing are two completely different things. Example: "Helping poor people in third world countries get online" turned out to be: "Deceiving poor people in third world countries into using something called 'Internet' that's actually 'Facebook with apps', and depriving them of real online access." That whole thing ended up being an attack on the free and open web. "Share with friends only" is short…

Looking forward to your multi-billion dollar donation to combat the evil genius of Mark Zuckerberg

[deleted]

Re: A letter to our daughter

#326
post #193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

His Charity is so great- that He simultaneously saves the world's poor while providing fodder for season 3 of Silicon Valley.

If only he had put something in the letter about how the opening of car doors has improved so much in the last 100 years.

We've got cars where the doors go ~~like this~~!

Re: A letter to our daughter

#327

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your question is a good response to the framing of this philanthropy as "giving back". Indeed, if the point of it is to give back, why not simply mold your corporate behemoth into something kinder and gentler. I don't think this sort of thing is about "giving back" however. I think it's something more ambitious than that: to "do something", do something transformative for the future. Though Zuck's manifesto isn't wel…

> Because hoarding up billions of dollars into family dynasties is pretty much doing nothing. Well, his money isn't stuffed under sofa cushions, so it would bankers choosing what to invest in, but your point still stands. ;)

If the wealth is held as stock then there is no "money" for the bankers to do anything with. At best he can borrow money with the stock as collateral and then allow bankers to invest that.

Re: A letter to our daughter

#329

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Either way, if Zuckerburg doesn't live up to his promise, his daughter is going to be as schizophrenic as the world her father helped create.

Parenting style doesn't cause schizophrenia.

It causes latent anxiety issues which can cause drug use which can then then increase chance of mental and physical diseases.

Re: A letter to our daughter

#330

Earlier quoted context omitted.

With Mark, saying and doing are two completely different things. Example: "Helping poor people in third world countries get online" turned out to be: "Deceiving poor people in third world countries into using something called 'Internet' that's actually 'Facebook with apps', and depriving them of real online access." That whole thing ended up being an attack on the free and open web. "Share with friends only" is short…

Looking forward to your multi-billion dollar donation to combat the evil genius of Mark Zuckerberg

The key to refraining from interfering with other's lives is to refrain from interfering with other's lives even that other is trying to interfere with us. Or we would end up just like them.

"The means is the end."

Post reply on HN