Live data from Hacker News

Temptations of an open-source Chrome extension developer (2021)

github.com

311–320 of 374 posts

Re: Temptations of an open-source Chrome extension developer (2021)

#312
post #271
post #262

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I worked at Meta, the execs said that many users think they're being spied on when they see ads based on a conversation they've had in real life, but the execs categorically denied that this could be happening, and said it's all just a coincidence. I thought this was a completely unfounded denial, since Meta had no way of auditing 3rd party apps on the user's phone, and it's perfectly plausible for another app t…

In many cases it’s more than simple: You had the conversation with someone and that someone googled/shopped/amaozned/clicked it. Or did before already, you don’t initiate every conversation in your life after all. Now go and try getting a denial that they are not using the fact that you share a wifi with someone as parts of the recipe for the recommendation cake.

The arrow of causality can also go the other way. X corp is currently running a campaign targeting your area/demographic. A friend of yours sees and X ad and mentions something X-related to you in a private conversation. The next day, you see an X ad too.

Re: Temptations of an open-source Chrome extension developer (2021)

#314
post #94

FWIW, and since a few of you probably use it… I own the JSON Formatter extension [0], which I created and open-sourced 12 years ago and have maintained [1] ever since, with 2 million users today. And I solemnly swear that I will never add any code that sends any data anywhere, nor let it fall into the hands of anyone else who would. I’ve been emailed several tempting cash offers from shady people who presumably want…

I had a JSON Formatter extension steal my browsing history earlier (on Firefox, no less) so this is bittersweet.

Re: Temptations of an open-source Chrome extension developer (2021)

#315
post #262

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I worked at Meta, the execs said that many users think they're being spied on when they see ads based on a conversation they've had in real life, but the execs categorically denied that this could be happening, and said it's all just a coincidence. I thought this was a completely unfounded denial, since Meta had no way of auditing 3rd party apps on the user's phone, and it's perfectly plausible for another app t…

Wdym? You cannot target specific individuals when creating ads on FB/IG?

You could roughly 10 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34780696

And, it looks like that feature still exists: https://www.facebook.com/business/help/170456843145568

"Upload a list of emails to create a custom audience"

Seems easy enough.

Re: Temptations of an open-source Chrome extension developer (2021)

#316
post #12

Can confirm. A couple years ago, I had a Chrome extension with ~100k users; I was receiving these types of emails every week. One of them straight up offered $10k, whether that was a real offer or not I don't know because I never replied to any of them. I've since taken down the extension as I'm no longer maintaining it, but weirdly I still get these emails, albeit less frequently.

I had a legit $13k offer for 180k users recently (even though it looked super shady, and the result for end-users would probably have been gross).

Re: Temptations of an open-source Chrome extension developer (2021)

#317
post #185
post #94

FWIW, and since a few of you probably use it… I own the JSON Formatter extension [0], which I created and open-sourced 12 years ago and have maintained [1] ever since, with 2 million users today. And I solemnly swear that I will never add any code that sends any data anywhere, nor let it fall into the hands of anyone else who would. I’ve been emailed several tempting cash offers from shady people who presumably want…

I've used this extension for years. Thank you for your service. I agree open source users are the worst.

Most of them are lovely really, I was just kidding. I don’t even mind the ungrateful ones these days. The store reviews are like 95% people expressing gratitude, and the rest are people having a very bad day with the pixels and I feel for them

Re: Temptations of an open-source Chrome extension developer (2021)

#318
post #138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> this is what regulations like EU's and CA's should be enforcing. Imagine if the choice was: We have this data about you (a comprehensive list of all the fruits of our creepy stalking: a,b,c,d, etc...), if you let us violate your privacy in a myriad of ways, we will let you have this little trinket for free. Otherwise, it will cost you x. How many people would select privacy violation? Unfortunately under the GDPR w…

It is legal[1] to require users to agree to data collection or pay a subscription. Some news sites have already begun to implement this scheme. [1] At least according to some countries' DPAs, and as long as the price is "fair". https://www.iubenda.com/en/help/24487-cookie-walls-gdpr

> It is legal[1] to require users to agree to data collection or pay a subscription. Some news sites have already begun to implement this scheme.

From your link, almost at the top: "The cookie wall is a mechanism where the user has only one option to access the website: accept the processing of the cookies. The cookie wall is prohibited.". So no, requiring users to agree to data collection, per your article, is prohibited.

Re: Temptations of an open-source Chrome extension developer (2021)

#320
post #262
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The most galling offer we saw on the mobile app side was something that would turn on the user's microphone, and listen for ads on tvs around them to track what they'd been exposed to offline. Adtech is such a thoroughly gross field.

When I worked at Meta, the execs said that many users think they're being spied on when they see ads based on a conversation they've had in real life, but the execs categorically denied that this could be happening, and said it's all just a coincidence. I thought this was a completely unfounded denial, since Meta had no way of auditing 3rd party apps on the user's phone, and it's perfectly plausible for another app t…

"since Meta had no way of auditing 3rd party apps on the user's phone"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onavo

Post reply on HN