Live data from Hacker News

Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

alqst.org

301–310 of 512 posts

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#301

Do they have a choice? It’s either that or they are shown the door, in which case they will probably be replaced by worse local alternatives in terms of freedom of speech and gov influence

> Do they have a choice? Neither the UAE nor Saudi Arabia have extradition treaties with the United States. (On a practical level, they wouldn't be able to enforce one if they had it.)

But they do control the routers that peer with external networks.

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#302

Remember when they told us that social media would "spread democracy" ?

I’ve never heard a single time social media companies say that social media would spread democracy. Sounds like a straw man to me

It’s quite the contrast when you look at Twitter then and X now.

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#304

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sorry if my comment came off dismissive, I was just remarking the idea of banning social media seems like we're going down the wrong alley. I like other commenter's ideas of outlawing the underlying tech. I'm more-so just asking how to make a distinction between a post on Reddit (commonly called social media) and a post on Stack-Overflow (not commonly referred to as social media). Discord vs Teams...etc. I think…

It still reads like a bunch of deflection, which is the usual response from industries from big oil to fast food to tobacco to pharmaceuticals. Delay delay delay and continue reap the profits in the meantime by making people talk in circles instead of addressing the problem. Let Q4 figure it out, just keep the Q2 gravy train rolling. Also, nobody is trying to outlaw math. That's just a silly hyperbolic talking point.

Mate understand I am not the industry trying to deflect, I am a human asking how to clearly define 'social media' to encapsulate all of the sites we consider 'social media' without damaging perfectly fine applications, or if we can come up with a better solution than 'ban it all'.

HN is usually pretty good about brainstorming as a group on topics like these, and I value the insights of others.

I'm a SysAdmin. I'm not about to write the law, just trying to partake in the discussion

Also, the comment I referred to was quite literally talking about banning the use of algorithms to serve content. I'll ask you what that is, if it's not banning math?

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#305

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If it’s legal to eat babies in a country, does it make it morally ok to do it too while visiting?

Then Meta should exit that country.

Meta / Facebook would happily sell advertising for baby eat restaurants and cook books. It is about profit not morality nor even being a good human being.

Need to maximum profits for the share holders. Modern day large scale companies follow the Friedman doctrine, not human decency. [0]. They need that fix of infinite growth, which by doing so become cancerous to society.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#306
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> "Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE" 79 chars.

Saudi Arabia is a city in UAE?

We can't solve the general problem of English syntax ambiguity in a HN headline, but that doesn't mean that we shouldn't try to be precise about the literal names of things

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#307
post #288
post #274

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Iran war is unpopular because of prices at the pump. Prior interventions in Iran (and elsewhere) that also violated rights did not garner the same reaction because to the average American they incurred no cost. If for some reason the war had caused prices to go lower the war would be popular. The fact you think otherwise would lead me to simply conclude you are in denial re the psyche of the American electorate.…

"If they did they would elect different leaders." Like who? Notable candidacies are predicated on million dollar budgets, and pretty much everyone who runs on justice and gets into an office in the US then neuters themselves. It's not a democratic state, and US society has very little tolerance for or understanding of democracy.

If your point is to suggest no alternatives have ever been contemplated then that is simply factually untrue and I think you know that. In some cases, such people succeed locally/statewide even if failing nationally.

My point is simply you don't get to rob the electorate of its agency because you don't like the choice its made. That's about as silly as the grandparent to your comment citing random polls to establish some authoritative notion of what Americans believe.

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#308

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is the exact opposite of what you think. The problem is the governments in those places, and not the private company. The private company would gladly connect everyone.

> The problem is the governments in those places, and not the private company. Do you think Meta will comply if North Korea or Iran requests same censorship? If your answer is "No, they will not comply", then problem is the company

i dont think meta does business in those two countries?

thats not a very relevant comparison.

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#309

Meta is the worst of the worst. I don't use it other than a tombstone account with some family connections and a separate burner account we use for Facebook marketplace.

Do you boycott Apple and Google too? Because they have to comply with debatable laws just as Meta. See drama about Apple maps for Taiwan/China for example.

Re: Meta blocks human rights accounts from reaching audiences in Saudi Arabia, UAE

#310

Do they have a choice? It’s either that or they are shown the door, in which case they will probably be replaced by worse local alternatives in terms of freedom of speech and gov influence

Yes they do. twitter followed way less requests than X does
Post reply on HN