Live data from Hacker News

M5 MacBook Pro

apple.com

301–310 of 579 posts

Re: M5 MacBook Pro

#301

Pretty funny how they're actively targeting M1 users with their marketing copy with this release. Sorry you made your first gen chip so good that I don't feel the need to upgrade lol.

Yeah, I am using a 2020 Macbook Air M1 with macOS 15.7.1 (which I am about to install Ashasi Linux) and I have no issues as a casual user. For most people who use macbooks I see no reason to but an M5 or M4 over an M1.

Re: M5 MacBook Pro

#302

Anyone know when to expect the M5 Pros? I am on a base 16gb M1 and struggling hard in daily workloads. I am often running at 20gb of swap memory usage. I don't really use local LLMs but think 32GB RAM would be good for me... but I am so ready to upgrade but trying to figure out how much longer we need to wait.

First rule of mac world is get the most memory you can afford. I got the cheapest m1 pro (the weird one they sold thats binned due to defects) with 32gb ram and everything runs awesome. Always get the most ram you can in mac world. Running a largish local LLM model is slowish but it does run. A mac out of memory is just a totally different machine than one with. probably because most of the devs building the software…

Part of me misses my OG base 14" M4 Pro. The battery on that thing was absolutely phenomenal - literal 12-14+ hours of real-world use. Not so much on the 14" M1 Max (64GB) that I upgraded to after about 2 yrs.

'Real-world idle' efficiency on the newer chips is the main reason I've got the (slight) itch to upgrade, but 64GB+ MBPs certainly don't come cheap.

Re: M5 MacBook Pro

#303

Pretty funny how they're actively targeting M1 users with their marketing copy with this release. Sorry you made your first gen chip so good that I don't feel the need to upgrade lol.

> Sorry you made your first gen chip so good that I don't feel the need to upgrade M1 MacBooks are ~5 years old at this point, and if you've been working a laptop hard for 5 years it's often worth getting an upgrade for battery life as well as speed.

I still have 94% of my battery health left on my 2020 M1, and I have all the speed I need as a casual, avergae user.

Re: M5 MacBook Pro

#304

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So, maybe don't do business with the worst of them? Of the big 3 in the US, T-Mobile is the one I'd avoid right now.

Verizon is overpriced and is the Comcast equivalent of cellular carriers. AT&T is about as bad

Verizon owns most of the value brands in the US and you made no connection between them and Comcast beyond mentioning them in the same sentence.

AT&T is "about as bad" as what? You gave no information.

Re: M5 MacBook Pro

#305
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

drop $20/month for any LLM and you don't even have to learn it!

LLMs are uniquely bad at writing nix configs I've found. The top models all regularly hallucinate options Really useful for debugging though

Really? This surprises me. I've used them for projects and for my home-manager setup and it's always been amazing at it. The best example I can come up with is packaging a font I needed into a nix package for a LaTeX file. It would have taken me a month of trying various smaller projects to know how to do that.

Re: M5 MacBook Pro

#306
post #177

No WiFi 7 and WiFi 6E only is annoying. Especially for what they are charging. And Bluetooth 5.3, Their Pro Mac are slower than their iPhone Pro. SSD has double the speed. I guess they say this only for M5 MacBook Pro, because the previous M4 has always had slower SSD speed than M4 Pro at 3.5GB/s. So now the M5 should be at 7GB/s. I assume no update on SDXC UHS-III.

The non-pro/max chipped MBPs have always been a little 'lower spec' in several regards. There used to be a little more separation though, with the non-pro chips available only in the Air & 13" MBP, but back then people complained about Apple having 'too many models'...

I suspect the M5 Pro/Max chipped MBPs will bring some of these improvements you're looking for.

Re: M5 MacBook Pro

#307

Pretty funny how they're actively targeting M1 users with their marketing copy with this release. Sorry you made your first gen chip so good that I don't feel the need to upgrade lol.

I have a 2020 Macbook, intel... 2.3 GHz Quad-Core Intel Core i7 is it worth upgrading?

Re: M5 MacBook Pro

#308

Probably great, but when the hell are they going to do another damn colour. Hoping by the time I upgrade from the M4 Pro they'll have a green version and a cell modem.

I wish they'd bring Space Gray back. Not a huge fan of Silver, and the 'Space Black' apparently tends to show smudges more.

Re: M5 MacBook Pro

#309

Earlier quoted context omitted.

M5 Pro and M5 Max will come later with higher RAM support. This has been their staggered release strategy for a while.

I thought the Pro and Max usually get announced at the same time and the Ultra comes later...

Correct. Sometimes much later.

Still no M4 Ultra Studio available.

Re: M5 MacBook Pro

#310
post #303

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Sorry you made your first gen chip so good that I don't feel the need to upgrade M1 MacBooks are ~5 years old at this point, and if you've been working a laptop hard for 5 years it's often worth getting an upgrade for battery life as well as speed.

I still have 94% of my battery health left on my 2020 M1, and I have all the speed I need as a casual, avergae user.

I saw it first on using a device 2 years older than your M1, so you might be in a similar boat soon - but I hope not.

The lower power and heat of M-devices might result in meaningfully longer battery life, and I'm curious to find out.

Post reply on HN