Live data from Hacker News

Mozilla to shut down Pocket and Fakespot

support.mozilla.org

301–310 of 782 posts

Re: Mozilla to shut down Pocket and Fakespot

#301
Dang, like many others I use Pocket extensively - especially with my Kobo e-reader. This is very sad!

I wrote this Deno script to convert the CSV export to a Netscape Bookmark File Format-compatible HTML-file so that it can be imported to Linkding. Hope it's useful for someone else too! https://github.com/enjikaka/pocket-to-bookmark

Re: Mozilla to shut down Pocket and Fakespot

#302
post #90

Well, crap. I've had a Pocket account for more than ten years. It's a key feature on my Kobo devices, to boot. I hope Kobo manages to find some alternative provider for similar functionality, rather than just dropping it altogether. EDIT: Oh, and worth noting that this product will officially die before Mozilla fulfills its promise to open source it, back when they acquired Pocket. Thanks, guys.

I use KOReader [1] on my Kobo. It supports Wallabag [2]. Wallabag offers both hosted [3] and self-hosted options. There's also a standalone kobo client for Wallabag [4]. In addition, Wallabag also supports direct import from Pocket. [1] https://koreader.rocks/ [2] https://wallabag.org/ [3] https://www.wallabag.it/en [4] https://gitlab.com/anarcat/wallabako

Thanks, just set it up via koreader that I already had installed.

Any opinion on using wallabako vs koreader? koreader might involve some more steps to sync it looks like?

Re: Mozilla to shut down Pocket and Fakespot

#303
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

anyone have any good suggestions for a self-hosted option?

I use linkding https://github.com/sissbruecker/linkding Have been hosting it for years, there’s a browser extension and a phone app by a third party developer as well. I also tried readeck for a while but went back to lindking because of missing features https://readeck.org/en/ There’s also linkwarden https://github.com/linkwarden/linkwarden Too colourful for me, can’t like the design And there’s also karakeep https:…

I wrote this Deno script to convert the Pocket CSV export to a Bookmark HTML-file so that it can be imported to Linkding: https://github.com/enjikaka/pocket-to-bookmark

Re: Mozilla to shut down Pocket and Fakespot

#304
> But the way people use the web has evolved, so we’re channeling our resources into projects that better match their browsing habits and online needs

Wasn't Pocket always trying to resist bad web trends? If I recall, they had a tool that would clean up webpages and remove all the junk so you can just focus on the article contents. And they were also trying to save the concept of bookmarking from complete irrelevance. I guess it's understandable that users didn't care, it was an uphill battle for non-power users, and power uses didn't like the sponsored articles and already had their bookmarks saved outside of Pocket.

Re: Mozilla to shut down Pocket and Fakespot

#306

I really enjoyed https://waldenpond.press/ when it was up and running. They selected articles from your pocket once a month and then printed, bound, and mailed them to you. When I discovered the service I had a 500 hour reading backlog, and for $14/mo I was getting 100+ page books of self-curated content. They were perfect for flights, trips, and lending out. I was able to force it to include recipes as well, and I s…

I would have absolutely loved this. I would love for someone to do this with Substack or podcast transcripts.

[dead]

Re: Mozilla to shut down Pocket and Fakespot

#307

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People who are happy about something have no reason to post. You're talking about two entirely different groups of people even though they're all on HN.

That's not true, I sing the praises of things that bring me value all the time. I am, arguably, getting pretty close to "shill" category for some of them. However, I think that behavior should get a pass if the things being shilled are actually FOSS and not just "change from one company to the other"

I think statistically I'm still right. Complaints are always more frequent than positive comments -- and more unsolicited. I always factor that in when reading, for example, product reviews. While there are always people willing to sing the praises of products they like, the average content person is likely to just move on with their lives, and a wronged person cannot wait to tell everyone.

This is also related to Cunningham's Law.

Look at this thread, I've never heard so much positive talk about Pocket in my life. Up until it's imminent demise nobody had any strong inclination to talk positively about it.

Re: Mozilla to shut down Pocket and Fakespot

#308
This sucks :(

I've been using Pocket for I don't know how long. I use it every day during my commute to read articles from everywhere. I was planning on using it on my 3-week multi-country summer vacation this August to occupy me during all the country hopping I was about to do.

This is a Google Reader killing type event for me.

I'm going to go self-hosted next. I'm sick and tired of this crap.

Re: Mozilla to shut down Pocket and Fakespot

#309
post #18

> Your export file will include links (URLs) of your saved items. The export does not extract the text of saved links. Additionally, the export does not contain tags or highlights. boo! without the tags, the links will be mostly useless for me. Every now and then I thought aboyt switching to some self-hosted solution. Should've done it sooner... and I will never trust Mozilla with any service again.

The tags are exported : https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/exporting-your-pocket-l... What is contained in the export file? Your export file will include links (URLs) of your saved items. The export does not extract the text of saved links. Additionally, the export does contain tags or highlights.

The page was "Last updated: 24 minutes ago". Someone at Mozilla saw this HN post and modified it (unsure if the export feature itself was changed or not).

You can tell it's a rushed edit as "Your export file will include links (URLs) of your saved items. The export does not extract the text of saved links. Additionally, the export does contain tags or highlights." reads very unnatural.

Via Wayback Machine, it can be easily verified that the old versions of it, both the one edited very recently or the old ones in 2024, said "does not contain tags or highlights".

https://web.archive.org/web/20250415002842/https://support.m...

https://web.archive.org/web/20250522175656/https://support.m...

Re: Mozilla to shut down Pocket and Fakespot

#310

Mozilla continues to appear to not get the philosophies behind open source. If they really wanted to help people and not simply try to get market share and make money, they'd examine ways to make Pocket itself open source, including the server end of things. "We're handing this over to a non-profit" would be nice.

Looks like much of it is. https://github.com/Pocket

Not sure how complete it is. But appears to have a typescript backend included.

Post reply on HN