Live data from Hacker News

AI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License

suno.com

301–310 of 389 posts

Re: AI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License

#301
post #178

These songs don't have any hooks. Melodies don't get repeated. They all just meander along. I think as they get better at making these great middle of the road songs, edgy music will reemerge. Whatever AI will be good at, will immediately devalue, in the realm of arts. Just how photography gave way to non-realistic art and how drum machines made sloppy drums (or ridiculous apex twins) hip. Then, the artifacts we see…

You can make them have a hook if you structure it right. The default prompt on Suno winds up as "verse, verse 2, chorus" for the structure, which indeed does sort of sound like a song, but not a song at the same time. When I changed things around and put a chorus in twice I wound up getting an actual song with a hook.

I assume the 2 minute limit has a lot to do with this. Often I find Suno generates anywhere between 40 seconds to 2 minutes, with the shorter generations having less of a recognizable structure as a song. If instead it was 3 to 4 minutes, I think it'd be radically different.

Re: AI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License

#302
post #178

These songs don't have any hooks. Melodies don't get repeated. They all just meander along. I think as they get better at making these great middle of the road songs, edgy music will reemerge. Whatever AI will be good at, will immediately devalue, in the realm of arts. Just how photography gave way to non-realistic art and how drum machines made sloppy drums (or ridiculous apex twins) hip. Then, the artifacts we see…

> These songs don't have any hooks. Melodies don't get repeated. They all just meander along.

Isn’t that a consequence of the pasted text, which itself doesn’t repeat?

I checked their homepage and clicked the #1 trending song. It has notation regarding the chorus and verses and the melody does repeat.

https://suno.com/song/c15f0251-fbac-4a30-a3e1-002dbc78cb79/

Re: AI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License

#303
post #287
post #178

These songs don't have any hooks. Melodies don't get repeated. They all just meander along. I think as they get better at making these great middle of the road songs, edgy music will reemerge. Whatever AI will be good at, will immediately devalue, in the realm of arts. Just how photography gave way to non-realistic art and how drum machines made sloppy drums (or ridiculous apex twins) hip. Then, the artifacts we see…

This is your comment as a song: https://suno.com/song/c974b1ca-c69e-47a9-994c-9172fae52927

If they didn't require an account to be able to create a song, I would have started an epic AI song battle right here and and right now :-p

Re: AI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License

#304
post #293

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> When recorded music was invented, musicians protested > we got the synthesizer. Again we got the same complaints I honestly don't believe this happened. Citations? You make it sound like one day there was no recording and then bam! flac quality recordings of musicians, out of the blue. You do realize it started with exceedingly shitty wax cylinders that sounded absolutely atrocious by today standards (and by the pa…

Not the parent but here's one article: >After the release of The Jazz Singer in 1927, all bets were off for live musicians who played in movie theaters. Thanks to synchronized sound, the use of live musicians was unnecessary — and perhaps a larger sin, old-fashioned. In 1930 the American Federation of Musicians formed a new organization called the Music Defense League and launched a scathing ad campaign to fight the…

well:

> live musicians who played in movie theaters

and it wasn't about recorded music, but mechanical pianos

Re: AI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License

#305
post #294
post #259

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I go full dystopian. Elevator music that delivers your compliance trainings in the corporate world...

And requires you to sing-along to reach desired floor.

Sounds like a skit from Bourniston.

Re: AI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License

#306
post #178

These songs don't have any hooks. Melodies don't get repeated. They all just meander along. I think as they get better at making these great middle of the road songs, edgy music will reemerge. Whatever AI will be good at, will immediately devalue, in the realm of arts. Just how photography gave way to non-realistic art and how drum machines made sloppy drums (or ridiculous apex twins) hip. Then, the artifacts we see…

This is suno, udio was just released which is even better and seems to exhibit some edginess. https://x.com/minchoi/status/1778074187778683253?s=46

This will be used for jingles and scoring by low cost studios and marketers. Making money at music was already hard and will only get harder. But maybe this makes sense in a way, music creation just became much easier and accessible to more people.

Alongside this prompt based music creation, we have AI powered autotune and voice masking, which allows even the worst singers to sing perfectly. Popular music was already being retuned during recording and this just makes it easier. In hip hop, old songs beats and verses are getting reused wholesale with little to no modification. See Jack Harlow’s First Class and Tyga’s Bops Goin Brazy. A lot of musical success is now business connections, studio promotion and timing, not being extraordinarily talented. Most rappers now don’t write lyrics down or freestyle, they record a line, pause, record another line, pause , erase the last one, rerecord, and then they’re done. This type of thing an LLM is made for. I think this means less works of art on the ‘radio’ and more garbage music forcefed by studios.

Re: AI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License

#307
post #7

I have to say, I completely lost it at the whisper '(The "Software")' (0:18)... give this tech another year or two and it will be better quality than your average radio song.

Not sure whether I'm being completely serious, but it's already better than most EuroVision songs.

Re: AI-generated sad girl with piano performs the text of the MIT License

#309
post #178

These songs don't have any hooks. Melodies don't get repeated. They all just meander along. I think as they get better at making these great middle of the road songs, edgy music will reemerge. Whatever AI will be good at, will immediately devalue, in the realm of arts. Just how photography gave way to non-realistic art and how drum machines made sloppy drums (or ridiculous apex twins) hip. Then, the artifacts we see…

Your comment seems to presume that AI will not get any better than it is now. Imagine an AI that understands how to create deep, impactful music better than humans do, because it understands how music works at a biochemical level. Imagine it can even predict the dynamics you're describing, about employing "unwanted artifacts" in the music as a way to evolve new genres. It would no longer need to create such obviously…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN