Live data from Hacker News

Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel

surgehq.ai

301–310 of 362 posts

Re: Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel

#301

There are some sites that are so useless and they have never ever helped me once, yet somehow they are always in the top 10 results 1. w3schools 2. pinterest 3. microsoft answers and all microsoft websites actually (it always looks like the person asking the question is asking exactly what i want, but unlike stackexchange, there are seldom any useful answers) 4. all the code clones for SO 5. all alternative to / revi…

W3schools is wonderful, it's got great primers on a whole lot of languages and libraries with concise, clear explanations and examples.

It used to teach people bad coding practices and it had outdated information. It has improved but I am not ready to recommend it to anyone I like.

Re: Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel

#302

There are some sites that are so useless and they have never ever helped me once, yet somehow they are always in the top 10 results 1. w3schools 2. pinterest 3. microsoft answers and all microsoft websites actually (it always looks like the person asking the question is asking exactly what i want, but unlike stackexchange, there are seldom any useful answers) 4. all the code clones for SO 5. all alternative to / revi…

pinterest completely destroyed google images and is now starting to infect duckduckgo

Re: Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel

#303

I know google search is probably not the same as google flights, but I spent a few hours recently (over a few days) using google flights and it was a delight to use compared to the Expedia children. We had a bereavement in the family and had to book multiple independent tickets because we could not travel together. This was just after the Ukraine war started so prices had gone through the roof. Exact number of days w…

I miss Hipmunk, and curse the day Concur bought them.

Same! Their “agony” sorting (basically sorted flights by a combination of # of stops, total hours, and price) was a breakthrough at the time. It seems to be factored into most flight searches today, even though it’s not labeled as such.

Re: Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel

#304
post #280
post #272

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Gah, why do we need another blocking addon? Because previously blocking addons have worked out really well. Why can't this have just been a uBlock Origin list?

https://github.com/quenhus/uBlock-Origin-dev-filter

Thanks! I saw this in a leaf comment of my original comment. Much better.

Re: Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel

#305
post #54

The one thing I wish that Google offered would be the ability to blacklist sites for a period (coud be fixed - say 6 months). So damn annoying when the top search results all lead to shitty SEO-optimised sites that use a whole page to blather on and on, leading to a tiny information nugget at the end. No value, just excellent SEO scamming. As these scam artists get better and better at this, Google gets less and less…

kagi.com allows you to adjust from the results page how often you want to see a page in the results or just block it entirely. I don't think there is a way to temporarily ban though.

Re: Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel

#306
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>"if there are not many good results, maybe I'm not asking the right questions" I used to think this way too, but I've come to realize that Google has turned from a search engine that returns results based on my input to an answer engine that actively tries to reframe whatever I enter into some other more generic query - usually with the intent of selling me something or returning SEO spam. I've also found that the o…

Nowadays you should google using what in 2005 would be considered "the wrong way to search". Back then it was all about keywords, quotes and so on. For example if you wanted to know if dogs could eat apples you'd search: > dog apple dangerous Today you should search: > can dogs eat apples And you get way better results with the second form. I've noticed that people who are stuck thinking that the right way to google…

I think this also indicates why Google seems to have gotten worse at programming questions.

Re: Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel

#307
post #276

Is that because users are starting to use other engines like DDG, meaning google have trouble learning its AI models? I have to say that most of the time, when I search for something related to python, it's difficult to land on the official doc, it's always something like tutorial point or something else, it's annoying. Same thing when I want to land on a wikipedia article. Maybe it would be a cool thing if I could l…

(Disclaimer, work for Neeva), but sounds like we might offer a lot of what you are looking for. We are an ad-free, private search engine. Which means no ads, no affiliate links and you data is not sold or shared. We give users control letting you customize your search result preferences for sources including news, shopping and more. Want more of X? That's your choice. want to see less of Y? That's your choice. We also block third party trackers, let you search across personal apps like dropbox and email all from the same search bar. See for yourself neeva.com

Re: Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel

#309
post #214

I am sure it’s plenty more than these three. Yesterday, I searched "best after-sale service of AC". What I was shown was SEO'd pure junk. Absolute junk as the first result. Next few were the same, but more focused on affiliate programs rather than providing genuine info. Down the line was Quora, where _sales rep of AC companies_ wrote answers that _theirs_ had the best service. I wad very disappointed. You.com showed…

you.com, the search engine you control, huh?

http://shitmyself.com/thumb/thumb_800_5e84542c26a8815f33d767...

Re: Three areas where Google Search lags behind competitors: code, cooking, travel

#310
I'm teaching my partner to drive and I've noticed that Google Maps will suggest very different routes to the same destination. It's also less accurate in estimating times, adding 5-10 minutes for its indirect routes versus taking straight paths.

Another thing I've noticed is that some directions will use businesses ("take a left after McDonald's") as landmarks in navigation. I'm beginning to believe the routing noise was introduced to allow navigational ads.

If the effectiveness of a core product is being compromised for monetization, is this what's also happening to their Search?

Post reply on HN