Earlier quoted context omitted.
There is not faster to way to discredit oneself than to offer a pat, single variable explanation. As others point out, Americans like and want to transport themselves by car. Let's accept this, work with it, and build around it instead of lusting after a minority defined Utopia.
Well said. Another angle is the race angle. Most people advocating for lesser cars are young, healthy, rich and white. Healthy enough to not use cars and rich enough to live near work. https://theconversation.com/the-unbearable-whiteness-of-cycl... The group that talks about systemic racism is perpetuating it.
Why can't we build nice neighborhoods anymore?
301–308 of 308 posts
Re: Why can't we build nice neighborhoods anymore?
#302Earlier quoted context omitted.
I am not an expert on the subject, but I do not think that the explanation for most of what you see in Japan is explained by “good policing”. There was an excellent article on policing in Japan a few years back that I sadly can not remember the outlet of, but I very much remember a sentence that resonated with my experience in Japan which was along the lines of: “It is not because of the quality of its policing, but…
It's a combination of cleanliness, social responsibility, and police presence true but I've also heard what happens when there is a disturbance and it's dealt with quickly either by police or conductors. Someone begging on the train is not tolerated at all. Japanese culture views that as an unacceptable imposition by that individual on the other riders. Western culture tends to shame you in the other direction which…
Re: Why can't we build nice neighborhoods anymore?
#303Earlier quoted context omitted.
> it will never work because crime on American public transport is rampant. Are you sure? I’ve never had that impression across years of transit, bus and rail, in Pittsburgh and Boston. I think the biggest barrier is a chicken and egg problem: it’s hard to motivate transit expansion without dense housing and it’s hard to motivate denser housing except along existing transit corridors
Lol the amount of times I've seen a tweaker snoozing on my septa ride to work or some idiot going "hey I'm sorry to bother you folks but [insert fake sob story]". No thanks. Plus have you noticed there's a pandemic? The last thing I need is to be in a tube with strangers. Do you realize how miserable subway stations in east coast cities can get when the AC is broken? If they even have AC? The whole system would need…
Re: Why can't we build nice neighborhoods anymore?
#304Earlier quoted context omitted.
Lol the amount of times I've seen a tweaker snoozing on my septa ride to work or some idiot going "hey I'm sorry to bother you folks but [insert fake sob story]". No thanks. Plus have you noticed there's a pandemic? The last thing I need is to be in a tube with strangers. Do you realize how miserable subway stations in east coast cities can get when the AC is broken? If they even have AC? The whole system would need…
Did you tell the bother brother to fuck off?
Re: Why can't we build nice neighborhoods anymore?
#305Re: Why can't we build nice neighborhoods anymore?
#306Earlier quoted context omitted.
There seems to be a lot of variability in what architects do and care about. In your last sentence, I feel like you could often replace architect with structural engineer and interior designer with architect in other situations and end up with the same outcome.
Agreed, I know architects who only do interior layouts.
But, as far as I know, they're separate disciplines.
Re: Why can't we build nice neighborhoods anymore?
#307For some reason the vast majority of houses are ugly for the following reasons: the proportions are off. I mean, I understand the need to have smaller lots. But, if you're going to have a small 3K sq ft lot then you need to limit the width of the house to allow at least 20' on each side and raise the height of the house to two stories, if it's more than 800 sq ft. Another big reason for ugliness is the extremely shal…
> Another big reason for ugliness is the extremely shallow and underdefined rooflines typical of ranch house style. You need to have steep well defined rooflines that give the house shape. These are clearly conservative preferences, not objective truths. Like social conservatism, there are valuable learnings embodied (steep roofs shed water -- more important in some climates than others), but there is also a lot of f…
Traditional Chinese housing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siheyuan#/media/File:Siheyuan_...
Traditional Japanese housing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sukiya-zukuri#/media/File:Shoi...
A style of traditional African housing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Architecture_of_Africa#/media/... (and many more are like it)
Slanted roofs are super common throughout the world and history.
Re: Why can't we build nice neighborhoods anymore?
#308Earlier quoted context omitted.
North American houses from my UK perspective: - Detached no matter the cost - so close they may as well be terraced, but they'll be detached 'gah-damnit'! - Garage in front. I.. ok. Practical I suppose. Bloody ugly. - Fake shutters!! I'm mentioning it last but it bugs me the most. At least have them wide enough that they look like they might be usable. But no, inch-wide 'shutters' on a six-foot window, why not.
> Detached no matter the cost - so close they may as well be terraced, but they'll be detached 'gah-damnit'! The difference between "so close" and "terraced" is hearing your neighbors fucking at night. No thanks. Agree with you about the shutters, though...