Live data from Hacker News

Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app

abc.net.au

301–310 of 361 posts

Re: Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app

#301

I wonder how much crime would be left if the drug trade were legalized

Black markets exist and are extensive for products that are available through legal means.

To a much lesser extent though. I cannot think of any time I've used a black market for something that was otherwise available on the regular market.

It's not common, and not very profitable.

Re: Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app

#302
post #11

So the big question is if would have been better to strike fast, silently gain more intel och strike in some kind of statistical analysis maner to not blow their cover á la Alan Turing and the enigma

Well, in hindsight, this is not a big question any more, they are all in jail now and will drag most of the supply and micro distribution chain with them. More careful actors are still out there and conducting business as usual. I have read a book on one of the main Italian groups, they have very efficient micro storage procedures to avoid big losses and at least the higher ups will not use phones or computers, they will meet in person. They have or used to have rules of conduct which are very strict, like, stay home with family and don't be seen in bars etc. The opposite of the green horns flaunting the cars and watches, or the Turkish guys wife documenting their lifestyle on Instagram up until yesterday. Sure, mass arrests happen in Italy as well, and some other countries the whole network works different. But using phones is too dangerous and it is avoidable to run efficient logistics. Not only for traceability, but a compromised or confiscated phone will have a lot of let's say problematic evidence on it. Even the Mexican and Colombian groups operate from remote areas, even if affiliated with some parts of governments. I think the usage of digital devices is just lazyness, another attribute like the flaunting of the illicit gains.

Re: Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app

#304
post #43

The Australian Broadcasting Corporation is covering it in more detail than the Reuters article, including some of the mechanics of how it was pulled off: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-08/fbi-afp-underworld-cr... Apparently it revolved around duping Hakan Ayik, one of Australia's most wanted drug dealers now operating as an international kingpin from Turkey, to trust the app and recommend it to his associates. I…

Many times it comes out much much later that the kingpins were in on it. The spy world equivalent of the double agent.

Re: Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app

#305
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So they got to this most wanted man and instead of arresting him they fed him an app to help catch all his buddies while at the same time put a target on his back? Pretty daring move.

It seems like kind of an evil move for law enforcement to put a target on his back like that. But I assume all of the bad guys knew which guy was pushing the phones, so he was probably going to be a target no matter what.

>> It seems like kind of an evil move for law enforcement to put a target on his back like that.

This is actually a very old method of getting criminals to cooperate with law enforcement.

The FBI used to do this with mob guys all the time in the 1980's. Show up, arrest them publicly, put out false newspaper articles saying he was close to flipping. He starts getting heat from the outfit and sooner or later, distrust is sown and suddenly he becomes a marked man. Word gets back to him they put a hit on him, or things get dicey with the underbosses and suddenly, he's like a cat in a cage with nowhere to go - so he turns on his associates in order to save his own life.

Cops used to do the same thing with low level drug dealers. Pressure them to flip on their supplier by pseudo arresting them, taking him away. They'd drive around a bit, then drop him off without cuffs in the middle of the neighborhood in broad daylight. Word gets around what happened, and suddenly the heat gets turned up because now he was seen getting out of a cop car with no cuffs? Must mean he's turned informant. Same thing, he gets too much heat and feels he needs to save himself and flips anyways.

Re: Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app

#306

This is how police should get around the problems presented with encryption. This is real policing. The PR barrage and faux posturing by the FBI to weaken encryption has always seemed like just lazy policing to me. If anything, the hacking attacks on industrial centers has better illustrated than anything why encryption is necessary, and this new triumph has demonstrated that police can continue to function, even thr…

> This is how police should get around the problems presented with encryption.

By adding a backdoor to E2E encryption? That is pretty much what they have been asking for :)

Amazing that criminals still pick some unknown device over an existing solution with a proven track record.

This is not the first time something like this has happened:

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EncroChat

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sky_Global

Re: Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app

#307

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It seems like kind of an evil move for law enforcement to put a target on his back like that. But I assume all of the bad guys knew which guy was pushing the phones, so he was probably going to be a target no matter what.

>> It seems like kind of an evil move for law enforcement to put a target on his back like that. This is actually a very old method of getting criminals to cooperate with law enforcement. The FBI used to do this with mob guys all the time in the 1980's. Show up, arrest them publicly, put out false newspaper articles saying he was close to flipping. He starts getting heat from the outfit and sooner or later, distrust…

Fun.. I guess that's one way to figure out if someone is guilty or not. Either he's innocent and nothing happens or he's guilty and he dies or flips. The whole side stepping the judge/jury to go straight to the executioner part seems like it should violate some kind of law.

Re: Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app

#308

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>> It seems like kind of an evil move for law enforcement to put a target on his back like that. This is actually a very old method of getting criminals to cooperate with law enforcement. The FBI used to do this with mob guys all the time in the 1980's. Show up, arrest them publicly, put out false newspaper articles saying he was close to flipping. He starts getting heat from the outfit and sooner or later, distrust…

Fun.. I guess that's one way to figure out if someone is guilty or not. Either he's innocent and nothing happens or he's guilty and he dies or flips. The whole side stepping the judge/jury to go straight to the executioner part seems like it should violate some kind of law.

I think it is more accurate to say that this is simply a risk of engaging in activities with people who will kill you if they think you will tell the truth.

Re: Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app

#309

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Russia and China would in fact be a better solution as most Westerners are never going to be subject to Russian or Chinese authorities.

Sure until you visit a geopolitically aligned airport and get detained and propositioned by a foreign intelligence agency. Then you end up spying against your own country because your VPN provider was just a honeypot for a foreign intelligence agency. Blackmail, forced detention, "crimes against the Chinese state", jail without due process or civil rights, who knows. Maybe you didn't even break US law but Chinese or…

That stuff already happens to people in the West, and people who visit non-Western but Western aligned countries. The fact of the matter is that if you are a Westerner, you are going to spend more time in the Western sphere of influence, of which Russia and China are not a part of.

Re: Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app

#310
post #70

What we've learned is only what was in Austrlia's piece of the cake, given they started their day already. New Zeland had theirs already, too. I imagine thousands of arrests are still happening worldwide and several press conferences are going to be held today. Looking at the seal of the operation ( https://www.anom.io/trojan_shield_seal.jpg ), following countries participated in the operation: Canada, Australia, US,…

> I expect this to be bigger than Panama Papers. Way bigger. I expect a few prominent politicians to be soon either arrested or "convinced" to step down. I highly doubt it. The main drug operations run with state approval. If anything this was just an attempt to either clean the country from competition or just keep law enforcement busy. If you read the reports, what they have collected, this is nothing if you compar…

> If you read the reports, what they have collected, this is nothing if you compare what kind of volumes are being moved every day.

I saw this. Watched the whole Europol conference. Those numbers are indeed low: 9 tons of cocain, 5 tons of cannabis/hashish. Some guns and 15m USD, if I remember correctly.

I still don't think I exaggerated. There's no way that's all they got from it after 3 years of eavesdropping. There's just no way that those tens of thousands of messages only incriminated some drug lords. What they did with these press conferences was a pure PR, they just wanted something for the press, but I still believe that the actual aftermath of this will much larger.

Post reply on HN