Live data from Hacker News

Coming to Chrome: a new way to use tabs

blog.google

301–310 of 392 posts

Re: Coming to Chrome: a new way to use tabs

#301

It’s sad that operating systems gave up, before even trying to, to properly organize content with windows managers. There’s really no good reason why browser needs to have tabs, and have that exclusive ecosystem, not available to rest of the apps on the system. I’d love to be able to group and manage my windows as easily as tabs.

You could give Groupy a shot...

https://www.stardock.com/products/groupy/

Re: Coming to Chrome: a new way to use tabs

#302
post #230

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm always constantly over 100. It mostly spirals out of control when deep in research and going down the rabbit hole.

I'm curious, wouldn't you read the info and process it in your mind, and then close the tab when done? If it's something you will need to reference again later, then bookmark it? Like you know... a book. Put it back on the shelf or have hundreds of books open on the floor. I do not understand tab people. I do have a meticulously organized bookmark system though. Do tab people use bookmarks much at all?

No because it's more transient. I'm diving into a topic, opening a few different sources, then following links from those sources into further tabs. But I try to roughly group them in windows so I can just close out the window when I'm done with the topic.

Re: Coming to Chrome: a new way to use tabs

#303

This is fixing the wrong problem. Tabs aren't broken, browser history is. When I tried to find a web page from a certain date a few months ago, it was almost impossible to find. I actually think Internet Explorer used to have quite a good history. That's what we need, not better tabs management.

Really? Chrome's history search tools are very good, and it's just a SQLite file. I've only had to break out the SQL queries once, but it allowed me to find something very specific. Take a look here: https://gist.github.com/dropmeaword/9372cbeb29e8390521c2

Re: Coming to Chrome: a new way to use tabs

#304

Earlier quoted context omitted.

With the first party isolate, mechanisms such as oAuth would not work. So the containers are less restrictive, but still allow you to have two sites with the same cookie context.

I've been using first party isolation for quite a while on desktop and Android and the only websites I experienced issues with are the Atlassian login and the Trello GitHub powerup. Everything else, including tons of single sign in/OAuth websites, work without any issue.

Yep, ditto Atlassian. There's a big thread of people complaining about it on their forums too.

Unfortunately of course it'll always be a minority, and won't affect whether even those people (have to) use Jira or whatever, so not really any incentive for Atlassian to fix it.

Re: Coming to Chrome: a new way to use tabs

#305
post #195
post #106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Shameless plug, but Vivaldi does this and so much more natively...since beta however many years ago. Haven't touched firefox since.

I'm not aware of Vivaldi having functionality similar to Firefox containers. Please elaborate.

Vivaldi Profiles. Only difference is that in Vivaldi each Profile use separate window (as far as I know).

Re: Coming to Chrome: a new way to use tabs

#307
Nothing can beat Tree Style tab in Firefox. You can make "folders of tabs" and whole hierarchies. For "tabs collectors" like me who have 40 tabs always open this is a must.

My current setup : I have 5 pinned tab on top of the tree.

Below I have a "github" group of tabs.

Below I have a set of tabs opened on different parts of an app I'm working on.

Below is a group of documentation tabs.

Below is another group of articles I plan to read at some point.

Below I have the HN tab, with a tree of articles and comments.

I can't imagine going back to horizontal tabs. This is just much too good.

Re: Coming to Chrome: a new way to use tabs

#308

I just want the title bar back, above the tabs, on the mac. It's so frustrating trying to move/select the window with a tiny sliver available to click on.

Top right seems to always have space. You can also drag any window from any side by dragging perpendicular to the resize direction. It’s still small but I never heard anyone complain about precision there. And then there’s window manager if you’re a power user. I also think you can move any window with three finger via system settings.

> Top right seems to always have space.

Top right isn't always visible when trying to click a window to bring it forward

> You can also drag any window from any side by dragging perpendicular to the resize direction. It’s still small but I never heard anyone complain about precision there.

Interesting, I hadn't seen that before. It's still a small space and annoying to grab, but it's better than now knowing about it.

> And then there’s window manager if you’re a power user.

Not sure what you mean here.

> I also think you can move any window with three finger via system settings.

I use a mouse and full keyboard. I've never been able to interact with the mac well without them.

Re: Coming to Chrome: a new way to use tabs

#309
See this is a good idea but suffers from a UX problem: it is just way too cumbersome to create a new group and add new tabs.

When I am on a roll I just want to hotkey a new tab open an start typing a search query for something. ctrl-t and type is just too fast and keeps me in the zone.

What if they added a new hotkey for opening a new tab in a new group? ctrl-g is taken, so something like ctrl-shift-g? Whatever it is, you get the point. Open a new tab in a new group. All tabs opened from a group stay in that group.

So, say I open a new tab group to search for something in google. I then read through the results and middle-click several items to open in new tabs. All those tabs should stay in the group. That way I can easily jump around to other tab groups and see what group had all the references to my question. I can then do this for several topics and keep things straight.

Re: Coming to Chrome: a new way to use tabs

#310

Maybe I'm wrong (EDIT: seems I'm wrong!), but I feel like the people with dozens of tabs open (guilty) aren't the ones who use organizational features? Also, it's a hidden feature, but you can already Shift+Select a group of tabs, and close/move/etc the whole group.

Move them where? I'd love to be able to right-click and move to a designated browser window because I use window titler so each window has a subject name. In firefox you can only move the tabs to a new window.
Post reply on HN