Live data from Hacker News

Apple Watch Series 5

apple.com

301–310 of 491 posts

Re: Apple Watch Series 5

#301
Am I correct that if a Watch user goes far away from his/her phone, receives a SMS during that period of time, and then comes back, the notification is never shown on the Watch?

If so, how come this is not a #1 issue Apple needs to address? The Watch is then unreliable for notifications and doesn’t eliminate the need to check the phone from time to time. I’m amazed this is not talked about.

Re: Apple Watch Series 5

#302
post #213

"International emergency calling also works with fall detection, if enabled, to automatically place an emergency call if Apple Watch senses the user has taken a hard fall and remains motionless for about a minute." I like how they have thought, don't need a sim to make an emergency call, let alone credit, why not add the ability to call emergency services and use the GPS to pick the right local number. Equally the sa…

I'm pretty sure that fall detection only activates when it senses rapid acceleration. Just because you stop moving doesn't mean you'll trigger fall detection.

Re: Apple Watch Series 5

#303
post #259

Earlier quoted context omitted.

18 hours is a practical level for smart watch battery. That way users will recharge it every night and never run out during the day. 24 hours means that people will sleep with it and forget to charge in the morning -> annoyed users. 36 hours would require charging every other night, but then you'd miss every other night's sleep tracking -> annoyed users. There's really no way for Apple to win, unless they jump up to…

Honestly, all I want is something that I can put on charge once during the day, for 30 minutes while showering, and have it last until the following nights shower. I want it to track sleep, and monitor health. That's it at least. My Fitbit Versa works perfectly for this, and hey, it has a bonus that if I forget to charge it one night or over a weekend, it still lasts! No interrupted heartrate monitoring or sleep trac…

That's what I used to do with my Pebbles. I recently tried an Android Wear watch (TicWatch C2) for a few months, and it failed to live up to my expectations for battery life. I'm now using a Fitbit Ionic, and it fits the bill quite nicely.

Re: Apple Watch Series 5

#304
post #266

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hoping one day it can be a standalone device With all the watchOS 6 stuff that makes it more independent (App Store on watch, iPhone-less apps, etc), I was thinking this might be the year. Oh well, bet it happens next year.

I don't think it will ever happen if I'm honest. Would take away from iPhone sales.

I think this depends on whether other manufacturers go that route. Apple would rather have their own Watch cannibalize iPhone sales than some Android Wear gadget.

Re: Apple Watch Series 5

#305
post #144
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was the polished stainless that I liked though, and that’s not there.

It says they have stainless in silver. Pretty sure that means polished. They said polished on stage.

Yup, I think they specifically referred to polished steel in the keynote as well.

Re: Apple Watch Series 5

#306

This is a big let down for me. I love endurance sports and currently use a S3+LTE with bluetooth headphones and it's the perfect running companion. I don't have to carry anything to track to run and listen to my music, podcasts, or audiobooks. But I was really expecting more innovation from the "by innovation only" event. Garmin's flagship watch has a feature that extends the battery life by embedded TWO SOLAR PANELS…

Is it really innovative, though? Solar-powered digital watches have been around for nearly fifty years.

Re: Apple Watch Series 5

#307
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I quite like the idea of a smart watch, but having to charge it every day is much less appealing.

You pretty much throw it on the charger when you put down your wallet when getting home. I put it down when I get home, wear it to sleep, charge it again when I wake up and shower, then wear it all day. It's a few seconds added to my routine.

Same. This is something I wouldn't have anticipated before buying the watch. Somehow, my habit formed around charging it when it needs charge rather than overnight.

Re: Apple Watch Series 5

#308
post #213

"International emergency calling also works with fall detection, if enabled, to automatically place an emergency call if Apple Watch senses the user has taken a hard fall and remains motionless for about a minute." I like how they have thought, don't need a sim to make an emergency call, let alone credit, why not add the ability to call emergency services and use the GPS to pick the right local number. Equally the sa…

I'm pretty sure that fall detection only activates when it senses rapid acceleration. Just because you stop moving doesn't mean you'll trigger fall detection.

Everyone knows what you mean, but the technically accurate account is that during normal use or while sitting still on a desk, the device's accelerometer registers an acceleration of approximately 1 g directed towards the center of the earth, and when the phone starts falling, the acceleration drops to approximately 0.

(Then the acceleration will asymptotically approach 1 g again as the device's velocity approaches terminal velocity, but well before then the software will have determined that the device is in free fall.)

Re: Apple Watch Series 5

#309

Am I correct that if a Watch user goes far away from his/her phone, receives a SMS during that period of time, and then comes back, the notification is never shown on the Watch? If so, how come this is not a #1 issue Apple needs to address? The Watch is then unreliable for notifications and doesn’t eliminate the need to check the phone from time to time. I’m amazed this is not talked about.

All messages including iMessages or just green SMS texts? In general if you're not on a cellular model then it's supposed to show you notifications once you reenter the range of your paired iPhone. The only Messages bugs I've seen on developer betas are related to how read receipts are shown in Activity workout replies.

Re: Apple Watch Series 5

#310

Am I correct that if a Watch user goes far away from his/her phone, receives a SMS during that period of time, and then comes back, the notification is never shown on the Watch? If so, how come this is not a #1 issue Apple needs to address? The Watch is then unreliable for notifications and doesn’t eliminate the need to check the phone from time to time. I’m amazed this is not talked about.

If your watch has WiFi or Cellular connectivity while away from iPhone, it will show you the notification, and will even let us reply (iMessage)
Post reply on HN