Live data from Hacker News

Anti-intellectualism in American Culture

news.ycombinator.com

31–39 of 39 posts

Re: Anti-intellectualism in American Culture

#31
post #6
post #4

Given the prevalence of "college is for suckers" comments in this forum, I'm surprised that you need to ask.

Little known fact: the mortarboard, or "thinking cap", grants all college graduates uncanny powers of logic and memory. It is impossible to become an intellectual without one.

So if I just buy the mortarboard, I don't need all that fancy book learnin'...

Re: Anti-intellectualism in American Culture

#32
post #4

Given the prevalence of "college is for suckers" comments in this forum, I'm surprised that you need to ask.

Being hostile to the college system is not the same thing as opposition to book learnin' in general. I always liked books -- I just don't like paying thousands of dollars to people who give me crappy books and make me listen to them talk for hours and hours a day. I suppose good college is not for suckers -- but when I say "college is for suckers" I mean most college is for suckers.

Re: Anti-intellectualism in American Culture

#33
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From the executive summary at the link I provided: "And despite all the stories about the erosion of U.S. manufacturing primacy, the United States remains the world's most prolific manufacturer--producing two and a half times more output than those vaunted Chinese factories in 2006."

Too bad no one wants it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_current_ac...

Hardly: the US exports more than $1 trillion USD of goods per year. The fact that it imports more than that doesn't mean that "no one wants US exports", or that the US "has essentially lost its production capability". Your argument would be more persuasive if you cut out the hyperbole.

Re: Anti-intellectualism in American Culture

#34
post #31
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Little known fact: the mortarboard, or "thinking cap", grants all college graduates uncanny powers of logic and memory. It is impossible to become an intellectual without one.

So if I just buy the mortarboard, I don't need all that fancy book learnin'...

Don't even need no mortarboard if your head's already flat.

Re: Anti-intellectualism in American Culture

#36
post #3

I don't know what you want to discuss, really. Yes, there is a strange element of anti-intellectualism in America. It stems from its form of capitalism and it's a shame really, because America has essentially lost its production capability, so if it doesn't compete intellectually, it's not going to compete at all.

> a strange element of anti-intellectualism in America There is a healthy distrust of elites claiming authority on the basis of intellect and education. "We are in charge because we're smarter than you and know how to take care of you" really does fly in a lot of other countries. Call it "Mandarinism"; its hallmark is examinations and elite institutions. In America, opposition to this sort of thing goes back to the d…

I'm an American living in various countries in Europe for the last 12 years, and really, there's a difference. Americans have a wonderful distrust of those claiming authority. But there is also a lack of respect for education and intelligence. Americans worship the rich, not how they got there. They venerate Bill Gates and Steve Jobs, not Alan Kay or Steve Wozniak.

Trust me, there really is a strange element of anti-intellectualism in America.

Re: Anti-intellectualism in American Culture

#37
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From the executive summary at the link I provided: "And despite all the stories about the erosion of U.S. manufacturing primacy, the United States remains the world's most prolific manufacturer--producing two and a half times more output than those vaunted Chinese factories in 2006."

Too bad no one wants it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_current_ac...

It's not that they don't want what we produce. It's that they are stupid enough to trade us stuff for our fiat pieces of paper that we send in exchange that they hold in reserve.

Re: Anti-intellectualism in American Culture

#38
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Too bad no one wants it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_current_ac...

Hardly: the US exports more than $1 trillion USD of goods per year. The fact that it imports more than that doesn't mean that "no one wants US exports", or that the US "has essentially lost its production capability". Your argument would be more persuasive if you cut out the hyperbole.

Ok, I'm being dramatic. But that export number includes, for example, when Ford produces a car in Mexico, with Mexican labor, and sells it in Mexico.

We've been outsourcing not just blue-collar work, but more and more white-collar work as well. While this is essentially inevitable, it will, in the end, demote America to a second-world country, divided into starkly wealthy areas and dirt poor areas.

Re: Anti-intellectualism in American Culture

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> a strange element of anti-intellectualism in America There is a healthy distrust of elites claiming authority on the basis of intellect and education. "We are in charge because we're smarter than you and know how to take care of you" really does fly in a lot of other countries. Call it "Mandarinism"; its hallmark is examinations and elite institutions. In America, opposition to this sort of thing goes back to the d…

I'm an American living in various countries in Europe for the last 12 years, and really, there's a difference. Americans have a wonderful distrust of those claiming authority. But there is also a lack of respect for education and intelligence. Americans worship the rich, not how they got there. They venerate Bill Gates and Steve Jobs, not Alan Kay or Steve Wozniak. Trust me, there really is a strange element of anti-…

> I'm an American living in various countries

I've lived in various countries over 8 years and am otherwise well travelled. I say there's no difference. The popular media is a bit more dumbed down in the US, but that's no reflection of the intellectual pursuits of people in general.

Post reply on HN