Live data from Hacker News

Kisha – The umbrella you'll never lose

getkisha.com

31–40 of 55 posts

Re: Kisha – The umbrella you'll never lose

#31

Isn't this just putting a Tile [1] (or any number of other BLE devices) on an umbrella? [1] https://www.thetileapp.com/

Actually no, because the use case is quite different. We wanted to create an umbrella that really has an app that helps. With Tile, you would just get the location feature, without the weather forecast

A person named Goran who created a smart umbrella called "Kisha" - rain in srbo-croatian. The world makes sense :)

Re: Kisha – The umbrella you'll never lose

#32

Isn't this just putting a Tile [1] (or any number of other BLE devices) on an umbrella? [1] https://www.thetileapp.com/

Actually no, because the use case is quite different. We wanted to create an umbrella that really has an app that helps. With Tile, you would just get the location feature, without the weather forecast

I have Tile, and I also have Phillips Hue lightbulbs, which I currently have hooked up to email and social media alerts, but, if I felt so inclined, I could easily connect to a weather forecast. Or... I could just have a weather alert app on my phone (I'm sure there are tons of them).

Current technology has already solved the generic version of this problem. What you've done is solve this problem again, but only for a very specific use case, while requiring the user to buy in to a bunch of specific software and overhead that only helps them in that specific use case.

Re: Kisha – The umbrella you'll never lose

#33
post #7

I really am not so sold on the idea of having to charge my umbrella... I do wish you all the success though!

You don't need to charge the umbrella, just replace the battery on the beacon.

Awesome, now I'll just add "replace umbrella batteries" on the list of things I have to remember to do every 6 months or so.

Re: Kisha – The umbrella you'll never lose

#34

At first I thought it was an umbrella... Than I thought it was an app that tells you when it's going to rain... Which led me to believe it could be some sort of satire... Then at the bottom is an actual umbrella, so now I'm thinking it's a weather app AND umbrella? and NOT satire? No idea, but I already have numerous weather apps, and an umbrella in my car.

And none of those put together cost you $60. These were my thoughts exactly!

Re: Kisha – The umbrella you'll never lose

#35
post #13

I can't love this. It seems there is a flood of new products that allow you to track or remember them. This can't be sustainable in the long run, as each product uses it's own proprietary technology, that requires you to use a specific app. Fast-forward 5-10 years. Do I want 30 apps on my phone that track the various things I may or may not bring with me? Nope. That would be very annoying, indeed.

>own proprietary technology

Surely they should all use BLE or similar? If umbrella disconnects (you're outside the 15-25m range), give an alert. If using BLE, the protocol is essentially open and other apps could build around it.

Re: Kisha – The umbrella you'll never lose

#36
I think a better product would be to create a band you can wrap around your own umbrella that does the same thing. Of course, it could be for anything at that point and that is often more difficult to market whereas losing an umbrella is a fairly normal problem.

Just my (unrequested) two cents.

Re: Kisha – The umbrella you'll never lose

#39
I'm curious what issues of false-positives and false-negatives this might have. Did I actually remember my umbrella, but the app hasn't updated the location it knows of the umbrella yet, so it starts bugging me to go back? Did I forget to turn the app on, so I leave my umbrella behind, feeling secure that I'll receive a reminder that is never going to come? Do I just plain forget my phone sometimes?

Without some way to guarantee a low failure rate, I can see something like this getting so annoying that I'd just turn it off completely.

And besides, I thought only people who rarely needed rain gear used umbrellas. The last time I visited Portland, or Ireland, I didn't see anyone with umbrellas. Everyone wore rain jackets. Incidentally, they keep your hands free.

Re: Kisha – The umbrella you'll never lose

#40

At first I thought it was an umbrella... Than I thought it was an app that tells you when it's going to rain... Which led me to believe it could be some sort of satire... Then at the bottom is an actual umbrella, so now I'm thinking it's a weather app AND umbrella? and NOT satire? No idea, but I already have numerous weather apps, and an umbrella in my car.

Same here. Except when I first read the headline I read it as "Kisha - The umbrella you'll never use."
Post reply on HN