Live data from Hacker News

Online Labs – ARM servers in the cloud

labs.online.net

31–40 of 41 posts

Re: Online Labs – ARM servers in the cloud

#32

I think the big use case for ARM in datacenters, over the next few years, is for servers whose CPU usage is very low today--they're consistently network-bound or they just act as a relatively dumb interface to RAM or disk (memcached, some distributed DBs, some dumb proxies). Baidu uses ARM for cloud storage, Facebook used AMD servers for memcached despite their lagging Intel on speed. Basically, you look elsewhere wh…

This Marvell SOC has 16 Serdes integrated inside the SOC can be partition to Gige ethernet, SATA, or PCIe in any numbers of ways.

http://www.marvell.com/embedded-processors/armada-xp/

Along with low power, make it very interesting.

I can see someone put 64, 128 of them in 1U chassis. This might be interesting low cost system for someone who need simulcast live video streams to millions of users at really low cost.

"64 4 cores CPU each with integrated 16 GIGE ports for fan out live video stream that potentially fit inside 1U chassis"

Re: Online Labs – ARM servers in the cloud

#33

Isn't the whole point of "the cloud" to abstract away the specific hardware you're using?

Nope, the cloud is about automation and self-service.

If the provider tells you what you're getting you can always ignore that information if you don't care. But some customers care about hardware specifics.

Re: Online Labs – ARM servers in the cloud

#36
Not impressive at all. Performance is not different from RK3188. Disk speed is also not impressing. Not good example of ARM server.

I wonder what advantages this product have if any?

                          | Online Net   | RK3188
  Coremark (single)       | 3288.391976  | 4745.333755
  Coremark (dual cpu)     | 6579.488445  | 8505.209441
  Coremark (4-cpu)        | 12985.958932 | 13930.001741
  dhrystones              | 3204101.2    | 5810575.0
  linpack_dp              | 96396.624    | 280673.07
  linpack_sp              | 141666.344   | 286485.812
  nbench ASSIGNMENT       | 5.4852       | 11.569
  nbench BITFIELD         | 1.8627e+08   | 3.1242e+08
  nbench FOURIER          | 4346.6       | 9248.2
  nbench FP EMULATION     | 94.734       | 143.8
  nbench HUFFMAN          | 1035         | 1444.5
  nbench IDEA             | 2035.4       | 1963.3
  nbench LU DECOMPOSITION | 183.26       | 459.03
  nbench NEURAL NET       | 8.0897       | 13.392
  nbench NUMERIC SORT     | 573.47       | 733.99
  nbench STRING SORT      | 56.463       | 108.94
  scimark Composite Score | 113.53       | 230.20
  scimark FFT             | 121.34       | 199.90
  scimark LU              | 92.63        | 279.92
  scimark MonteCarlo      | 64.20        | 81.53
  scimark SOR             | 191.28       | 420.49
  scimark Sparse matmult  | 98.23        | 169.17
  stream Add              | 1239.3447    | 1615.2325
  stream Copy             | 1168.6045    | 1147.0347
  stream Scale            | 926.4318     | 1599.6019
  stream Triad            | 1066.3372    | 1528.7064
  stream_omp Add          | 3159.7990    | 1271.3516
  stream_omp Copy         | 2603.3387    | 1193.8474
  stream_omp Scale        | 2372.8052    | 1653.1527
  stream_omp Triad        | 2595.0168    | 1245.1069

Re: Online Labs – ARM servers in the cloud

#37

I think the big use case for ARM in datacenters, over the next few years, is for servers whose CPU usage is very low today--they're consistently network-bound or they just act as a relatively dumb interface to RAM or disk (memcached, some distributed DBs, some dumb proxies). Baidu uses ARM for cloud storage, Facebook used AMD servers for memcached despite their lagging Intel on speed. Basically, you look elsewhere wh…

This Marvell SOC has 16 Serdes integrated inside the SOC can be partition to Gige ethernet, SATA, or PCIe in any numbers of ways. http://www.marvell.com/embedded-processors/armada-xp/ Along with low power, make it very interesting. I can see someone put 64, 128 of them in 1U chassis. This might be interesting low cost system for someone who need simulcast live video streams to millions of users at really low cost. "6…

128 Armada cores in 1U is nearly impossible due to cooling issues.

Re: Online Labs – ARM servers in the cloud

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This Marvell SOC has 16 Serdes integrated inside the SOC can be partition to Gige ethernet, SATA, or PCIe in any numbers of ways. http://www.marvell.com/embedded-processors/armada-xp/ Along with low power, make it very interesting. I can see someone put 64, 128 of them in 1U chassis. This might be interesting low cost system for someone who need simulcast live video streams to millions of users at really low cost. "6…

128 Armada cores in 1U is nearly impossible due to cooling issues.

May be not for Armada, but most of cell phone ARM cpu, the power is 1-2 watts at max frequency.

If that hold true, 128 SOC in 1U can be 2-300 Watts. That can true ly go against x86 for "some" applications.

Re: Online Labs – ARM servers in the cloud

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

128 Armada cores in 1U is nearly impossible due to cooling issues.

May be not for Armada, but most of cell phone ARM cpu, the power is 1-2 watts at max frequency. If that hold true, 128 SOC in 1U can be 2-300 Watts. That can true ly go against x86 for "some" applications.

Actually 3-5 for current gen. And you don't count all other things that are necessary for practical system: PCI-E connectors, RAM, Ethernet PHYs, etc.

P.S. I believe in 64 in 2U, though.

Post reply on HN