Live data from Hacker News

EBay to Spin Off PayPal

dealbook.nytimes.com

31–40 of 102 posts

Re: EBay to Spin Off PayPal

#31
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't Paypal just another middleman between the retailer and the banks? I mean, Paypal is all very well for a small site where customers don't trust you with their card details or you're not doing enough volume to get a decent merchant account - but neither of those applies to Amazon. Paypal will want a bigger cut than Amazon's existing credit card processors. So why would Amazon want to use Paypal?

PayPal allows people who don't have a credit card to make purchases online. Many people in European countries don't have a credit card for example. Accepting PayPal is an easy alternative to supporting all of the different payment methods that you might need to meet certain regions expectations.

Not sure how widespread it is, but here in Portugal banks offer a service that allows you to create virtual CCs tied to your bank account. You just set a limit (in €) and it returns all the CC info needed to make a payment.

Re: EBay to Spin Off PayPal

#32
post #22

Once this goes live, PayPal will sooner or later face stiff competition beyond its current stage under the umbrella of eBay, competing against Chinese players like those of alipay and tenpay which already have users in the hundreds of millions. These players are agressively looking into the markets outside of mainland China. The landscape won't change in a few years, but in a decade, may look completely different.

I agree that they are companies with promise, and certainly will be strong in their domestic markets... but I remain skeptical of their success in the West. I personally would not directly support Chinese businesses if I have an equivalent Western business that I can support, not simply because of xenophobia or some nationalistic nonsense, but because what China does as a Government is reprehensible. For all its faults, America is still a shining emblem of Democracy when compared to other powers such as Russia and China.

Re: EBay to Spin Off PayPal

#33
post #5

Great decision, allowing PayPal to grow beyond the virtual ceiling placed by being governed by a marketplace company which rightly has its own agenda before PayPal's.

As long as the split does not disrupt the current relationship for buyers and sellers using Ebay. Right now the process is quite simple and there had been recent efforts to link the two sites even more, as in not needing to ever log into Paypal to complete ebay purchases. hopefully that integration won't suffer.

I don't see why it would... ebay would still hold a significant percentage of paypal and influence such decision making. The main benefit will come from large competitors choosing Paypal as it becomes a less biased payment service and not one that directly profits a competitor. Essentially, Ebay will now have to pay closer to market-rate for processing.

Re: EBay to Spin Off PayPal

#34
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Still, a simple escrow system on top of Bitcoin could provide the same guarantees while potentially being cheaper. It's not like Bitcoin prevents such systems from being created - on the contrary, it has mechanisms to support them.

What makes you think it would be much cheaper? I think it might have to be more expensive. The anonymity aspects of bitcoin could result in more fraudsters getting away with fraud.

I'm not saying it would; I'm saying it potentially could.

But the CC system also provides anonymity, since most cards used for fraud are stolen anyway, so the fact they're tied to a real person is irrelevant.

Bitcoin, on the other hand, doesn't suffer from the same problem as CC - that the payment info must be shared with every single merchant - so it's potentially must harder to steal; Target wouldn't have a copy of your bitcoin wallet just because you bought something from them, for example.

Re: EBay to Spin Off PayPal

#35

This articles suggests only 20% of PayPal will be sold, although I doubt that number is anywhere near final. It's just like EMC spinning off VMware. EMC held on to 80% of VMware [and still does?]. It lets them capitalize much more effectively on the faster growing subsidiary. Even today VMware trades at double the PE ratio that EMC does.

The 20% figure quoted is describing an earlier deal that eBay considered and rejected.

Re: EBay to Spin Off PayPal

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't Paypal just another middleman between the retailer and the banks? I mean, Paypal is all very well for a small site where customers don't trust you with their card details or you're not doing enough volume to get a decent merchant account - but neither of those applies to Amazon. Paypal will want a bigger cut than Amazon's existing credit card processors. So why would Amazon want to use Paypal?

Anybody who doesn't have a credit card can't buy from Amazon (easily) right now, even if you have a paypal account. Given that EBay and Amazon are direct competitors in the retail space, it made good sense not to share purchasing/sales information with Paypal. Once Paypal and EBay are separate entities, Amazon now can reasonably enter into a merchant agreement with Paypal. I don't buy into the Amazon/Paypal being com…

Uhm they can, one can buy amazon.com giftcards in any retailer in US and at any coinstar kiosk for cold cash.

Hell one can even buy amazon giftcards using bitcoin via gyft.com and receive 3% bonus back!

If anything its Paypal that is unable to reach as many people as Amazon, and continue to alienate more and more users every day by screwing around with them etc.

Re: EBay to Spin Off PayPal

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't Paypal just another middleman between the retailer and the banks? I mean, Paypal is all very well for a small site where customers don't trust you with their card details or you're not doing enough volume to get a decent merchant account - but neither of those applies to Amazon. Paypal will want a bigger cut than Amazon's existing credit card processors. So why would Amazon want to use Paypal?

Anybody who doesn't have a credit card can't buy from Amazon (easily) right now, even if you have a paypal account. Given that EBay and Amazon are direct competitors in the retail space, it made good sense not to share purchasing/sales information with Paypal. Once Paypal and EBay are separate entities, Amazon now can reasonably enter into a merchant agreement with Paypal. I don't buy into the Amazon/Paypal being com…

Put your money where your mouth is, I will bet £100 that this won't happen.

Re: EBay to Spin Off PayPal

#38
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't Paypal just another middleman between the retailer and the banks? I mean, Paypal is all very well for a small site where customers don't trust you with their card details or you're not doing enough volume to get a decent merchant account - but neither of those applies to Amazon. Paypal will want a bigger cut than Amazon's existing credit card processors. So why would Amazon want to use Paypal?

PayPal allows people who don't have a credit card to make purchases online. Many people in European countries don't have a credit card for example. Accepting PayPal is an easy alternative to supporting all of the different payment methods that you might need to meet certain regions expectations.

Amazon accepts debit cards and other payment methods in those countries though. For a company of Amazon's scale, supporting different payment methods across European borders is not the challenge that it would be for a small business.

Re: EBay to Spin Off PayPal

#39
post #26
post #22

Once this goes live, PayPal will sooner or later face stiff competition beyond its current stage under the umbrella of eBay, competing against Chinese players like those of alipay and tenpay which already have users in the hundreds of millions. These players are agressively looking into the markets outside of mainland China. The landscape won't change in a few years, but in a decade, may look completely different.

These would still have a massive trust issue in most parts of the "Western World". Certainly doable under the umbrella of buying an established western (banking) brand but Asian brands will have a hard time communicating trust, reliability and security.

Even though it makes no sense, I'd rather use an unknown western banking company than an unknown asian banking company and I'm sure many feel the same.

Re: EBay to Spin Off PayPal

#40
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

PayPal allows people who don't have a credit card to make purchases online. Many people in European countries don't have a credit card for example. Accepting PayPal is an easy alternative to supporting all of the different payment methods that you might need to meet certain regions expectations.

Not sure how widespread it is, but here in Portugal banks offer a service that allows you to create virtual CCs tied to your bank account. You just set a limit (in €) and it returns all the CC info needed to make a payment.

Bank of America has the exact same thing.

https://www.bankofamerica.com/privacy/accounts-cards/shopsaf...

Post reply on HN