Live data from Hacker News

Moto 360 review

theverge.com

31–40 of 75 posts

Re: Moto 360 review

#31
Seriously, I can just about see Apple doing something with such impractical battery life, but that software?

This thing looks like a complete failure of integrated design, with the hardware being considered in isolation from what the software on it actually does. That it is supposedly the best smartwatch is really quite damning.

Re: Moto 360 review

#32
post #4

I have a Pebble and I'm quite ready to upgrade to a 360. Google Now is the secret killer feature that reviewers don't take into account — probably because they've only had the device for a day and are in plugged into Apple services instead anyway. My two caveats are battery life and wrist straps. The early reviews suggest about 12 hrs battery life which is the bare minimum I'm willing to accept. I don't mind charging…

>> "Google Now is the secret killer feature that reviewers don't take into account"

I love the promise of Google Now and it's the reason I switch to my Android phone every now and then to see how it's going. But it isn't as good as advertised. The only thing that it is very good with is sports (upcoming games, results, live scores). Everything else is hit or miss and when you're supposed to forget everything else and rely on it that's just not good enough. I wish it was everything it promised because I love the idea but I've found it lacking.

Re: Moto 360 review

#34

So, here's something I've been wondering about smart watches, maybe someone here can answer. It seems like the big dealbreaker for these is battery life. But a cheap watch with quartz timekeeping and digital lcd display can last a year or more on a single small battery. Would it be possible to sandwich two lcd displays into the face of the watch, one that is cheap and one that is high-res full-color? Always display t…

I don't think that the display is the biggest energy draw here. It will be the CPU which is drawing most power compared to the quartz crystal in a simple $10 LCD watch.

In which case, could you hibernate the CPU as well as the screen, but still leave the time on display?

Re: Moto 360 review

#35
I don't care. I am never wearing a watch again. The only stuff I want on me are clothes and jewellery. Clothes to keep the cold and wet and dirt off; jewellery as non-functional art pieces that speak to me in some way and say something about myself to others.

I don't want to have any piece of electronic technology tethered to any part of my body unless one day (God forbid) I'm forced to wear a pace-maker. I was never as happy as when I lost my last watch years and years ago and realised I didn't have to actually get another.

Re: Moto 360 review

#36
post #4

I have a Pebble and I'm quite ready to upgrade to a 360. Google Now is the secret killer feature that reviewers don't take into account — probably because they've only had the device for a day and are in plugged into Apple services instead anyway. My two caveats are battery life and wrist straps. The early reviews suggest about 12 hrs battery life which is the bare minimum I'm willing to accept. I don't mind charging…

>> "Google Now is the secret killer feature that reviewers don't take into account" I love the promise of Google Now and it's the reason I switch to my Android phone every now and then to see how it's going. But it isn't as good as advertised. The only thing that it is very good with is sports (upcoming games, results, live scores). Everything else is hit or miss and when you're supposed to forget everything else and…

I've found the traffic warning notifications extremely useful, they've given me prior warning of heavy traffic on plenty of occasions and saved me countless hours of sitting in traffic jams. I've been extremely happy with how integrated they've become into my daily routine.

I've also got the email integration turned on and I've been impressed with the integration with ticketmaster. It knew that I was going to see a concert, knew how long it would take to get there for its start time and knew how long it would take to get home.

Re: Moto 360 review

#37
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think that the display is the biggest energy draw here. It will be the CPU which is drawing most power compared to the quartz crystal in a simple $10 LCD watch.

In which case, could you hibernate the CPU as well as the screen, but still leave the time on display?

but then you are defeating the purpose of wearing a smartwatch, which I believe is to keep receiving notifications for calls, emails, messages and so on. If you only wake up the CPU every minute to check then it's far too slow to be useful.

Re: Moto 360 review

#38

I don't care. I am never wearing a watch again. The only stuff I want on me are clothes and jewellery. Clothes to keep the cold and wet and dirt off; jewellery as non-functional art pieces that speak to me in some way and say something about myself to others. I don't want to have any piece of electronic technology tethered to any part of my body unless one day (God forbid) I'm forced to wear a pace-maker. I was never…

Aren't watches (also) amazing pieces of jewellery?

Re: Moto 360 review

#39
post #23

Pebble lasts 5 days. I like the look better too. Plus it seems simple, and I like the screen in sunlight better. Plus it works with iOS AND Android - which is good, since I'm a multiplatform kind of person.

My pebble lasts between 7 and 10 days. You must be getting a lot of notifications; do you enable accelerometer-triggered backlight? Do you listen to music often (with the music controls) ?

Re: Moto 360 review

#40

So, here's something I've been wondering about smart watches, maybe someone here can answer. It seems like the big dealbreaker for these is battery life. But a cheap watch with quartz timekeeping and digital lcd display can last a year or more on a single small battery. Would it be possible to sandwich two lcd displays into the face of the watch, one that is cheap and one that is high-res full-color? Always display t…

I agree that battery life is the killer feature that all these watches are missing. I can also see that Google, Samsung, LG, and Motorola are trying to hype the watches like there's no tomorrow.

I really think that the center of the universe for all these devices is the phone and that the watch is really a phone accessory.

Are these watches water resistant/proof?

Post reply on HN