Live data from Hacker News

Job interviews go both ways (2011)

diegobasch.com

31–40 of 82 posts

Re: Job interviews go both ways (2011)

#31
post #15

This is a really relevant piece, if I'm interviewing you I'm going to wonder if you're not asking any questions about the company. I get that its hard to ask challenging questions in a situation where you want to get hired, but you will need to ask challenging questions when you don't want to get fired too, and if you can do that you are more valuable than someone who can't. That bit about everyone focused on the sto…

I've never interviewed anyone, but also, if they don't ask me any questions about the company then I'm gonna think they simply don't care and they applied for the role "just for a job". I don't want to work with people who don't care.

Well, define "care" and "just for a job." My view is that it very rarely happens that a candidate has sufficient information to know whether the job he's applying for is one he can "care" about as more than just a method of obtaining a paycheck. In fact, I submit that such information isn't possible to obtain, outside fringe cases (e.g. knowing people on the inside already), without actually working at a place for a time.

Re: Job interviews go both ways (2011)

#32

The author advocates questioning the interviewer directly, but he doesn't mention questioning anyone in his Netscape interview, only making mental notes of various red flags. In practice, I think that's the way 'both way' interviews generally have to go - you don't interview your interviewer, but you do evaluate and judge your potential employer critically. Personally, my attempts at interviewing an interviewer have…

Here are some that I've asked:

1. "During your most recent budget period, what influence did politics rather than the merits of budget requests have in distributing resources, and in what ways?"

2. "How heavily influenced by politics (or upper management) is the performance review process?"

3. "Has anybody recently been let go as the result of being ranked lowest on a performance review?"

4. "Are managers subject to performance improvement plans?"

5. "When was the last time your HR department found in favor of an employee over management or upper management when a dispute arose?"

There's a bias to these (if it isn't obvious). But experience informs me that answers to these questions offer a good insight into how the company really operates. If they are honest answers (they won't be, most of the time, if they're answered at all).

Re: Job interviews go both ways (2011)

#33

This is a really relevant piece, if I'm interviewing you I'm going to wonder if you're not asking any questions about the company. I get that its hard to ask challenging questions in a situation where you want to get hired, but you will need to ask challenging questions when you don't want to get fired too, and if you can do that you are more valuable than someone who can't. That bit about everyone focused on the sto…

>'This is a really relevant piece, if I'm interviewing you I'm going to wonder if you're not asking any questions about the company.' Honest question, can you give some examples of good questions that the typical interviewer would be able to answer?

- How do / would you interact with [role]? What do you most want from people in [role]?

- What do you like / dislike most about working here? (I'd typically lead with like for obvious reasons).

- What surprised you the most after you started working here?

- Relevant questions you discovered when you did your homework on the company.

Re: Job interviews go both ways (2011)

#34

The author advocates questioning the interviewer directly, but he doesn't mention questioning anyone in his Netscape interview, only making mental notes of various red flags. In practice, I think that's the way 'both way' interviews generally have to go - you don't interview your interviewer, but you do evaluate and judge your potential employer critically. Personally, my attempts at interviewing an interviewer have…

I know you think it might come across antagonistic in an interview, but I wouldn't be offended if you came in and asked us these:

> Who's the weakest person on your team?

The newest hire to our company. It's not a total ordering though, every person on the team has weaknesses.

> What do you mean to do about that?

Make sure to put people on things that they're good at is the first thing! Don't put someone on something where they're not set up to have the ability to achieve success. My main job is to figure out what's getting in your way and attack that directly so you can just focus on being successful. If there's doubt about whether someone would be successful here then we'd rather pass on a candidate.

> When's the last time you lied to someone here? How did you rationalize it?

Never. It destroys any credibly you have to lie. That's one of the biggest red flags I could think of. I'd encourage anyone encountering a boss that lies to quit.

>Are you on any medications? Do you cheat on your spouse?

No. No.

> What are you most insecure about?

I used to be insecure about my ability to obtain sales from customers, but after having to do it over past 3 months and focusing on the basics I've become much better and we're now on a great track on the sales side of the company. Be aggressive about going after your weaknesses!

All of my answers are honest and I'd encourage you to hear about the experiences of other people on the team. I'd also encourage you to reach out to anyone who has worked with me in the past through any backchannels you have- that will give you the most unfiltered picture.

Re: Job interviews go both ways (2011)

#35
post #30

Did I ever mention that interview with a whizzo East Coast startup where the interviewer couldn't answer where the company was planning to be in five years time? It's one of those questions where they will squirm like eels, but you have to know, because you are committing your time and future earnings to them. Squirming is fine, but being struck dumb is not acceptable. The experience was epic, it ended with a greybea…

I always ask "Do you enjoy working here?" Their instant response is usually telling.

Wow! I all ask this on my next interview.

Re: Job interviews go both ways (2011)

#36
I guess I've interviewed over a hundred candidates over the years. I always end with: is there anything you'd like to ask me? I can't recall a single meaningful conversation that ensued as a result.

Re: Job interviews go both ways (2011)

#37

This is a really relevant piece, if I'm interviewing you I'm going to wonder if you're not asking any questions about the company. I get that its hard to ask challenging questions in a situation where you want to get hired, but you will need to ask challenging questions when you don't want to get fired too, and if you can do that you are more valuable than someone who can't. That bit about everyone focused on the sto…

If you're the fifth person I've spoken to that day, any questions I have about the company have most likely already been asked and answered. Would it comfort you or worry you to find out I'm asking questions I already know the answer to just for the sake of appearance? Or is there something else at work here I'm not getting?

Re: Job interviews go both ways (2011)

#38
post #30

Did I ever mention that interview with a whizzo East Coast startup where the interviewer couldn't answer where the company was planning to be in five years time? It's one of those questions where they will squirm like eels, but you have to know, because you are committing your time and future earnings to them. Squirming is fine, but being struck dumb is not acceptable. The experience was epic, it ended with a greybea…

I always ask "Do you enjoy working here?" Their instant response is usually telling.

Never thought of this! Great question, I'm gonna keep that in mind.

Re: Job interviews go both ways (2011)

#39
post #36

I guess I've interviewed over a hundred candidates over the years. I always end with: is there anything you'd like to ask me? I can't recall a single meaningful conversation that ensued as a result.

During my noob days my questions were always about 1. Work times 2. Dress code 3. Questions of growth in company

As I got exposure it moved on to 1. Specific question on potential growth 2. Companies market position risks/challenges and their actions/plans

But I have not asked hard questions that a few have outlined here. Hopefully I don't have to :)

Re: Job interviews go both ways (2011)

#40

The author advocates questioning the interviewer directly, but he doesn't mention questioning anyone in his Netscape interview, only making mental notes of various red flags. In practice, I think that's the way 'both way' interviews generally have to go - you don't interview your interviewer, but you do evaluate and judge your potential employer critically. Personally, my attempts at interviewing an interviewer have…

Unfortunately, this sort of thing is a soft skill and doing it well requires a lot of expertise. It's comparable to being a good interviewer, which is also a rarity.

You can't just ask hard, probing questions baldly and expect to get accurate answers. More so, you can't expect to do that and expect it to not affect your interviewer's appraisal of you as well. You need to build up a rapport first and then you need to ask some leading questions that give your interviewer the opportunity to reveal some perhaps unsavory truths about their workplace. Granted, it might be hard to generate a rapport, or they might be too wary to tell you anything of substance or anything negative about the company, but that alone provides a lot of information regardless. If you have a hard time connecting with interviewers then maybe culture fit would be a problem. And if they won't open up about problems then that might be a sign of a dysfunctional corporate environment that discourages honesty and openness.

Post reply on HN