Live data from Hacker News

I wish I could read Wikipedia like this

blog.assaflavie.com

31–40 of 68 posts

Re: I wish I could read Wikipedia like this

#31
post #17

Incidentally, this was what my diploma thesis was about. The basic idea was to have a single »text« that contains lots of possible branching or expansion points, depending on certain criteria. Depending on those criteria you'd get a expanded or contracted text to read that would be tailored to what you already know or are interested about. Altering the text in small parts (like [−1½] mentioned in another comment – I…

Telescope Text is very interesting, thanks for the link.

Re: I wish I could read Wikipedia like this

#32
post #30

I prefer popups (floating elements) instead of altering the flow of the document. The continuous re-flow of the document is distracting.

I'm the same - I'm currently trying to use DuckDuckGo and familiarising myself to it, but it's driving me nuts as it reflows the results as it loads elements. I'll go to click on something only to have it move away as another element is loaded.

Re: I wish I could read Wikipedia like this

#33

Didn't Ted Nelson suggest this sort of in-situ display for transclusion in Xanadu?

Goes a bit beyond that, especially in the kablang navigation and sworfing but yes ... it definitely gets closer than the current one-way linking model of html.

Re: I wish I could read Wikipedia like this

#34
Wish granted: http://wikiballoons.tomodo.me/wiki/Main_Page

I also made a (by no means complete) POC more simmiliar to your animation which you're welcome to fork and improve: http://en.wikimore.tomodo.me/wiki/Main_Page

In general, whenever you want to improve a website - Tomodo is the place to go (http://tomodo.com/)

Re: I wish I could read Wikipedia like this

#35
post #4

This already exists on Wikipedia. Under preferences, select the Gadgets tab and enable "Navigation popups". When hovering over a link in a Wikipedia article, a small popup will appear, in addition to some metadata about the link, the first paragraph of the article will appear, including links that may appear in that paragraph, which can also be hovered to make another popup appear.

The OP's design for it is much nicer.

Navigation popups have been around since 2005, and while in some ways better than the OP's design (pictures!) this is useful enough to test it as default behavior.

Hover doesn't work on mobile, so perhaps they should appear if you click and hold for a few seconds.

Re: I wish I could read Wikipedia like this

#36

About popups/tooltips/hovercards: I considered this approach, but decided to go with this sort of "inline" expansion for the following reasons: 1. A popup obscures the original text. This interferes with context, albeit admittedly to a much lesser degree than full-blown navigation, but still. 2. Multi-level popup hierarchies just don't look good, in my opinion. 3. You must dismiss a popup to continue, whereas with in…

Agree with all four; I prefer inline expansion to popups as well. Especially 2/ - multiple popups can quickly lead to a mess on screen, just like on the Wikipedia's Navigation Popups screenshot, where it does not only look ugly, but the popups also obscure each other as well as the original text.

Re: I wish I could read Wikipedia like this

#39
While the suggested feature would be a improvement, the real goal imho should be that each Wikipedia article can be read and understood by itself, without the need to go on a recursive yak shaving expedition through other articles first.
Post reply on HN