Live data from Hacker News

Facebook to pull chat from iOS and Android apps in favour of Facebook Messenger

theinquirer.net

31–40 of 46 posts

Re: Facebook to pull chat from iOS and Android apps in favour of Facebook Messenger

#31
post #12

This is just an opportunity for Facebook to show twice as many ads as usual. It's sad, but I really do feel bad for the people who use Facebook nowadays. When I have to look at the job market again, I'm really not looking forward to having to (a) sign up in the first place, (b) have that stupid like button following me around everywhere again and (c) have to become "friends" with people that I really don't want to se…

I have never seen an ad in messenger.

Re: Facebook to pull chat from iOS and Android apps in favour of Facebook Messenger

#32
post #7

Oh great, now there's a double whammy 40 MB + 40 MB for the stupid MqttPushService that is run twice by the Facebook and the Facebook Messenger apps. Might as well not use Facebook on this 512 MB device. Why can't Facebook just implement push via GCM without sucking all the memory and wakelocks itself?

Maybe it doesn't want to pass through a Google service.

Re: Facebook to pull chat from iOS and Android apps in favour of Facebook Messenger

#34
post #28
post #5

The new battlefield is the real estate on your phone´s front page. FB + Messenger + Instagram + Whatsapp: 4 out of 16 icons, not bad.

Very interesting theory! Google must not have realized this because all of the google apps are in a single folder. Still, my home screen is 4 out of 20: Google folder, Gmail, Chrome and Authenticator.

Random question: Is Authenticator secure from Google themselves? I thought "yes," but after thinking a little more it seems like the answer is "maybe not."

What's to prevent an app like Authenticator from uploading its cryptographic seeds to Google's servers?

I was wondering why a company would invest resources into creating an app like Authenticator, which seems to have no obvious path toward monetization. But if the company who writes Authenticator can also spy on its users, then that might be the answer.

Re: Facebook to pull chat from iOS and Android apps in favour of Facebook Messenger

#36
post #5

The new battlefield is the real estate on your phone´s front page. FB + Messenger + Instagram + Whatsapp: 4 out of 16 icons, not bad.

Facebook has been playing this game for a while. They've also had Facebook Camera since mid-2012. It was clearly meant as a drop-in replacement for the iOS camera app, that just made it easier to upload your photos to Facebook.

Re: Facebook to pull chat from iOS and Android apps in favour of Facebook Messenger

#37
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Very interesting theory! Google must not have realized this because all of the google apps are in a single folder. Still, my home screen is 4 out of 20: Google folder, Gmail, Chrome and Authenticator.

Random question: Is Authenticator secure from Google themselves? I thought "yes," but after thinking a little more it seems like the answer is "maybe not." What's to prevent an app like Authenticator from uploading its cryptographic seeds to Google's servers? I was wondering why a company would invest resources into creating an app like Authenticator, which seems to have no obvious path toward monetization. But if th…

It's not hard to decompile and verify Authenticator if you really need to.

IMHO the real problem is the actual OS :/

Re: Facebook to pull chat from iOS and Android apps in favour of Facebook Messenger

#38

For people like myself who have Facebook on my mobile but not the messaging app it means we now need to install it. For some percentage of folks like myself that means we might start using facebook messaging more instead of using it as the messaging platform of last resort.

Or just use a web browser and use the FB mobile website.

I use Tinfoil for this: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.danvelazco...

Re: Facebook to pull chat from iOS and Android apps in favour of Facebook Messenger

#39
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you have folders on iOS? I've bundled all of my messaging apps together.

Is there people still using iOS?

*Are, and what makes you think there aren't??

Re: Facebook to pull chat from iOS and Android apps in favour of Facebook Messenger

#40
This is incredibly annoying. For the last couple of months the FB app has been switching me to the messenger app every time I accidentally hit the messenger button in the middle of the bottom navbar. And every single time it nags me with a full screen interstitial asking me to turn on notifications!!! Removing all FB apps now.
Post reply on HN