There's no need for speculation here. Open Facebook, right click, select "Inspect Element" then the "Network" tab. On a self-censored status update, they send a request to /ajax/bz that triggers their censorlogger, but don't pass the content itself. On messages & chat, they send a request to /ajax/messaging/typ.php to show the other person you're typing, but again, they don't pass your message to their servers. On se…
Yes you could do that two seconds worth of testing, in basically every browser these days even. But then you couldn't write a link bait article about the possibility that they are doing it.
Facebook self-censorship: What happens to the posts you don’t publish?
31–40 of 47 posts
Re: Facebook self-censorship: What happens to the posts you don’t publish?
#32Re: Facebook self-censorship: What happens to the posts you don’t publish?
#33Someone should fix the HN headline, currently "Facebook monitors and analyzes posts that users type but don't submit". In their article, Das and Kramer claim to only send back information to Facebook that indicates /whether/ you self-censored, not /what/ you typed. The Facebook rep I spoke with agreed that the company isn’t collecting the text of self-censored posts.... "we have arrived at a better understanding of h…
From the paper: Furthermore, all instrumentation is done client-side. In other words, the content of self-censored posts was not sent back to Facebook's servers https://autoblog.postblue.info/autoblogs/wwwinternetactunet_... Of course, that doesn't mean they _couldn't_ do this, just that they say they don't currently.
Re: Facebook self-censorship: What happens to the posts you don’t publish?
#34Re: Facebook self-censorship: What happens to the posts you don’t publish?
#35Here is some of the data they are transmitting:
[{"user": "BLANKED","page_id":"BLANKED","posts":[["censorlogger",{"cl_impid":"BLANKED","clearcounter":0,"instrument":"composer","elementid":"BLANKED","parent_fbid":BLANKED,"version":"x"}, BLANKED,BLANKED]],"trigger":"censorlogger"}]
BLANKED is inserted where some of the data could potentially be personally identifiable information. Of note is the "clearcounter". They apparently evaluate how many times you clear the data. The ajax call is apparently a more general function as they must supply the trigger.
Re: Facebook self-censorship: What happens to the posts you don’t publish?
#36There's no need for speculation here. Open Facebook, right click, select "Inspect Element" then the "Network" tab. On a self-censored status update, they send a request to /ajax/bz that triggers their censorlogger, but don't pass the content itself. On messages & chat, they send a request to /ajax/messaging/typ.php to show the other person you're typing, but again, they don't pass your message to their servers. On se…
Re: Facebook self-censorship: What happens to the posts you don’t publish?
#37There's no need for speculation here. Open Facebook, right click, select "Inspect Element" then the "Network" tab. On a self-censored status update, they send a request to /ajax/bz that triggers their censorlogger, but don't pass the content itself. On messages & chat, they send a request to /ajax/messaging/typ.php to show the other person you're typing, but again, they don't pass your message to their servers. On se…
I don't think /ajax/bz has anything to do with censorlogging. I'm seeing it hit just for scrolling down the page.
Re: Facebook self-censorship: What happens to the posts you don’t publish?
#38Earlier quoted context omitted.
I don't think /ajax/bz has anything to do with censorlogging. I'm seeing it hit just for scrolling down the page.
I think it may be their generic logging system. The JSON passed back to their server contained the phrase trigger:"censorlogging" when I bailed on the status update.
Re: Facebook self-censorship: What happens to the posts you don’t publish?
#39There's no need for speculation here. Open Facebook, right click, select "Inspect Element" then the "Network" tab. On a self-censored status update, they send a request to /ajax/bz that triggers their censorlogger, but don't pass the content itself. On messages & chat, they send a request to /ajax/messaging/typ.php to show the other person you're typing, but again, they don't pass your message to their servers. On se…
Re: Facebook self-censorship: What happens to the posts you don’t publish?
#40Furthermore, and somewhat amusingly, "a summer intern conducted this work." Thus, it was mostly a summer project, researching demographics about people who started to comment and then stopped.
They put forth 7 major hypothesis:
1) posts will be censored more than comments 2) men will self-censor more than women 3) users with more opposite-sex friends will self-censor more 4) younger users will self-censor less 5) users with older friends will censor more 6) users who more frequently used audience selection tools self-censor less 7) users with more diverse friends will self-censor more
All of these are interesting questions based in a large amount of literature that they could uniquely address and answer with the data that they had. Recording whether or not users enter and then remove data is honestly relatively unimportant. Yes, websites taking user data without asking is an invasion of privacy, but I think this sort of article represents a type of knee jerk alarmism and exaggeration that can be incredibly hurtful to efforts to use data Facebook has available to answer interesting questions about human interaction. It also, furthermore, represents a purposeful misreading of the article, which is journalistically questionable.
If you want to read the article for yourself you can find it at https://www.facebook.com/publications/493601774027388/.