Live data from Hacker News

Sustainable Micro Home that Costs Less Than $30,000

mymodernmet.com

31–40 of 62 posts

Re: Sustainable Micro Home that Costs Less Than $30,000

#31
post #28

The open stairs going over the kitchen (!!), and the bed with nearly no protection barrier are two bad points that strike me in the prototype

Protective barrier? For falling out of bed?

... and immediately down the stairs.

It's not like people don't fall out of bed from time to time. I'd rather not have to include "down the stairs" in the story.

Re: Sustainable Micro Home that Costs Less Than $30,000

#32
This probably competes with the IKEA houses announced in the past few years. But the best concept for modular, mobile micro homes in my opinion is still the Nagakin Tower (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nakagin_Capsule_Tower).

Imagine taking your home cube with you to another big city and having it attached to a fixed base (your choice of floor and orientation as available), or even just relocating to be in walking distance from your new office.

Re: Sustainable Micro Home that Costs Less Than $30,000

#34
post #15

The thing that stood out most as missing to me is a shower. Sure, I suppose you could do that at a gym, but still - having at least a shower is a pretty big quality-of-living improvement (or lack thereof).

The bathroom is indeed a shower, per this photo: http://www.nomadmicrohomes.com/uploads/3/2/7/6/3276237/51529...

via http://www.nomadmicrohomes.com/gallery.html

Re: Sustainable Micro Home that Costs Less Than $30,000

#35
post #30

Quite dangerous to sleep like that, right over the stairs...You can easily fall down. Also it looks like its going to be hard to get in/out of the bed.

> Quite dangerous to sleep like that, right over the stairs

Just add a safety rail. EDIT: Ah, there is a safety rail, but it should be extended so you have to get out of bed on the end.

Re: Sustainable Micro Home that Costs Less Than $30,000

#36
- No temperature control. This could only work in areas with moderate temperatures year-round. You probably wouldn't want one of these in Arizona or Montana.

- Seems like it would have the same tenuous relationship with tornadoes that trailer homes/parks do.

- Lack of a divider between the stairs and the kitchen makes it seem like it would be too easy to accidentally knock things off of the shelf or counter while going up the stairs. I especially don't like that the counter turns into a stair without any sort of clear dividing line.

Re: Sustainable Micro Home that Costs Less Than $30,000

#37
Pretty pictures.

() open steps over the food preparation area is not particularly sanitary due to what can fall off the bottom of a person's shoes, socks and feet...neither is using a food preparation surface as a tread.

() Considering falls are the principal mode of fatal and serious domestic injuries, no handrails on a winding stair that the occupant will be navigating to use the toilet in the middle of the night is unconscionable design.

() The simple task of making the bed becomes a gymnastic exercise performed without a net.

() Because it has fenestration on three sides, it's not efficient in terms of footprint. The safety, hygiene and convenience compromises are unnecessary - a larger footprint could be equally cost effective in single application and more environmentally sound by allowing denser development (e.g. as a grouphouse, rowhouse or flat in a multistory aggregate.

Re: Sustainable Micro Home that Costs Less Than $30,000

#38
post #36

- No temperature control. This could only work in areas with moderate temperatures year-round. You probably wouldn't want one of these in Arizona or Montana. - Seems like it would have the same tenuous relationship with tornadoes that trailer homes/parks do. - Lack of a divider between the stairs and the kitchen makes it seem like it would be too easy to accidentally knock things off of the shelf or counter while goi…

If you made this out of plywood/polystyrene sandwich and gave it a slightly more aerodynamic shape, you could probably arrange to have this quite securely anchored, depending on the ground where you are moving. The hyper insulation of such materials would also do a lot to alleviate the climate control issues. You'd want to arrange for shade to control solar heating in warm climates. Also, such a small house would be easier to cool using solar and wind power.

Your third objection probably kills this, though. I'd just make the place 5' longer.

Re: Sustainable Micro Home that Costs Less Than $30,000

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is quite a market for them, don't knock it. Buy a cheap lot somewhere, pour a slab, wheel the tiny house into place, nice starter home for a young'un in one weekend flat.

Why do you even need the slab? Just get some concrete blocks, bring the home in, put in a septic tank...and you are in business. Bonus if you live in the boonies and have to burn your trash.

I wouldn't bother with the slab either. Set it on blocks but also ensure that it's anchored on all 4 corners. Instead of a septic tank, change the design to incorporate a Clivus Multrum toilet and put in a large water tank for rainwater and to act as a heat sink for a heat exchanger. (Depending on climate, of course.)
Post reply on HN