Live data from Hacker News

Did these guys just reinvent the Web?

javaworld.com

31–40 of 93 posts

Re: Did these guys just reinvent the Web?

#31

Betteridge's law of headlines comes to mind.

I would like to analyze the comment threads of all the submissions ending with question marks and see in how many Betteridge is referred to. I would guess it's close to 100%.

This was a particular bad reference since the title was very rhetorical and not meant to be taken literally.

Re: Did these guys just reinvent the Web?

#32
"Obviously, this isn't exactly the reinvention of the Web, but Famo.us has pushed JavaScript in a novel direction -- and has poked a large hole in the argument that native apps alone deliver the goods. It will be fascinating to see the new types of applications that emerge."

Re: Did these guys just reinvent the Web?

#34
post #12

Sounds like they came up with a novel and impressive optimisation that everyone could benefit from, but decided to keep it to themselves and charge for it. So less "reinvent the web" than "go back to the way things were before the web" really. Whether or not there's anything wrong with that is left up to the reader. :)

From the article: "Last month Famo.us announced that its core would be available for free under an as-yet-unspecified open source license when the company releases its software sometime next year."

So they're planning on releasing open source and charging for components on top.

Re: Did these guys just reinvent the Web?

#35
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's the law for someone always mentioning Betteridge's law of headlines when a headline is posed as a question on Hacker News?

Ahem: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5742893

How about this one:

Any time a commenter cries ad hominem, there will be a sub-thread arguing about the definition of ad hominem.

Re: Did these guys just reinvent the Web?

#36
post #25

Seems browsers are obsolete and are now just getting in the way. People are trying to use every loophole and new technology possible to bypass features implemented in browsers. I think it's time browsers took a step back and gave more control to developers. It's time for a major rethink of what a browser should be/do.

I'm inclined to agree with you here. While I love HTML, CSS and Javascript it's not the right tool for where the web appears to be heading, which is essentially a transport layer for data that services apps.

Mobile devices have turned the process of installing an app into something 'close enough' to the experience of browsing the web that I think a lot of consumers wouldn't notice if the twitter web site disappeared (except that would be big news, and they wouldn't be able to avoid all the complaining).

Conclusion... I don't know, but I think our current concept of a browser and the web might be reaching the end of it's usefulness. More data needed.

Re: Did these guys just reinvent the Web?

#39
I saw a video of the founder giving a talk, seems like they are hijacking css3 animations and doing matrix calcs better optimised than most css3 browser implementations

Cool stuff but I wouldn't call it re-inventing the web

Post reply on HN