Live data from Hacker News

Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free

konklone.com

31–40 of 264 posts

Re: Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free

#31
Using HTTPS everywhere doesn't really help much. It doesn't help at all if the surveillers either have your cert or access to decrypted traffic inside the firewall. Any PII being sent over the wire should most definitely be encrypted, but encrypting my access to a news site isn't really hiding anything. The requested URL still need to be unencrypted, you'd just be encrypting content that is already availble unencrypted.

Re: Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free

#32
This isn't strictly related to this post, but I've always thought that the idea of paying a fee for SSL certificates was a bad one. Time spent buying and setting up an SSL certificate would be better spent making your site available as a Tor hidden service.

Re: Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free

#33
post #31

Using HTTPS everywhere doesn't really help much. It doesn't help at all if the surveillers either have your cert or access to decrypted traffic inside the firewall. Any PII being sent over the wire should most definitely be encrypted, but encrypting my access to a news site isn't really hiding anything. The requested URL still need to be unencrypted, you'd just be encrypting content that is already availble unencrypt…

> The requested URL still need to be unencrypted

The SSL connection is set up before the HTTP request is sent; that's why the dedicated IP per domain is required, since the domain (Host header) is part of the request as well. The URL you're accessing is not sent in the clear.

Re: Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free

#34
post #15

I just recently enabled SSL on my business website. It was anything but simple. First of all, I had to get a dedicated server, because a bunch of other sites were running on the same server, and the hosting company doesn't offer additional IP addresses. Then I wanted to get an SSL certificate. I picked Comodo, because they seemed to offer the cheapest full business validation certificate, but then accidentally bought…

I had a similar experience when I purchased a software signing certificate from Comodo, exacerbated by the fact that we had accidentally transposed two adjacent digits in the phone number we gave in our listing. It ended up taking about two weeks in all to get Dun & Bradstreet to correct the typo and have Comodo verify the update, and then call us at that number. While the delay was not pleasant, I am glad that they make an effort to ensure that a legitimate organization is purchasing the certificate.

Re: Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free

#35

Excellent guide but unfortunately StartSSL does not support all top-level domains. I went through the trouble of registering with StartSSL, they even issued a client certificate for my email account at .tk domain, but they refuse to issue SSL server certificates for any .tk domain. Even though this is a perfectly legitimate top-level domain (yes I paid for a real .tk domain, and I fully control the DNS settings just…

StartSSL will also refuse to give you a certificate based on some sort of blacklist of words, which they won't disclose. I remember they didn't even want to tell me why they refused my domain, I had to send many emails asking for more information, until the guy answering finally decided to tell me.

Re: Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Webfaction enabled SNI on all of their servers in December 2011 [1], which means you no longer need to buy a dedicated IP address to use SSL. In fact, when they made this switch, they switched my server over to SNI automatically and stopped charging me the extra $5/month automatically. Awesome! A small fraction of Internet users on extremely out-of-date system cannot use SNI. If you need to support those users, you w…

Almost 1 in 5 people on the web are still running Windows XP. No version of Internet Explorer on XP supports SNI. Neither does Safari on XP, the browser in Android 2.x, the BlackBerry browser or Opera Mobile before 10.1. It may be a minority of users, but it's not just "people who are still running IE6". Pretty much everyone would love to use SNI; site owners wouldn't have to pay for extra IPs, hosting companies woul…

I appreciate your detailed response! I should not have been so dismissive of those users. Still, I maintain that the "extra cost for a dedicated IP" is a poor excuse for not implementing SSL.

Re: Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free

#38
post #15

I just recently enabled SSL on my business website. It was anything but simple. First of all, I had to get a dedicated server, because a bunch of other sites were running on the same server, and the hosting company doesn't offer additional IP addresses. Then I wanted to get an SSL certificate. I picked Comodo, because they seemed to offer the cheapest full business validation certificate, but then accidentally bought…

I would be willing to bet over 95% of SSL-secured sites don't have business validation certificates. Given virtually nobody visiting your site will know what that means, let alone how to check anything about the certificate you're using, it just doesn't make sense to pay extra for no benefit. A domain-validated certificate costs less while providing the same padlock icon and level of encryption, and takes just minute…

In my case, I don't care about encryption. On my website, I only offer software for download. No private data. Payment is handled by a third party.

The only reason why I want to support https is so that customers can confirm who they are downloading from. Ideally, I'd like an EV certificate, but I can't afford that. So I chose a business validation cert. A domain only certificate wouldn't really confirm anything.

(Also, some of my troubles would have been the same with a domain-only cert. The emails with missing links were those for domain validation, and I had to paste the CSR in the management area that was offline...)

Re: Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free

#39
Oh, the sweet irony -

> SSL’s not perfect, but we need to make surveillance as expensive as possible

immediately followed by -

> And hey, bonus: more complete referrer information in Google Analytics

Make up your mind already. Are you against the surveillance or for it? You can't really sit with one ass on two chairs.

  --
(edit) Point being is that if you are pulling the anti-surveillance card, then you shouldn't really be siphoning off your visitors data to Google.

Re: Switch to HTTPS Now, For Free

#40
post #15

I just recently enabled SSL on my business website. It was anything but simple. First of all, I had to get a dedicated server, because a bunch of other sites were running on the same server, and the hosting company doesn't offer additional IP addresses. Then I wanted to get an SSL certificate. I picked Comodo, because they seemed to offer the cheapest full business validation certificate, but then accidentally bought…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN