Live data from Hacker News

Stripe: Redesign status page as part of job application

finejobs.co

31–32 of 32 posts

Re: Stripe: Redesign status page as part of job application

#31

I always wonder when I see things like this -- are there actually people who will work for free just to apply for a job? I do not mean this as snark. And I certainly would be open to the idea of a trial period or working on an in house project after the interview. But to ask someone to put in hours just for the possibility of an interview seems like a very asymmetric request. Am I off base here? EDIT: It's probably w…

You're on base. I guess this would work for certain companies like Google, or Apple, but if you're an average company (no offense, but Stripe is nothing special), then you probably won't get many candidates, maybe not even 4 or 5.

In other words, Stripe is just like every other boring, trivial corporation!!!

Re: Stripe: Redesign status page as part of job application

#32

This feels so unfair to an applicant. A better way would be to go through the normal filtering process of accepting applications. Choose several designers, then offer them this same task with proper payment for their time.

The idea this is unfair or "spec" work seems silly to me. As a professional, you do a ton of stuff that you don't get paid for: attending classes, building your skillset, designing your portfolio, writing your resume, creating concepts, etc., etc. This is simply a fact of life.

It's not simply a fact of life. These types of application processes are no different than saying "There is a $200 application fee."
Post reply on HN