As someone who's had recruiters find my personal email via my GitHub commits, this is a welcome feature.
Actually, a few recruiters found my personal address by scraping AUTHORS files like https://github.com/joyent/node/blob/master/AUTHORS
Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
31–40 of 41 posts
Re: Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
#32Earlier quoted context omitted.
Thank your choice of profession that you even have this 'problem'. I would literally dance on my hands if I were hounded (courted?) this way in my choice of profession (bio/pharmaceutical research)! Hell, if someone knows where else I could put up email, phone and CV to be seen by successful recruiters, please let me know. Quit the whining and be a bit more thankful for what you do have. Sheesh!
Alternatively, quit your whining that you entered a profession where you're not as marketable, and don't minimize the problems people have even if they appear trivial. I don't think you know much about how recruiters operate...they're very annoying and antagonize the process for small businesses/boutique firms. There is a reason why hiring managers will say they don't want recruiters. Often, they obfuscate the proces…
Alternatively, quit your whining that you entered a profession where you're not as marketable, and don't minimize the problems people have even if they appear trivial.
This being HN, by definition devs are certain to be over-represented, as well as their problems (real or imaginary!).
Also, since I know I am out of my peer group here, I hope that as I learn from fellow HNer's, I can also contribute, however minutely, and in this instance, by sharing perspective from my neck of the woods.
As to marketability, (something you also suggest) it varies across professions and disciplines, and I have no problem with that per se. From where I stand, the problem, as defined by you, and many others in other HN posts over the years, appears akin to complaining of flies when you are drinking from a river of honey.
Of course, there are annoyances in every facet of life, but from where I am looking at things, all I see is a bunch of fat piglets squealing that their milk is cold.
tl;dr - Peoples' problems are peoples' problems. Other peoples' problems don't make them go away, but they sure help provide some much needed PERSPECTIVE!
Re: Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
#33Earlier quoted context omitted.
I think many developers complain about recruiters as a way of subtly bragging about how many people want to hire them. Secretly, they'd be kind of disappointed if the emails stopped coming.
I can't really argue with you if you've experienced this, but for what it's worth, all the developers I know professionally have legitimate reasons to dislike recruiters, and avoid them wherever possible. I think it's unfair that people have their motives for disliking something called into question just because they're in a certain strata that has that problem and not everyone else does.
I'm not trying to say the recruiters are pleasant or anything. I just feel like the amount of complaining about recruiter emails is disproportionate to how inconvenient they actually are.
There's nothing wrong with disliking the emails--a lot of people get recruiter emails and just silently ignore them; a few complain loudly about them, and that's who I'm talking about.
Re: Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
#34Not going to help. Cloning some public repo will expose all emails you commited with anyway.
Good point. I mistakenly thought that they were going to rewrite the email addresses in git commits, it appears that is not the case.
Re: Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
#35Earlier quoted context omitted.
I can't really argue with you if you've experienced this, but for what it's worth, all the developers I know professionally have legitimate reasons to dislike recruiters, and avoid them wherever possible. I think it's unfair that people have their motives for disliking something called into question just because they're in a certain strata that has that problem and not everyone else does.
I'm not trying to say the recruiters are pleasant or anything. I just feel like the amount of complaining about recruiter emails is disproportionate to how inconvenient they actually are. There's nothing wrong with disliking the emails--a lot of people get recruiter emails and just silently ignore them; a few complain loudly about them, and that's who I'm talking about.
Alright, that's a fair point. I'm in the group that silently ignores and tries to foil them, although I will chime in if people minimize the problem.
Re: Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
#36This seems kind of like privacy theatre to me. What's to stop someone from just cloning your repos and deriving your email from the commit attributes?
I use fake email addresses on all my git contributions.
Re: Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
#37Earlier quoted context omitted.
Clearly a cousin of the "HumbleBrag", this should be called the "HumbleWhine"... Boo Hoo, Just Look At Me, What An Awesome Developer I Am, That So Many Recruiters Spam Me With Their Offers Darn, spoilt rich kids (devs) and their rich problems!
This isn't a fair perspective. Recruiters are legitimately annoying. Especially as many recruiters obfuscate the hiring process so you can't just skip them directly to the company they're fielding. There's a long litany of abuses they take part in quite frequently, ranging from knowingly introducing you to companies you're not qualified for just because you're a "programmer" to deliberately making the hiring process…
When you have a job, maybe you can afford to be annoyed. When you don't, a recruiter is helpful.
Re: Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
#38So how is this different from using any fake email address?
There previously was no way to use a fake email address when making changes from the web UI and still receive email notifications from Github since the same email address was used for both things.
Re: Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
#39This seems kind of like privacy theatre to me. What's to stop someone from just cloning your repos and deriving your email from the commit attributes?
The actual commits will have the fake address. The change isn't that they're hiding the email addresses in the UI; it's that they've added the option to use a fake email address for commits made via the web UI while still receiving notification emails from Github.
Re: Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
#40This seems kind of like privacy theatre to me. What's to stop someone from just cloning your repos and deriving your email from the commit attributes?
Nothing. Which is why I use a fake email in my commits.