Live data from Hacker News

Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

policymic.com

31–40 of 57 posts

Re: Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

#31

Who cares? There is a lot of people who can nominate someone for the Nobel Peace Prize. Fidel Castro has even been nominated.

Deservedly so.

Would you like to elaborate?

"Castro, on the other hand, was convinced that an invasion of Cuba was soon at hand, and on October 26, he sent a telegram to Khrushchev that appeared to call for a pre-emptive nuclear strike on the USA." - Wikipedia, on the Cuban Missile Crisis

Re: Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

#33
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Anyone who gets in the way of government abuses is promoting peace in my opinion . In Snowden's case, he's released information about programs that are specifically abusing the privacy of the world's population . One hopes that such a release serves as an impetus to curb or prevent it in the future. I think that at least fits my criteria.

I'm sorry, I still don't see the link between "[curbing] government abuses" and "promoting peace". What is the link?

How about the fact that a young clever men with top salary, beautiful girlfriend and comfortable life in one of the (supposedly) most developed country in entire world couldn't stand his own government's abuse, and decided to break the silence, knowing (Bradley M?) that his life is over.

Is that good enough reason for you? How about this: he promoted the truth, because otherwise had he not done it, we could have ended in a North Korea type dictatorship.

Hats off to Mr. Snowden.

http://ih1.redbubble.net/image.14361929.4039/flat,550x550,07...

Re: Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

#34
post #4

I fail to see how what Snowden has done has promoted world peace. The Nobel Peace prize is not (recent awardees notwithstanding) a we-like-you prize. It's supposed to be about world peace , and I just don't see how Snowden has advanced that particular goal. Or am I just dense?

Weakening the global hegemon is certainly a contribution to world peace.

Historically, weakening hegemony has led to periods of strife, not peace.

Re: Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

#35
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Obama was awarded the Peace Prize prematurely. I've yet to see something he's done to deserve it, despite voting for him the first time.

That may be so, but let's keep in mind that there is no reason to criticize the President for being undeserving of the prize. It's not like he awarded it to himself.

It was awarded upon the rhetoric of hope he espoused, but failed to follow up with in action. But your statement is factually correct.

Re: Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Deservedly so.

Would you like to elaborate? "Castro, on the other hand, was convinced that an invasion of Cuba was soon at hand, and on October 26, he sent a telegram to Khrushchev that appeared to call for a pre-emptive nuclear strike on the USA." - Wikipedia, on the Cuban Missile Crisis

In the sense that, if they can give it to Henry Kissinger, the prize is therefore meaningless, and they might as well give it to Mugabe, or Castro, or Ríos Montt, or Reagan.

Re: Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

#37
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Obama was awarded the Peace Prize prematurely. I've yet to see something he's done to deserve it, despite voting for him the first time.

That may be so, but let's keep in mind that there is no reason to criticize the President for being undeserving of the prize. It's not like he awarded it to himself.

Perhaps he was criticizing the Nobel committee, not the president?

Re: Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

#38
post #3

the irony of a whistleblower trying to escape from the nobel-prize winning president of the United States being nominated for the nobel prize is, well pricelss.

Obama was awarded the Peace Prize prematurely. I've yet to see something he's done to deserve it, despite voting for him the first time.

besides ending the Iraq war, he's done a lot of stuff that is somewhat subtle. off the top of my head: a concerted and sustained nuclear arms reduction effort[1], and the specific way he handled the Libya situation[2].

still it remains that Obama is fundamentally pragmatic, for better or worse in any given issue.

[1] good report here: http://video.msnbc.msn.com/rachel-maddow/46790266#46790266

[2] http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/inside-obamas-war-...

Re: Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

#39
post #14
post #3

the irony of a whistleblower trying to escape from the nobel-prize winning president of the United States being nominated for the nobel prize is, well pricelss.

I don't really understand the nobel peace prize, or specifically why Obama was awarded it. I understand being the first black president of the United States is a big deal, but did he personally do anything to promote peace? Or does being black in the white house somehow lower racism, hence promoting world peace?

It was awarded, in part, I believe upon campaign rhetoric that was not followed though on. There is something to be said for the crowds that turned out for his first speech in Germany and his most recent. Actions matter.

Re: Edward Snowden nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

#40
post #14
post #3

the irony of a whistleblower trying to escape from the nobel-prize winning president of the United States being nominated for the nobel prize is, well pricelss.

I don't really understand the nobel peace prize, or specifically why Obama was awarded it. I understand being the first black president of the United States is a big deal, but did he personally do anything to promote peace? Or does being black in the white house somehow lower racism, hence promoting world peace?

He was awarded the prize in the hope of influencing him to actually promote peace in the future.

The idea was that accepting the peace prize would have led Obama to see himself as a Nobel peace prize winner, and thus as someone promoting peace, and that he thus would subconsciously actually try to promote peace to avoid the cognitive dissonance.

It didn't work as well as it could, but maybe it worked to some extent.

Post reply on HN