Live data from Hacker News

Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

popehat.com

31–40 of 59 posts

Re: Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

#31
post #15

Anytime someone uses the word "Creeper" it quickly identifies the person as a Millenial. It sounds passive-aggressive. The word is "Stalker" kids. A creeper is someone who creeps around at night.

So, the term for someone who behaves in a socially inappropriate and over-reaching way, but isn't literally stalking anyone is.... ?

Socially awkward? Unattractive?

Re: Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

#32

"creepy" is just a code word for "unattractive" or "awkward" i've been called hot, sexy, and creepy in the same hour span on a night out. speaking up in the conversation at the wrong time, or just having the wrong look on your face can be "creepy". staring off into space while thinking about code? watch out, you could be creeping someone out. overhear something and decide to but in with a "hey i think i know what you…

"creepy" is just a code word for "unattractive" or "awkward" In this context, it simply means being pushy and mumbling (or screaming) about sex and/or violence all the time. E.g. http://fatuglyorslutty.com/ i've been called hot, sexy, and creepy in the same hour span on a night out. Yes, and people have called making a lot of money "killing it" before, too, but that doesn't suddenly make murder okay. How's that for a…

Yes, and people have called making a lot of money "killing it" before, too, but that doesn't suddenly make murder okay. How's that for a simple exercise in logic.

That doesn't really follow.

What he meant was that some people experienced him as hot, some experienced him as sexy, and some experienced him as creepy. In other words, he was not objectively any one of those things - different people had different expectations and standards. He was more appealing to some people than others.

And this is perfectly normal. Not everyone gets along with everyone else.

Re: Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

#33
post #19
post #7

Because it is an attack on gender. Creepers and harassment are exceedingly rarely discussed in gender neutral ways- it is usually a man doing something to a woman, or sometimes a discussion of the reverse. It is not often both in a neutral way. Additionally, the behaviour are things that a lot of people still do. Whereas with racism, to use the author's example, might draw the same ire (and it does in certain cases)…

I'd also like to add that the word "creeper" should be kept out of these discussions. It seems obvious that sexism is very common in United States computer culture. But the word "creepy", when used to describe an undesirable man, is every bit as derogatory as "fattie" or "slut" when applied to a woman. It's the kind of word that is used for character assasination. As you say, it doesn't go well when you imply that ev…

The exact same behavior which would be met with disgust and derision at a tech conference, could be considered flirtatious and hot if it came in the right tone of voice from a hot guy at a nightclub.

Exactly! Context is so important. And something that would be experienced as "inappropriate" at a given moment might be the perfect thing to do half an hour later. It's all about making other people comfortable in your presence.

Re: Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

#34
I think it's because the group in question -- nerds, essentially -- are among the least sexually successful population of males. And, generalizing here, that's because in various ways, they typically don't understand other people in a relatable way. So, owing to not being able to understand women, they get rejected and they can't understand why -- it feels like a black box. This feels unfair, and creates a sense of victimization.

So to tell people who are (maybe understandably) bitter and resentful, who are feeling like rejects and victims, that their behavior is the problem -- well, that just feels spiteful and insulting. From the perspective of the nerds, women are arbitrary and cruel, so fuck them and what they think of us. Further, now that women are becoming integrated into parts of nerd culture, this feels like an encroachment into the territory which was previously able to provide a haven/escape from female rejection.

This, at least, is what my experience has been in talking with others. I don't think I personally ever felt this way, but I also have never identified strongly as a nerd either. I'm definitely generalizing heavily.

Re: Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

#35

This entire essay is about how other people perceive a certain thing in a more extreme matter than would be warranted by logic, but the author makes the mistake of using the same extremities in his essay, thus nullifying his own argument. (Did that make sense? If not, it basically means: he is saying "there are a lot of nutters who are angrily responding to discussions about creepers and harrassment", but he doesn't…

It's not the language that makes people nutters. They might have downvoted you for discounting the entire article for something that doesn't matter. Have you never seen the reactions the article is talking about?

I have seen a wide variety of reactions from people to this issue. They range from law-oriented, logic-oriented, or biologically-based viewpoints to exasperated "Damn, it, it was just an invitation to coffee!" types to completely illogical and counterproductive things like threats of violence.

My point is that the author here doesn't really say which of these he doesn't "get", but just blanket calls people who disagree with his viewpoint "nutters", and talks about "basement-stinking" reactions, and then claims that they are very common and says he doesn't get why. So he/she is really vague about the issue, and does not give any concrete data or opinions in the discourse relating to it.

EDIT: Another example, the last sentence of the article: "are these freaks going to keep jumping up and down on my lawn?" ← Do you think this is a measured, logical response by a person who is talking about responses to accusations of sexism etc. at tech conferences?

Re: Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

#36
I think it's because the men in the ensuing backlash put themselves in the place of the creeper and empathize with a feeling of persecution or believe the behavior to be misinterpreted by the author/experiencer. Most men won't feel intimidated or fear for their safety just by the unwanted presence of a woman, so it may be difficult for some to empathize with the opposite of this experience. Add on to this that, as humans, we judge others for their actions, but ourselves for our intent. Many men are not going to physically hurt women, and commenters that empathize with the creeper come to assessment that since they wouldn't hurt her, then she must have been over-reacting. (This fails to take into account that the woman in the situation doesn't at all know what the man she is intimidated by is going to do or what kind of harm he could cause her.) Add the stereotype of the regular nerd culture participant as being socially awkward and thus unaware of many rules regarding social interaction, and it's easy to paint a caricature of an unaware fool who was just misunderstood and is now being bullied for his awkwardness.

"Most men fear getting laughed at or humiliated by a romantic prospect while most women fear rape and death." -Gavin de Becker

Re: Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

#37

Anytime someone uses the word "Creeper" it quickly identifies the person as a Millenial. It sounds passive-aggressive. The word is "Stalker" kids. A creeper is someone who creeps around at night.

A creeper is someone you suspect of being a stalker.

No, really; that's pretty much it. Someone who calls you creepy is expressing a sincere worry that you won't take no for an answer. No more, no less.

Re: Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

#38

"creepy" is just a code word for "unattractive" or "awkward" i've been called hot, sexy, and creepy in the same hour span on a night out. speaking up in the conversation at the wrong time, or just having the wrong look on your face can be "creepy". staring off into space while thinking about code? watch out, you could be creeping someone out. overhear something and decide to but in with a "hey i think i know what you…

"creepy" is just a code word for "unattractive" or "awkward"

No, it's not — at least not necessarily, which seems to be your implication.

One can be awkward and not be a creeper. One can be unattractive and not be a creeper. One can be a creeper and be neither awkward nor unattractive. And, yes, one can be all three.

The difference between them tends, in my (male, second-hand) experience, to be one of persistence. Awkward doesn't always stick around long past the point where it's no longer welcome. Creepers, awkward or not — and unintentionally or not — do.

EDIT: phrasing.

Re: Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

#39
post #38

"creepy" is just a code word for "unattractive" or "awkward" i've been called hot, sexy, and creepy in the same hour span on a night out. speaking up in the conversation at the wrong time, or just having the wrong look on your face can be "creepy". staring off into space while thinking about code? watch out, you could be creeping someone out. overhear something and decide to but in with a "hey i think i know what you…

"creepy" is just a code word for "unattractive" or "awkward" No, it's not — at least not necessarily, which seems to be your implication. One can be awkward and not be a creeper. One can be unattractive and not be a creeper. One can be a creeper and be neither awkward nor unattractive. And, yes, one can be all three. The difference between them tends, in my (male, second-hand) experience, to be one of persistence. Aw…

>The difference between them tends, in my (male, second-hand) experience, to be one of persistence.

Woman: "If you're not listening to me now when I say no, how can I possibly trust you will listen later?"

Re: Why Does Talking About Creepers And Harassment Make People So Angry?

#40
post #38

"creepy" is just a code word for "unattractive" or "awkward" i've been called hot, sexy, and creepy in the same hour span on a night out. speaking up in the conversation at the wrong time, or just having the wrong look on your face can be "creepy". staring off into space while thinking about code? watch out, you could be creeping someone out. overhear something and decide to but in with a "hey i think i know what you…

"creepy" is just a code word for "unattractive" or "awkward" No, it's not — at least not necessarily, which seems to be your implication. One can be awkward and not be a creeper. One can be unattractive and not be a creeper. One can be a creeper and be neither awkward nor unattractive. And, yes, one can be all three. The difference between them tends, in my (male, second-hand) experience, to be one of persistence. Aw…

Actually, I'd argue that over the age of 25 or so, one can't be awkward and not be a creeper. If you're still oversexualizing every interaction with women like some 14-year-old, as evidenced by awkwardness, there is something deeply wrong.

So the theory goes, ay any rate.

Post reply on HN