Live data from Hacker News

All calls in the Netherlands are stored, indexed and searched for keywords

translate.google.com

31–40 of 56 posts

Re: All calls in the Netherlands are stored, indexed and searched for keywords

#31
post #21
post #2

I call bullshit. Phone metadata is saved since forever yes, but stored at ISPs, not at government organisations. There are strict regulations regarding the privacy of voice data over the phone (VoIP does not count as such though), and I don't think the secret service and military secret service (AIVD and MIVD) can do anything they like. They have more permissions, such as demanding passwords for encrypted files as lo…

more information on the CIOT http://ripe58.ripe.net/content/presentations/ciot.pdf it says 250k queries per month... kinda hard to get warrants for all of them i guess

Like I care how hard it is for them to get warrants. My question to them is why do you even need all this data in the first place?

Re: All calls in the Netherlands are stored, indexed and searched for keywords

#32

The newspaper that published this, 'Telegraaf', is notorious for publishing bullshit. The article is very short, the journalist wouldn't be able to check if it's true, and the newspaper hungry to publish anything that attracts readers. Offline version of link-bait.

Yes, I got the same notion

Re: All calls in the Netherlands are stored, indexed and searched for keywords

#33
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And a homegrown Islamist network assassinated a well-known dutch film director after he made a movie criticizing the treatment of women in Islam: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theo_van_Gogh_(film_director)

What? So you can have attacks on your country without requiring the world to go into lockdown, without having to invade several countries and without having to molest every traveler?

"without requiring the world to go into lockdown, without having to invade several countries and without having to molest every traveler?"

Have you ever been here? There are cameras on all highways that recognize license plates and track the movement over every car on the road network (cfr: the ease with which they tracked the whereabouts of the father who killed his children a few weeks ago), it has the most phone taps per inhabitant (to the extent that if you look at the data, it seems like somebody accidentally types a few numbers too much when typing it into Excel, that's how far we are removed from the runner up), and in general the amount of information the government has on every citizen is staggering (e.g. the age at which you first grew pubes (!) ).

At Schiphol you are searched at will - a few years ago I was on a flight back from the Caribbean and everybody on the plane was searched - thoroughly, more intense than when you are searched e.g. at sports events. Every city has autonomous authority to designate certain areas as 'search at will' areas - police can (and will), without cause, search you and your belongings (including your car - US doctrine about the car being an extension of a man's house? Hahaha, yeah, in the sense that it doesn't take much to search your house, either...). Most train stations are such zones, but most of the city centers of the bigger cities are, too (let that sink in - there a whole city center where police, without any cause, can search you and your belongings!)

Oh, not carrying ID (anywhere)? €90 fine, and you can be taken into custody until you have proven your identity. No cause necessary for asking for it, either.

Invading has never been a strategy generally employed here, the Dutch are merchants, war is bad for business (I'm sure there's a fitting Ferengi quote here...) Plus a country the size of a flyspeck on a global map just doesn't generally have the muscle.

Look, I still love my country, and for all its flaws it's still the best place on earth to live for me - but let's not kid ourselves, the surveillance state is alive and kicking here, and the 'OMG the terrorists are coming' sentiment is, too.

Re: All calls in the Netherlands are stored, indexed and searched for keywords

#34
post #24
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree this is a bullshit story. They only store conversations when they have an eavesdrop approval. A lot of people underestimate the amount of storage it would take to store all voice data.

Storing voice (audio) data is not what the article says. I'd imagine you transcribe the audio to text and search in that. Storing text is incredibly easy. Besides you can throw away 99.9% of the data almost immediately. I'm actually curious how much text data this would be per day; number of call minutes * average number of words per minute. I'd be surprised if that wouldn't fit in a reasonable cluster.

I'm sorry, but do we really think that machine transcription of millions of cell phone conversations is worth anything? How can anyone believe that after using google voice?

Re: All calls in the Netherlands are stored, indexed and searched for keywords

#35
post #28
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> without having to molest every traveler Schiphol is organised better than most comparable airports, and it has improved dramatically in the last 5 years, but the level of actual harassment can still be quite high (seems to vary by day).

It's probably the most harassing airport in Europe. I haven't been to all airports but I've been to many (>50) and Shiphol was the worst. Still better than the US though, if you're an EU citizen at least.

Maybe my POV is skewed by having MAN as home airport - security here is horrendous, slow, invasive and obsessed with trying every new braindead security scheme under the sun, including the infamous pornscanners.

Schiphol was not that bad the few times I've used it (last three weeks ago), IIRC they do the actual scan at gates which I think is always the superior option.

Completely agree on the EU/US comparison, of course. You can actually see how European aviation has now fully caught up and often surpassed its US counterpart -- US infrastructure looks old and creaky, often not fit for purpose, and thanks to TSA it now feels more like a series of gulags than a 3rd-millennium transportation network.

Re: All calls in the Netherlands are stored, indexed and searched for keywords

#36
post #31
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

more information on the CIOT http://ripe58.ripe.net/content/presentations/ciot.pdf it says 250k queries per month... kinda hard to get warrants for all of them i guess

Like I care how hard it is for them to get warrants. My question to them is why do you even need all this data in the first place ?

I think that is the question we all would like an answer to, but we don't all draw your conclusion from it (that if they don't need it they won't collect it).

We have a public transport system here that functioned just fine using anonymous cards, and it got replaced by one that allows near perfect tracking of every individual using public transport. Why anybody would want to is a good question, but it is the system we've got and the data is being kept.

Re: All calls in the Netherlands are stored, indexed and searched for keywords

#39
post #2

I call bullshit. Phone metadata is saved since forever yes, but stored at ISPs, not at government organisations. There are strict regulations regarding the privacy of voice data over the phone (VoIP does not count as such though), and I don't think the secret service and military secret service (AIVD and MIVD) can do anything they like. They have more permissions, such as demanding passwords for encrypted files as lo…

Also all telecom companies must provide to CIOT all new and updated registered customer buying MSISDN's. If it is postpaid, all details including address, full name and D.O.B is given, prepaid also, but that can depend on how the customer has purchased the SIM.

Anyhow, why does it matter that much. If you have something to hide, then I'd be sweating. If not, who really gives a sh*te if people are tapping into our digital lives.

Facebook, Google and rest are just as bad as the governments. They are invading us with advertisements in all parts of our digital life.

If people are worried about it, turn your crap off.

Re: All calls in the Netherlands are stored, indexed and searched for keywords

#40
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Storing voice (audio) data is not what the article says. I'd imagine you transcribe the audio to text and search in that. Storing text is incredibly easy. Besides you can throw away 99.9% of the data almost immediately. I'm actually curious how much text data this would be per day; number of call minutes * average number of words per minute. I'd be surprised if that wouldn't fit in a reasonable cluster.

I'm sorry, but do we really think that machine transcription of millions of cell phone conversations is worth anything? How can anyone believe that after using google voice?

[deleted]
Post reply on HN