Live data from Hacker News

3 In 10 Americans Will Not Knowingly Buy Chinese-Owned Brands

hdtradeservices.com

31–40 of 65 posts

Re: 3 In 10 Americans Will Not Knowingly Buy Chinese-Owned Brands

#31
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's a difference between a Chinese-owned brand and a Chinese-made product. I think most Americans are fine buying Chinese-made goods but Chinese brands are seen as being of inferior quality.

As if Chinese made goods are not perceived as inferior. Claims are just claims after all.

In China, Chinese brands are considered inferior to western ones, even if everything is made here. They compete on price alone mostly.

Re: 3 In 10 Americans Will Not Knowingly Buy Chinese-Owned Brands

#32
post #17
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because I'd rather support the economy of Wisconsin than the economy of Chengdu. I like people in Wisconsin, can't really relate to people in Chengdu, and then there is the whole militarily adverse repressive communist regime thing. Beyond that, I have no desire to contribute to the externalization of pollution, health and safety risks, etc, that come from exporting production overseas. I think globalization is utter…

> I like people in Wisconsin, can't really relate to people in Chengdu, ?? They're just people.

People in Wisconsin are people I might meet. People in Chengdu are people I will never meet.

Re: 3 In 10 Americans Will Not Knowingly Buy Chinese-Owned Brands

#33
There are some things I will not buy if they're made in some countries, of which China is just one. There are other things that I don't care where in the world they were produced.

There's a definite relationship between the length of time I expect to own or use a product, the country's reputation for products of that type, and which of the two categories it falls in.

Re: 3 In 10 Americans Will Not Knowingly Buy Chinese-Owned Brands

#34
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It would be great if most of the products being sold are made in your home country Why?

Because I'd rather support the economy of Wisconsin than the economy of Chengdu. I like people in Wisconsin, can't really relate to people in Chengdu, and then there is the whole militarily adverse repressive communist regime thing. Beyond that, I have no desire to contribute to the externalization of pollution, health and safety risks, etc, that come from exporting production overseas. I think globalization is utter…

> I like people in Wisconsin, can't really relate to people in Chengdu, and then there is the whole militarily adverse repressive communist regime thing.

Think about the cute pandas.

> I'm happy to pay a little more

The problem is that its not just a "little more." I remember the 80s before China became a manufacturing powerhouse, and many things just got so much cheaper in the 90s.

Re: 3 In 10 Americans Will Not Knowingly Buy Chinese-Owned Brands

#36
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It would be great if most of the products being sold are made in your home country Why?

Because I'd rather support the economy of Wisconsin than the economy of Chengdu. I like people in Wisconsin, can't really relate to people in Chengdu, and then there is the whole militarily adverse repressive communist regime thing. Beyond that, I have no desire to contribute to the externalization of pollution, health and safety risks, etc, that come from exporting production overseas. I think globalization is utter…

I like people in Wisconsin, can't really relate to people in Chengdu

The people in Wisconsin will be better off if they produce something at which their comparative advantage is the highest. You'd harm them, as well yourself and the Chinese people, by shifting the allocation of resources slightly away from optimal for all these parties.

Re: 3 In 10 Americans Will Not Knowingly Buy Chinese-Owned Brands

#37
post #33

There are some things I will not buy if they're made in some countries, of which China is just one. There are other things that I don't care where in the world they were produced. There's a definite relationship between the length of time I expect to own or use a product, the country's reputation for products of that type, and which of the two categories it falls in.

I feel the same way. You can infer quality by the packaging (and country of manufacture) in some cases, but other times it's a tossup between Chinese, Indian, U.S. or wherever else. The safest bet it is to limit purchases by reputation for that particular type of item depending on cost and lifetime.

Re: 3 In 10 Americans Will Not Knowingly Buy Chinese-Owned Brands

#38
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because I'd rather support the economy of Wisconsin than the economy of Chengdu. I like people in Wisconsin, can't really relate to people in Chengdu, and then there is the whole militarily adverse repressive communist regime thing. Beyond that, I have no desire to contribute to the externalization of pollution, health and safety risks, etc, that come from exporting production overseas. I think globalization is utter…

China is far more capitalist than US! There's not a hint of communism left in modern china, it's just a different kind of democracy than US.

China is a debunking of the idea that you need either free markets or political freedom to have an effective economy. It's still a tightly planned economy where the state either has a heavy involvement with or outright owns key industries. And politically, it's not a "democracy" in any sense of the word.

Re: 3 In 10 Americans Will Not Knowingly Buy Chinese-Owned Brands

#39
post #2

3 In 10 Americans claim they Will Not Knowingly Buy Chinese-Owned Brands I suspect the reality is wildly different to the survey result - after all, "made in China" is hardly a secret.

from the same website as the article: 94% of Americans Cannot Name One Chinese Brand. https://www.hdtradeservices.com/blog/Ninety+Four+Percent+of+...

So apparently, there aren't any Chinese companies making a point of telling people they are Chinese, and US consumers don't care enough to look for the "Made in ..." notice.

Post reply on HN